Aller au contenu

Photo

Sera "The Artful Dodger" discussion thread - V2 (now with more V1)


100542 réponses à ce sujet

#98051
FemHawke FTW

FemHawke FTW
  • Members
  • 1 194 messages

How does the cookie scene trigger? I never got it on my first playthrough. Is it because I told her not to do the pranks?


Yeah I think you need a high approval rating for the cookie scene, it's a way of showing how Sera has come to trust your Inquisitor enough to open up about her past.

#98052
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

How does the cookie scene trigger? I never got it on my first playthrough. Is it because I told her not to do the pranks?

 

I suspect that it's approval-based at the least. She's telling you stuff about her past because she likes and trusts you. It could also be that turning down the pranks stops you from being able to get the scene even with otherwise high approval. I don't know as I've not done that.

 

elven Vortigern needs to happen at some point in DA lore

*Googles Vortigern* Ah right. While I had a rough idea of the first Anglo-Saxons in Britain being invited mercenaries I wasn't aware of or had forgotten the names involved.  It reminds me in a way of the native peoples of Mexico who allied with Cortés against the Aztecs. Yes such an idea would be fun in DA lore.


  • FemHawke FTW aime ceci

#98053
God is Tigger

God is Tigger
  • Members
  • 78 messages

I love the way the Inquisitor says "Why didn't you take their weapons?!" at the start of the fight and Sera just laughs and says "Because no breaches."

 

Sera is a lot of fun to have in your party too. I always put her in my party right then and she has a permanent place until I beat the game.

Her laugh is the best part for me.  :)


  • Bowie Hawkins, Rel Fexive, FemHawke FTW et 1 autre aiment ceci

#98054
Rel Fexive

Rel Fexive
  • Members
  • 6 598 messages

I have more fanfic, guys! There's Cold Feet, which has mentions of Sera/Adaar though no real Sera in it (but it does have Adoribull being adorable, so), and For She Who Trusts in the Maker, which is Sera and my Adaar exploring their religious differences. And eating scones. And pulling pranks.


Great read!!

#98055
Aimi

Aimi
  • Members
  • 4 616 messages

*Googles Vortigern* Ah right. While I had a rough idea of the first Anglo-Saxons in Britain being invited mercenaries I wasn't aware of or had forgotten the names involved.  It reminds me in a way of the native peoples of Mexico who allied with Cortés against the Aztecs. Yes such an idea would be fun in DA lore.


yeah that's not it

Vortigern is a figure of medieval British mythology, and only pops up comparatively 'late' (specifically, the eighth century). The name means something like "High Ruler" in Old Welsh. Many historians identify Vortigern as being the same as an unnamed individual in Gildas' sermon De excidio et conquestu Britanniae. Gildas, ostensibly, is a relatively early source, and is certainly the earliest writer on the 'coming of the Saxons' (usually referred to as the adventus) available to historians. So identifying Vortigern with this person in Gildas is supposed to lend the later account in Bede a considerable amount of credibility.

There are all sorts of problems with this reasoning, which have been drawn out by innumerable scholars from Dumville to Halsall. Just as there are problems with the primary-school story of the adventus by Hengist and Horsa and all that nonsense, and problems with the story of King Arthur. But let that go.

Part of the reason that Vortigern became associated with this figure in Gildas is that the figure in Gildas is called superbo tyranno, or the "Proud Tyrant". Some historians have thought that this is a reference to the meaning of Vortigern's "name", that is to say "High Ruler". Often, people will refer to Vortigern as the "Proud Tyrant" directly.

There are some superficial connections that can be drawn between elven history and that of the Romano-British/Welsh, but the one I was going for was that: Vortigern, the so-called "Proud Tyrant". You pointed out that Sera particularly disliked pride, whether it was from Lady Emmald or from Dalish elves. So I thought it would be appropriate to take a figure from history and myth who has become known for his pride, and apply him to elven history, to make somebody that Sera would probably loathe beyond all reason.

#98056
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

yeah that's not it

Vortigern is a figure of medieval British mythology, and only pops up comparatively 'late' (specifically, the eighth century). The name means something like "High Ruler" in Old Welsh. Many historians identify Vortigern as being the same as an unnamed individual in Gildas' sermon De excidio et conquestu Britanniae. Gildas, ostensibly, is a relatively early source, and is certainly the earliest writer on the 'coming of the Saxons' (usually referred to as the adventus) available to historians. So identifying Vortigern with this person in Gildas is supposed to lend the later account in Bede a considerable amount of credibility.

