Your analysis of Sera's character is very interesting. One thing that stands out after her speeches about the little people is...
It's a shame we learn so little about her over her romance arc. Although there is one thing she says after her personal quest (romanced or not) that makes my ear twitch with curiosity.
Soo this is my first time posting on the BSN, and i'm sorry for hijacking your comment for it, i had trouble figuring out where to start because i have a lot of weird feelings about Sera hahaha
But just... everything you said basically?? I feel like with all the other characters, we got to know them. We got to know a bit about their history and figure out what made them act the way they do, even got to help them with some of their issues, and with Sera..... i'm just disappointed even though i LOVE her?
Because while i don't hate her for her views or her actions (on the contrary, i think they are interesting and i love her personality), i am terribly frustrated by how i just don't know enough to understand WHY she is the way she is?
What made her dislike Dalish? She's a city elf how did she meet them? what sort of experiences did she have with them? what made her hate having her views challenged? why does she dislike debates so much? how was her childhood as an elf growing on a human house? was the baker thing the only incident she had with elf-racism? what made her believe that the past is not important? what are her beliefs, what does she think the chantry is supposed to be like? why can't we help her with any of it???.... I could go on and on, there are so many questions, and i care so much about her.....
but i feel like she lacks depth and it's such a shame because i love what we got to see. And all of this is compared to the other characters because, we don't know EVERYTHING about EVERYONE, but given the interactions we've had with her, those questions are simple stuff about the core of what was shown us, it's like Cassandra not telling us how she became a seeker and why. It's like never getting to ask why Blackwall did that one thing........
I love her romance and her personality and i hope Lukas Kristjanson comes chat here and tell us more about her, or does something about it in future dlc, Carver and Aveline were my favorite DA2 characters and i'm still a bit confused on how this happened with Sera......
Love reading all the interpretations people who gave her a chance posted here though, it's good to see other people are also trying to fill the gaps and some of you made pretty amazing comments