Aller au contenu

Photo

Blackwall Discussion Thread -- The Resolve! [Voiced by Alastair Parker]


14909 réponses à ce sujet

#11951
KealaFerret

KealaFerret
  • Members
  • 419 messages

I know I have to have senoirity in this (I have to be the oldest, have to be!). Everyone in line behind me!  MOVE IT! :lol:

 

I have to tell a secret.  *looks around* Shh.  I made an elf.  To romance Solas.  Um...it didn't work.  Guess who I'm with.......that's right.  Blackwall <3 :wub:  Better luck next time?  Probably not :lol:

 

Edit:  Maybe I can reload? *sigh*

Stuff like this is why I made a dudeQuisitor this time around. :D


  • Kaidan Fan et veeia aiment ceci

#11952
MrsHairyMcLummox

MrsHairyMcLummox
  • Members
  • 273 messages

Maker's balls... that director's cut sex scene  tumblr_m7wusejA2Z1r17mw1.gif

 

I reblogged the Blackwall-bash comic a while ago on tumblr, giggling because my reaction was exaxtly the same   :lol:


  • AtreiyaN7 et Catwall aiment ceci

#11953
alialias

alialias
  • Members
  • 101 messages

Oh yes Harrison Ford!  I'm pretty sure he was my first crush.

 

I also created a Lavellan last night!  I am not sure who she will romance yet - my very first character was a Lavellan who had the first two romance scenes with Solas.  However I accidentally let her clan died and still felt guilty about not saving anyone at Haven so I restarted with my Trevelyan who I planned to romance Cullen with.  Well, that didn't happen.

 

Also, kind of appropriate given the discussion on writing, I saw this today: http://well.blogs.ny...to-happiness/. After writing for myself for the first time in years I can attest to how great it feels.  I used to write stories as a kid all the time, so I'm really grateful I stumbled upon this group.


  • Sabreenei et MrsHairyMcLummox aiment ceci

#11954
Catwall

Catwall
  • Members
  • 550 messages

A new thread about Blackwall has popped up, from someone who is sympathetic to him. Is it bad that amidst all of the srs bsns arguing about the Inquisition's reputation and moral posturing that's going on in there, I just want to run in and shout "RIDE THE BEARD!" and then run the hell back out?


  • mordy_was_here, Ryzaki, Bugsie et 8 autres aiment ceci

#11955
AtreiyaN7

AtreiyaN7
  • Members
  • 8 399 messages

One thing I never understood about Blackwall is, How does a Free Marcher come to be a captain within the Orlesian Millitary?


It does say in the codex (I think) that Blackwall retained a certain level of fame for winning the Grand Tourney, so when he came back penniless two years later, he was basically able to capitalize on his reputation and join the Orlesian military. His subsequent advancement was based on skill as far as I know.
  • Sabreenei et MrsHairyMcLummox aiment ceci

#11956
Rosalee_TAL

Rosalee_TAL
  • Members
  • 62 messages

A new thread about Blackwall has popped up, from someone who is sympathetic to him. Is it bad that amidst all of the srs bsns arguing about the Inquisition's reputation and moral posturing that's going on in there, I just want to run in and shout "RIDE THE BEARD!" and then run the hell back out?

 

Do eeet! And use this gif:

 

tumblr_md6twxnLra1qclb0e.gif


  • mordy_was_here, AtreiyaN7, Catwall et 6 autres aiment ceci

#11957
Catwall

Catwall
  • Members
  • 550 messages

LMAO! OMG Rosalee, I am laughing so hard right now that I nearly made a mess of my breakfast! Thank you!


  • Bugsie, Kaidan Fan, Sabreenei et 2 autres aiment ceci

#11958
MrsHairyMcLummox

MrsHairyMcLummox
  • Members
  • 273 messages

A new thread about Blackwall has popped up, from someone who is sympathetic to him. Is it bad that amidst all of the srs bsns arguing about the Inquisition's reputation and moral posturing that's going on in there, I just want to run in and shout "RIDE THE BEARD!" and then run the hell back out?

