1038 réponses à ce sujet

[Hydromatic]

damn i  really do not like Cullen and Leliana for many reasons from DAO and i very sure that i do not want them expecially Cullen(i think that this is a joke) as my or anyone advisors for any stuff in Thedas exept only i would wanted them as advisors for my enemy's and i know that they are the worst advisors ever

 

as for "Scribbles" i am sure that this is Isabella and if this is really her i do not want her too as if it was Zevran)))

 

i hope that we will have advisors and companions and Inquisition soldiers according to our decisions and choosing factions...if i choose mages i do not want to have Templars/Seekers and Orlais Chantry members by my side...and those with Grey Wardens, dalish, dwarfs, Tal-Vashoth and all other groups what we would have

 

Huh?

[Asdrubael Vect]

Besides it making no sense why Isabela would be the adviser for commerce and politics, she could be a Qunari prisoner for some players.

 unfortunately it was in DA2 that she is stole the book again after some days if you give her to Arishok and she was with Alister and Varric in comics, so yeah i think that this is her like we must have Leliana what many people killed

[SomberXIII]

Isabela? As an advisor for commerce! OMG. This is da best joke of the day!

[Lorien19]

Isabela? As an advisor for commerce! OMG. This is da best joke of the day!

Ikr?I love her to pieces...But no!

[Ye Elder Geeke]

Ikr?I love her to pieces...But no!

 

Yeah, set the fox to guard the chickens. "What could possibly go wrong?"

[Chanda]

Well, Leliana was confirmed to be the head of the espionage part which leaves military and poltical/commerce. We know Cullen is in the game and not as a companion, and it wouldn't make much sense to put him in charge of the financial/political part so he is with the military part. That leaves politics and economy up to Scribbles.

 

But has it been confirmed that Cullen is an advisor and not a companion? By the devs?

[Nocte ad Mortem]

But has it been confirmed that Cullen is an advisor and not a companion? By the devs?

It hasn't been confirmed. It's just that there's a massive amount of evidence that he isn't a companion. The devs have been very deliberate about not confirming or denying he is a companion, though.   

[Chanda]

It hasn't been confirmed. It's just that there's a massive amount of evidence that he isn't a companion. The devs have been very deliberate about not confirming or denying he is a companion, though.   

 

That's why I wanted to know if it was confirmed or not. Everyone (including myself) is assuming that Cullen is an NPC advisor that will stay at the home base, but that's a lot of assumption, and assumptions could be wrong.

[The Elder King]

unfortunately it was in DA2 that she is stole the book again after some days if you give her to Arishok and she was with Alister and Varric in comics, so yeah i think that this is her like we must have Leliana what many people killed

Other than the fact that it makes absolutely no sense for Isabela to be our finita ciao and/or political advisor (and the third pillar of the Inquisition was described as political), the only think in common between Isabela and that character in the trailer is the skin colour. And that it's not nearly enough to state that she's Isabela.

That's why I wanted to know if it was confirmed or not. Everyone (including myself) is assuming that Cullen is an NPC advisor that will stay at the home base, but that's a lot of assumption, and assumptions could be wrong.

Assumptions can be wrong Indeed, and it's better to keep an open mind. But there are really low chances the Cullen is a companion. Leliana isn't and she doesn't have a weapon in the trailer, as the other two rumoured advisors.

[The Elder King]

Oh, and the fact that Isabela was in the comics holds no relevance here. The comics followed a particular universe, where Alistair is king. He could very well be a Warden, a drunkard or dead.

[stuffystuffs]

Isabela? As an advisor for commerce! OMG. This is da best joke of the day!

 

She's skilled at acquiring goods for really cheap prices...even for free!

 

Politics?  Sure, why not.  Isabela's been to loads of different countries 

[Feryx]

Oh, and the fact that Isabela was in the comics holds no relevance here. The comics followed a particular universe, where Alistair is king. He could very well be a Warden, a drunkard or dead.

Official cannon is that Ali is king though, so who knows.

[The Elder King]

Official cannon is that Ali is king though, so who knows.

He's king in the comics and books' universe, yes. This doesn't mean he's everytime. We would be able to choose that in the Keep, as we did in the game. They already stated (even this year) that the OGB isn't canon and it'd be based on our choices. I don't see why the Alistair choice should be treated different.

