Thanks for the additional insight into Halward's character; I only have in game info about the family. I'm still not sure I wouldn't classify Halward as an abuser due to his manipulative nature which falls into emotional abuse territory and near physical assault with the blood magic which falls under physical abuse. His disrespect of boundaries by deceiving Dorian into seeing him are also controlling and manipulative behaviors; both behaviors fall under the emotional abuse category. He and his father may very well love each other and even gotten along better in the past but that doesn't mean all of these most recent actions aren't abusive.
Relationships are complicated especially parental relationships. I've spent time in therapy dealing with the aftermath of a mentally ill mother that was physically and emotionally abusive so I'm probably extra sensitive to the signs. Or perhaps I read too much of my own situation into what is going on. Dorian obviously still loves his father and wants his approval but he's so young. Again, that parallels my own experience. My mom had terminal cancer while I was in college and I helped care for her. In her last few days while she was doped up to the point of not being able to talk I said my final goodbyes. I begged for her forgiveness for being such a horrible daughter and causing her behavior toward me. She didn't respond but squeezed my hand when I asked if she needed more pain medicine. I was too young at that point and still too caught up in the abusive cycle to even call her previous behavior abuse. It took therapy to name her behavior for what it was and understand that I wasn't a horrible daughter. That's why it's so hard for me to stroll in and make these decisions for Dorian. The situation is too complicated and nuanced for anyone to get a good read in the 5 minutes that we know Dorian.
I guess I'm really getting much closer to my discomfort with the whole situation. I didn't realize all of this was going through my head when I started typing. Think I'll go have a cry, hug my hubby and pups and be grateful for the love I have in my life now.
Honestly, imo relationships between parents and children are some of the most fraught and complicated ones we experience, even when they are really good and healthy. There are just so many layers to everything and often issues stem through the generations. I have some personal experience about how a parent can make horrific choices out of love, but I think because at this point I have a healthy relationship with my mom I often do take a more forgiving view of Halward. Part of what BioWare does really well is to tell stories which touch people emotionally and our feelings on these things can't help but be informed by our personal experiences in real life. It's why there is such a wide breadth in how people react to these things. People's reactions to this quest in particular are fascinating. Personal experience informs even when the person experiencing it isn't aware of it.
Anywho, that's a lot of words to say I understand on a basic level how you feel about it and why you view it how you do ![]()
If you encouraged them to speak, Dorian says, "I only saw him a handful of times while I was home. He never said anything about keeping me as his heir."
The lines above about seeing his (drunk) mother only seem to trigger if he went home for the 2 years rather than the month or two, but I got the 'handful of times' line from a Dorian who'd been gone a month. I think when he's been gone 2 years and was encouraged to speak to Halward, he says something along the lines of "I went home - twice. Father was only there once. Mother was drunk both times."
Oh! Thanks, I was just wondering why I never got that line about seeing his mother drunk. That makes a lot of sense ![]()
Do you feel it is a pity that you have to buy a source book to get the full picture about Dorian? I mean it is obvious from the biography in WoT2 that the problems with his family started back in his childhood, so had been going on and off for around twenty years before the final straw with the blood magic. It is also clear that Dorian wouldn't be the person he is today but for Alexius.
I wish they could put everything in the game, but honestly there's so much depth to everything it's not really possible and it would really water stuff down. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if most people wouldn't care ![]()
About when the family issues started... honestly I think the issues started from the moment Halward and (damn I forgot her name) got married. I mean I suppose it's possible they liked each other at some point but it seems unlikely. Also this is probably a great example of familial problems spanning generations.





Retour en haut