There are all sorts of problems with this reasoning, which have been drawn out by innumerable scholars from Dumville to Halsall. Just as there are problems with the primary-school story of the adventus by Hengist and Horsa and all that nonsense, and problems with the story of King Arthur. But let that go.

Part of the reason that Vortigern became associated with this figure in Gildas is that the figure in Gildas is called superbo tyranno, or the "Proud Tyrant". Some historians have thought that this is a reference to the meaning of Vortigern's "name", that is to say "High Ruler". Often, people will refer to Vortigern as the "Proud Tyrant" directly.

There are some superficial connections that can be drawn between elven history and that of the Romano-British/Welsh, but the one I was going for was that: Vortigern, the so-called "Proud Tyrant". You pointed out that Sera particularly disliked pride, whether it was from Lady Emmald or from Dalish elves. So I thought it would be appropriate to take a figure from history and myth who has become known for his pride, and apply him to elven history, to make somebody that Sera would probably loathe beyond all reason.

I wouldn't seriously expect tales of that time to be much more than legend perhaps based on a kernel of truth, but a fun story is a fun story, and it would be interesting to learn that some Elven chief invited humans into Elvenhan to help only have them turn on her/him and the Elves in general. Is there a reason given for Vortigern's pride, or is it just a name?

 

(I suspect that the reason the Dalish have Celtic accents is precisely because of those similarities.)



#98057
Aimi

Aimi
  • Members
  • 4 616 messages

I wouldn't seriously expect tales of that time to be much more than legend perhaps based on a kernel of truth, but a fun story is a fun story, and it would be interesting to learn that some Elven chief invited humans into Elvenhan to help only have them turn on her/him and the Elves in general. Is there a reason given for Vortigern's pride, or is it just a name?
 
(I suspect that the reason the Dalish have Celtic accents is precisely because of those similarities.)


There's a lot of dispute about that.

First of all, there's dispute about whether Vortigern ever existed. A lot of scholars think he didn't. Some think that somebody like him might have existed. Virtually nobody credible believes the classic primary-school version of the myth.

Then there's the issue of what to believe about the 'historical' Vortigern, if there was one. Some historians make him into a Romano-British community leader or warlord unattested elsewhere. Others have connected him with other provably historical figures, like the late Roman would-be emperor Magnus Maximus, or similarly-named individuals that appear on grave markers (e.g. the Ogham marker to "Vortipor").

You can see how differing opinions of what Vortigern might actually have been would change historians' view of why he was called a proud tyrant.

Halsall, who advanced the Maximus theory, suggested (tongue-in-cheek) that anybody who called himself "Great the Greatest" and made a play for the imperial throne would be in for denunciation as a proud tyrant by somebody; he also thought that the Vortigern figure was hopelessly mythological at worst and unprovably primeval at best, that he originated as a legendary founder of the kingdom of Powys, and that he probably acquired the originally-unconnected story of the superbo tyranno - Maximus - relatively late in the medieval era.

Others, who modify more traditional readings, suggest that the proud tyrant appellation has more to do with some sort of hypothetical effort to use the Saxons to gain control of Britain for himself, a plan that supposedly backfired.

And then there's the most traditional reading, which in my mind is extremely bizarre, in that Gildas was supposedly making a pun on Vortigern's name. Never mind that Gildas refers to the same tyrant with three epithets ("proud tyrant", "unlucky tyrant", and "bloody tyrant")...
  • Caddius aime ceci

#98058
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

Others, who modify more traditional readings, suggest that the proud tyrant appellation has more to do with some sort of hypothetical effort to use the Saxons to gain control of Britain for himself, a plan that supposedly backfired.

That totally sounds like something Solas might have done... ;)



#98059
The Loyal Nub

The Loyal Nub
  • Members
  • 5 732 messages

tumblr_nqqn4xtFql1upa1u3o2_1280.jpg


  • Bowie Hawkins, Rel Fexive, Aimi et 4 autres aiment ceci

#98060
BSpud

BSpud
  • Members
  • 1 055 messages

How does the cookie scene trigger? I never got it on my first playthrough. Is it because I told her not to do the pranks?

 

No, you can refuse to do the pranks (though if you're mean about it, you'll take a big approval hit). It's approval based.



#98061
SardaukarElite

SardaukarElite
  • Members
  • 3 766 messages

That totally sounds like something Solas might have done... ;)

 

Speaking of which, what happens if Sera twigs to who Spoilas really is?