[ChaosMorning]

Yeah. I imagine that, while the events of Asunder, the Masked Empire, the Last Flight, and The Silent Grove, Those Who Speak, and, Until We Speak, follow Bioware's canon, the events unfold regardless - simply adjusted to our choices.

 

Like, Asunder happened whether Wynne and Shale were dead or not. If they were then the events would unfold differently.  If Alistair was a Warden then the comics would probably be roughly the same, and if he were dead then they'd probably unfold with Maevaris, Isabela, and Varric trying to take down Aurelias instead. 

[LordofOrzammar]

Yeah. I imagine that, while the events of Asunder, the Masked Empire, the Last Flight, and The Silent Grove, Those Who Speak, and, Until We Speak, follow Bioware's canon, the events unfold regardless - simply adjusted to our choices.

 

Like, Asunder happened whether Wynne and Shale were dead or not. If they were then the events would unfold differently.  If Alistair was a Warden then the comics would probably be roughly the same, and if he were dead then they'd probably unfold with Maevaris, Isabela, and Varric trying to take down Aurelias instead. 

These are my thoughts on the subject and I believe bioware confirmed this as true.

 

The books/comics happen, but modified slightly to fit whatever choices you made in the games.

[xarthas2]

These are my thoughts on the subject and I believe bioware confirmed this as true.

 

The books/comics happen, but modified slightly to fit whatever choices you made in the games.

 

Which sometimes it is not quite straightforward. Try to carry out the main arch in Those Who Speak in a DA universe where Alistair is dead.

[The Elder King]

David actually state that those events might not even happen at all. While I doubt it'd be the case for Asunder, it could be for the comics.
The only situation when I see the events of the comics not happening though, is when both Alistair and Loghain are dead. I can see it happening with Loghain instead of Alistair.

[Cobra's_back]

Which sometimes it is not quite straightforward. Try to carry out the main arch in Those Who Speak in a DA universe where Alistair is dead.

 

True it wouldn't work without him.

[Cobra's_back]

David actually state that those events might not even happen at all. While I doubt it'd be the case for Asunder, it could be for the comics.
The only situation when I see the events of the comics not happening though, is when both Alistair and Loghain are dead. I can see it happening with Loghain instead of Alistair.

 

 

 

How would that work with the following comics: Silent grove, Those who speak, and Until we Sleep wriiten by David Gaider. It can't, because it is all about Alistair's dragon bloodline. If Alistair is dead, those comics don't make sense at all.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

She's skilled at acquiring goods for really cheap prices...even for free!

 

Politics?  Sure, why not.  Isabela's been to loads of different countries 

She's terrible with money though. She blows it all on booze instead of buying a ship.

[teenparty]

How would that work with the following comics: Silent grove, Those who speak, and Until we Sleep wriiten by David Gaider. It can't, because it is all about Alistair's dragon bloodline. If Alistair is dead, those comics don't make sense at all.

 

Doesn't that mean Tevinter would rule the world if Alistair was dead?

[Cobra's_back]

Doesn't that mean Tevinter would rule the world if Alistair was dead?

 

Interesting point. I wonder how long they could have kept Marc alive using his blood. I know the only reason Claudio gave Alistair the invite was to use him to get to the silent grove for the dragon's blood. It seems Aurelian needed more blood of an ancient dragon or a younger dragon blood king. 

[karushna5]

How would that work with the following comics: Silent grove, Those who speak, and Until we Sleep wriiten by David Gaider. It can't, because it is all about Alistair's dragon bloodline. If Alistair is dead, those comics don't make sense at all.

Exactly, since stories to work at all must have some timeline, they pick one. In some other choices, those comics never happened. He has said before that they are not canon, they are just one story from a possible choice. None of that happened if you didnt make him king.

[The Elder King]

Exactly, since stories to work at all must have some timeline, they pick one. In some other choices, those comics never happened. He has said before that they are not canon, they are just one story from a possible choice. None of that happened if you didnt make him king.

It Could've happened in a different way if Alistair was a Warden though.

[TKavatar]

Do we know Alistair is dead for sure after Anora orders him away? Bioware could pull a Leliana on us and resurrect Alistair because of plot reasons.