Last Resort of Good Men bug
So I came across this bug today. I spoke to Dorian, did the war table missions, and killed all three Venatori, got back to skyhold thinking I'm gonna get things started and bam, no Mother Giselle.
I tried reloading, nothing, went back to a save just before talking to Dorian to see if I may have clicked something wrong, nope. Went to talk to Giselle, nope. lol! Then I thought, what did I do differently in this playthrough that I've never done before. I got it.
I talked to Hawke at Skyhold before doing Dorian's war table and Venatori stuff. Actually, this was the very first time I've spoken to Hawke right when I first arrive at Skyhold. I usually save him for later when I've done Inner circle stuff and taken over a keep or something. I spoke to Hawke, got the cut scenes between Varric and Cass, Talked to Varric with more cut scenes et al. Perhaps it isn't talking to Hawke that does it, it could be any number of those cut scenes that come afterwards. idk
All I know is that I went back to an early save when I first reach skyhold (after talking to Blackwall on the battlements). I ignored Varric and went straight to talking to Dorian (had to recruit him because I picked the Templars) then to the wartable and did all three of Dorian's missions, then took him out and killed 2 of the Venatori in the Hinterlands, came back to skyhold, got cut scene about Felix (I don't think I got it at all before), and bam there is Mother Giselle waiting for me. lol!
I don't know if anyone pinpointed the issue yet or can confirm if talking to Hawke is the problem. I just wanted to share just in case anyone comes across the bug still.