I can't stand the man. His actions lead to the deaths of innocent women and children. That is something that I can't forgive.
this is it exactly. i try my best not to align my real world views with the role playing...i really do. but that just utterly disgusted me. and then living in the real world where too many people get away with horrific crimes...and that thought process of "he seems to regret his action"...you'd have to be me to understand why that is NOT enough. especially when he benefits from this lie for YEARS. My spidey senses tingled with him when i took him to Valamar on my first playthrough...i mean we're in the deep roads so taking a warden seems wise right? "How many darkspawn are nearby, Blackwall?" "Idk. Hard to say...we should stay alert." The HELL you say? you're a warden and can't tell? you don't make sense! i digress.
(this is also why i have yet to go back in that Morrigan thread and explain myself. I'm still incensed.)