#98062
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

Speaking of which, what happens if Sera twigs to who Spoilas really is?

That will be interesting to see if the upcoming DLC is truly about him...



#98063
SardaukarElite

SardaukarElite
  • Members
  • 3 766 messages

That will be interesting to see if the upcoming DLC is truly about him...

 

It seems the logical place to take things. On the other hand I'm wary of DA plot hooks disappearing into the Deep Roads.



#98064
Jedi Master of Orion

Jedi Master of Orion
  • Members
  • 6 912 messages

No, you can refuse to do the pranks (though if you're mean about it, you'll take a big approval hit). It's approval based.

 

Hmm, well she still sounded like she was my friend by the end of the game. She still wanted to stay in the epilogue.



#98065
ComedicSociopathy

ComedicSociopathy
  • Members
  • 1 951 messages

Speaking of which, what happens if Sera twigs to who Spoilas really is?

 

Sera: Ha! I knew his head was cramped up thousand years ago. 


  • Rel Fexive, FemHawke FTW et Inverse_Twilight aiment ceci

#98066
BSpud

BSpud
  • Members
  • 1 055 messages

Hmm, well she still sounded like she was my friend by the end of the game. She still wanted to stay in the epilogue.

 

Must have to be really high approval, then. I refused the pranks (without being mean), but did all of the Red Jenny caches (and the majority of stashes in the Winter Palace) and she approved of the majority of my decisions. I triggered the cookie scene even before completing her personal quest, so it's not that, either.

 

Note: I'm talking about my second, current playthrough here. In my first, she liked my Inq a lot but it still did not trigger the cookie scene. I also hadn't done any of the caches/stashes and was mean to her about refusing to do the pranks. So it must be a really high approval threshold.



#98067
Inverse_Twilight

Inverse_Twilight
  • Members
  • 2 588 messages

Hey guys.

 

Good Cookies is updated with Chapter 3

 

http://archiveofouro...hapters/9610422


  • Bowie Hawkins et FemHawke FTW aiment ceci

#98068
SardaukarElite

SardaukarElite
  • Members
  • 3 766 messages

Sera: Ha! I knew his head was cramped up thousand years ago. 

 

When you put it like that, I guess she had him figured out all along.



#98069
draken-heart

draken-heart
  • Members
  • 4 009 messages

tumblr_nqqn4xtFql1upa1u3o2_1280.jpg

 

Don't think anyone commented on this yet. Looks like Sera is tickling the Inquisitor (or someone with dark hair), looks good.


  • The Loyal Nub aime ceci

#98070
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

Don't think anyone commented on this yet. Looks like Sera is tickling the Inquisitor (or someone with dark hair), looks good.

Yup. On Tumblr it's captioned "When the gf discovers how ticklish you are."


  • Bowie Hawkins, Rel Fexive et FemHawke FTW aiment ceci

#98071
YourFunnyUncle

YourFunnyUncle
  • Members
  • 7 587 messages

D'awwww.... Here's a positive spin on "racist" Sera...

 

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho1_1280.jpg

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho2_1280.jpg

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho3_1280.jpg

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho4_1280.jpg

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho5_1280.jpg

tumblr_nqsxe0I39z1uy4o3ho6_1280.jpg

 

Source.


  • SardaukarElite, Bowie Hawkins, Rel Fexive et 10 autres aiment ceci

#98072
SardaukarElite

SardaukarElite
  • Members
  • 3 766 messages

D'awwww.... Here's a positive spin on "racist" Sera...

(...)

 

Is "you're not qunari" something Bull actually says in game?

 

I like how her hair is longer before the game starts.



#98073
Caddius

Caddius
  • Members
  • 2 222 messages

Is "you're not qunari" something Bull actually says in game?

 

I like how her hair is longer before the game starts.

Yes. Qunari Inquisitors can chat up Iron Bull about the Qun, but with extra dialogue. In one of them, he politely corrects them, "No, you're not Qunari. Qunari isn't a race. (But qunari is.) You're Vashoth."

I can understand how it could sting, but he's also right, so...*shrug*



#98074
FemHawke FTW

FemHawke FTW
  • Members
  • 1 194 messages
Awww! Sera does make life better :)

#98075
FemHawke FTW

FemHawke FTW
  • Members
  • 1 194 messages

Hey guys.
 
Good Cookies is updated with Chapter 3
 
http://archiveofouro...hapters/9610422


Yay another chapter! Thanks Verse :D
  • Inverse_Twilight aime ceci