 

do it! xD

 

dammit I saw Rosalee's gif only now, do eet with gif :D



#11959
Gilsa

Gilsa
  • Members
  • 5 828 messages

Speaking strictly from my "canon" world state, I would say that I'd pick Blackwall over Alistair for maturity reasons. Alistair has fantastic wit and can make me laugh all day, but he walked out at Landsmeet for his own reasons (understandable, no issues with the why of it). In that world, he went on to be a drunk and I don't know what happened after Teagan took him home. I keep hoping he'd turn it around. Blackwall hit rock bottom and made an effort to claw his way out. He is not a drama queen and prefers bluntness. I feel like any squabbles, disagreements, fights, whatever with Blackwall would be resolved with a frank discussion and that he'd love the Inquisitor no less. Alistair was more prone to being argumentative. Two different games, two different approaches, and Alistair is plot blocked so his character development can't really go any further, totally get that. I still miss Alistair -- he's the man that got away! ;)

 

If Alistair never left, oooh boy, couldn't ask me to pick either, probably!


  • KealaFerret, AtreiyaN7, Kaidan Fan et 2 autres aiment ceci

#11960
AtreiyaN7

AtreiyaN7
  • Members
  • 8 399 messages

@rosa: Oooh, an Aragorn gif - what an excellent suggestion. I'd give your post a Like, but I Just ran out of them earlier (which is entirely Harrison Ford's fault).

 

EDIT: Woohoo, more Likes! *proceeds to Like that Aragorn gif a billion times* Okay...maybe not that many times.



#11961
alialias

alialias
  • Members
  • 101 messages
I tend to romanticize Alistair in my mind because he was my first pixel crush but you are so right about being argumentative. His storming out was pretty ridiculous.

That said I think he would have eventually pulled himself together. I wonder if there is any mention of him in Inqusition if he had been a drunk in the world state.

Also love that Aragorn gif. I think the next game should have an LI modeled on him.
  • Gilsa aime ceci

#11962
Gilsa

Gilsa
  • Members
  • 5 828 messages

No mention of drunk Alistair in DAI. I thought maybe I missed it, but veeia confirmed it to me since she had the same world state as well.



#11963
Kaidan Fan

Kaidan Fan
  • Members
  • 2 556 messages

I actually played Mass Effect before Dragon Age so Kaidan was my first pixel crush, but I fell hard for Alistair.  Oh my.  And I lucked out at the end I guess because he didn't walk out on me.  Probably because I wanted Loghain dead as much as he did.  I was an elf mage so I didn't get to be his bride, but we got rid of Anora and I stayed as his mistress.  That was my first, bumble play through.  I knew nothing and was completely unspoiled so I guess I did okay getting that ending :lol:

 

Blackwall is a much more mature romance.  But man, he can do the silly, raunchy jokes.  And I love him for it.

 

So a friend tells me I have to deny Blackwall before I can progress the Solas romance.  I think I may just dump this play through.  I can't dump Blackwall........:crying:


  • AtreiyaN7, Catwall et MrsHairyMcLummox aiment ceci

#11964
Kaidan Fan

Kaidan Fan
  • Members
  • 2 556 messages

Stuff like this is why I made a dudeQuisitor this time around. :D

I've done one manquisitor.  He romanced Cass.  Totally worth it.


  • MrsHairyMcLummox aime ceci

#11965
MrsHairyMcLummox

MrsHairyMcLummox
  • Members
  • 273 messages

Scientific studies indicate that women who like Harrison Ford have a natural tendency to like also Blackwall :D


  • Kaidan Fan, Sabreenei et Rosalee_TAL aiment ceci

#11966
Gilsa

Gilsa
  • Members
  • 5 828 messages

I wanted to hear more of what Riordian had to say about Loghain's usefulness and I was a dummy and thought if we conscripted Loghain, we'd also gain the army he had at Ostagaar along with the three treaties. I didn't realize I was merely trading one man for another. I kept thinking Alistair would come back, but by the time I realized it was a done deal, I had no saves to go back to. I had been overwriting the same save file as I progressed. I also turned down Morrigan's ritual for dwarven reasons and she left me. Man, I was pouting at the end of that game, let me tell you. I was mad enough to give the game back to my husband and tell him I was done with it. (A week later, I decided to try again. =p)

 

But that is how I picked up Mass Effect. There was a thread comparing Alistair with Kaidan and someone said that Kaidan would stay to the end. That was all I need to hear! =p


  • AtreiyaN7, Kaidan Fan et Sabreenei aiment ceci

#11967
Kaidan Fan

Kaidan Fan
  • Members
  • 2 556 messages

I read the new Blackwall bashing thread.  I was going to post ride the beard and the gif, but I'm afraid I'll get reported  :(

 

<---Big, fat chicken.



#11968
AtreiyaN7

AtreiyaN7
  • Members
  • 8 399 messages

@kaidan: Well, technically it's a support thread, but I fully expected the bashing. I said what I had to say in there, sans any gifs (alas).



#11969
Catwall

Catwall
  • Members
  • 550 messages

I read the new Blackwall bashing thread.  I was going to post ride the beard and the gif, but I'm afraid I'll get reported  :(

 

<---Big, fat chicken.

The day is young, friend, and I may still do it if that thread reaches peak armchair ethicist wankery. But then again, I am about to head into Wicked Eyes and Wicked Hearts, which kind of exhausts me.


  • AtreiyaN7 et Kaidan Fan aiment ceci

#11970
Gilsa

Gilsa
  • Members
  • 5 828 messages

I actually played Mass Effect before Dragon Age so Kaidan was my first pixel crush, but I fell hard for Alistair.  Oh my.  And I lucked out at the end I guess because he didn't walk out on me.  Probably because I wanted Loghain dead as much as he did.  I was an elf mage so I didn't get to be his bride, but we got rid of Anora and I stayed as his mistress.  That was my first, bumble play through.  I knew nothing and was completely unspoiled so I guess I did okay getting that ending :lol:

 

Blackwall is a much more mature romance.  But man, he can do the silly, raunchy jokes.  And I love him for it.

 

So a friend tells me I have to deny Blackwall before I can progress the Solas romance.  I think I may just dump this play through.  I can't dump Blackwall........ :crying:

 

Oh! That reminds me! I remembered reading on Gaider's blog that they had intended for non-humans to be able to get engaged to King Alistair, but with negative reactions from everyone. I thought that was interesting. I had always wondered if being married to the sister of the dwarven king would be seen as a political advantage. Anyway, Gaider is deleting his tumblr blog on Friday so if there's anything of his you wanted to save, best grab it before then.


  • MrsHairyMcLummox aime ceci

#11971
Kaidan Fan

Kaidan Fan
  • Members
  • 2 556 messages

Oh! That reminds me! I remembered reading on Gaider's blog that they had intended for non-humans to be able to get engaged to King Alistair, but with negative reactions from everyone. I thought that was interesting. I had always wondered if being married to the sister of the dwarven king would be seen as a political advantage. Anyway, Gaider is deleting his tumblr blog on Friday so if there's anything of his you wanted to save, best grab it before then.

I did not know that!  About other races marrying Alistair or about Mr. Gaiders tumblr.  But I don't visit often so I probably missed it.  That's sad  :(  He had some pretty interesting stuff to say about making games and writing and such.

 

@Catwall:  That quest always makes me anxious.  I'm a nervous wreck until I finish it :lol:

 

Edit: @Sabreenei: I use Shadowplay too and then I use microsoft movie maker to save them in HD and it makes them take up MUCH less room and I delete the Shadowplay video.  So they still look nice.  I have some videos up and you can see they quality is still good  :)


  • Catwall et Sabreenei aiment ceci

#11972
Catwall

Catwall
  • Members
  • 550 messages
@Catwall:  That quest always makes me anxious.  I'm a nervous wreck until I finish it :lol:

Oh goodness me too, and the anxiety is compounded because I know a pivotal Blackwall moment is coming up. So then I get to choose: a literal roll in the hay (pushy-kissy Blackwall is my weakness) or "let's spend time with friends." I'm leaning toward the latter, because that seems more in character for their particular dynamic. Either way, Lorna's about to go through hell, and I'm so sad for her, in a delicious drama kind of way. :D


  • AtreiyaN7, Kaidan Fan, veeia et 2 autres aiment ceci

#11973
Sabreenei

Sabreenei
  • Members
  • 488 messages

re: Alistair or Blackwall - it depends on their ages!

 

If I had to choose young Alistair over older Blackwall, it would totally be Blackwall.

If it was older Alistair (like King Alistair here, I haven't seen him as Warden yet) ,vs older Blackwall... eiiii, I don't know. So hard to say! Alistair has a slight edge, because I fell for his character first and he has so many cutscenes that made me fall for him. But then, Blackwall... unnnf. Hard to say.

If it were old or young Alistair vs the young Blackwall, it would be Alistair.

 

I lucked out in my first DAO playthrough, since i started as a Cousland. I've never had Alistair as a drunk,  though I did play through it once just to see the scene. Never again or for real, it hurt my heart too much. (<--- is a pushover for videogame characters feelings) I'd started a fic about it, that never went anywhere. I'm so awful at finishing fics, I'm a bad, bad person. Plus, it was pre-DA2. I liked DA2, but it ruined all my stories!

 

While in the Alistair thread people kept talking about Mass Effect & Kaidan, and I was like, another game similar to DAO?? With fighting, plot & love interests?? I'm in! And of course, fell for Kaidan.

 

<3 Aragorn. I have a thing for the men of Middle Earth, but especially Aragorn. I love that gif. And It should be used!! Yesssss. I also love the one of him opening the doors and sweeping in majestically, with the caption, "I'm here for your women." or something like that. I can't find it at the moment. Someday I'll organize my gifs.

 

Edit: @Kaidan: Thank you! I was thinking of trying out the microsoft movie maker. I want to edit some together. I'd been using vdub to make my fraps videos smaller, but only for upload purposes. I never got rid of the original. With the quality the same, I'll definitely have to do that!!


  • Kaidan Fan et MrsHairyMcLummox aiment ceci

#11974
Kaidan Fan

Kaidan Fan
  • Members
  • 2 556 messages


Oh goodness me too, and the anxiety is compounded because I know a pivotal Blackwall moment is coming up. So then I get to choose: a literal roll in the hay (pushy-kissy Blackwall is my weakness) or "let's spend time with friends." I'm leaning toward the latter, because that seems more in character for their particular dynamic. Either way, Lorna's about to go through hell, and I'm so sad for her, in a delicious drama kind of way. :D

I'm weak.  I always go for the hay roll.  Not even sorry! :lol:

 



re: Alistair or Blackwall - it depends on their ages!

 

If I had to choose young Alistair over older Blackwall, it would totally be Blackwall.

If it was older Alistair (like King Alistair here, I haven't seen him as Warden yet) ,vs older Blackwall... eiiii, I don't know. So hard to say! Alistair has a slight edge, because I fell for his character first and he has so many cutscenes that made me fall for him. But then, Blackwall... unnnf. Hard to say.

If it were old or young Alistair vs the young Blackwall, it would be Alistair.

 

I lucked out in my first DAO playthrough, since i started as a Cousland. I've never had Alistair as a drunk,  though I did play through it once just to see the scene. Never again or for real, it hurt my heart too much. (<--- is a pushover for videogame characters feelings) I'd started a fic about it, that never went anywhere. I'm so awful at finishing fics, I'm a bad, bad person. Plus, it was pre-DA2. I liked DA2, but it ruined all my stories!

 

While in the Alistair thread people kept talking about Mass Effect & Kaidan, and I was like, another game similar to DAO?? With fighting, plot & love interests?? I'm in! And of course, fell for Kaidan.

 

<3 Aragorn. I have a thing for the men of Middle Earth, but especially Aragorn. I love that gif. And It should be used!! Yesssss. I also love the one of him opening the doors and sweeping in majestically, with the caption, "I'm here for your women." or something like that. I can't find it at the moment. Someday I'll organize my gifs.

 

Edit: @Kaidan: Thank you! I was thinking of trying out the microsoft movie maker. I want to edit some together. I'd been using vdub to make my fraps videos smaller, but only for upload purposes. I never got rid of the original. With the quality the same, I'll definitely have to do that!!

I LOVE Warden Alistair.  The choice between him and Hawke was a no brainer for me.  This is what brought up the choice question from my youngest daughter the other day.  If it had been Blackwall or Alistair.  I couldn't have made that choice.  I was have unistalled the game and pretended it didn't exist!  :lol:

 

I like the movie maker.  I'm still learning it, but it comes in handy.  I used it with fraps too.  Which I'm sad I paid for and didn't bother to reinstall on this computer because it always cut down the performance of my games and Shadowplay is so much better!

 

P.S  My canon is my Cousland pt that marries Alistair, btw.  <3


  • Sabreenei et MrsHairyMcLummox aiment ceci

#11975
Bugsie

Bugsie
  • Members
  • 3 609 messages
So yesterday I heard about the Mark Kennedy case in the UK, and geez it reminded me a bit of the some of the ethics and arguments surrounding Blackwall's story arc.

It wouldn't surprise me if some of the inspiration for Blackwall came from that case!