Aller au contenu

Photo

Should Loghain Live or Die?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
3201 réponses à ce sujet

#651
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Well, it's my first playthrough and although I've seen a couple of spoilers I've largely managed to avoid them, so it's not as if I know what's going to happen in any great detail (e.g. I knew there was something called the Dark Ritual but not what it was). I do tend to spoiler myself on what the alternative options would've done as soon as I've made a decision though :)

 

Still, by and large a very good game.

 

D: why are you here if you're trying to avert spoilers. Shoo Shoo! *waves away*

 

Ah that it is despite the several wtf moments near the ending.



#652
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

More like 5 possibly six times. Lanaya, Zatherine's hate for humans, and Leliana's backstory (probably Zev's too come to think of it).

 

Didn't even know that. My god that is **** writing. I mean how many times to we have to use the same things. There are a lot of terrible people in the world and a lot of terrible things that happen. Not all of them are rape, murder, etc. Most often it's being worn down over time with bad conditions and situations that does it. It's cheap and easy to just grab for the most horrific one. When I first began writing I did that too. It seems like drama, but some of the best drama out around doesn't even include these things. It's other variables, with things like time and elements of oppression, failure, depression, self blame... all sort of things that fuel situations. Just being oppressed with horrible conditions, being used and mistreated is enough to create powerful backstories with powerful characters. We don't need to rape and murder all of them. Look at the mage. No rape or murder there and of course, they couldn't because that would change things so that you hate the templars. But in other places where they can do it they do.



#653
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

There's rape in the circle tower.

 

I understand why it's used. It's horribly and it is not uncommon sadly.

 

That said I would like someone with a happy backstory that's an ******* because people are sometimes just assholes.

 

 

So it edits at the singular but not the plural? LOL they need to fix this



#654
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

That sort of subtlety would work when the whole story is about city elves and you can sort of build it up... but when having to pack things in tightly to one origin story to give you a clear view of how things work in your former life, especially in a dramatic and violent way, I think this one worked well enough.

 

 

Aside from needing to harden him if he's made king, I don't see anything that was more significant than what my Warden jumped through to romance Leliana.

 

See, that is where you are wrong. You don't need to build up to it. Having the noble tear through on a drunken rage, ruining their celebration and smacking a few of them around, calling them names, even saying he owns them, creating an environment of fear and oppression gets you a very clear image. Then maybe he abuducts Shianni for attacking him. You don't even need to have her raped. The implication that he was going to teach her a lesson while keeping it very grey area as to what he was going to do and having the guards go along with it would more than suffice. It created an environment of terror, shows the oppression they face, the racism, the mistreatment, the abuse of power... if that doesn't get you to see things clearly then you are daft.

 

Edited to add: The option I just presented is far more dramatic and overall terrifying that what they did. Now we see the elves, overall, aren't really even safe in the alienage. We see that anyone could be grabbed for whatever reason and the guards back it. We see that they are mistreated and abused and it is allowed. It's an environment of fear and oppression and mainly happens because they are elves, once property of the humans.



#655
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

There's rape in the circle tower.

 

I understand why it's used. It's horribly and it is not uncommon sadly.

 

That said I would like someone with a happy backstory that's an ******* because people are sometimes just assholes.

 

There's a rape in the tower? Where is that? Dear god they just have a rape fetish I guess.



#656
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

There's a rape in the tower? Where is that? Dear god they just have a rape fetish I guess.

 

I'm using information from DA2. Anders does state the Templars raped the mages and he was lucky enough to avoid it.

 

It makes sense there. It is pretty much a oppressive environment (prison was a bad way of putting it) with a severe power imbalance.

 

I don't see it as a fetish as much as it's common and easily seen as indefensible so it's a quick way of creating conflict, negativity towards an institution or an antagonist.


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#657
Guest_starlitegirlx_*

Guest_starlitegirlx_*
  • Guests

I'm using information from DA2. Anders does state the Templars raped the mages and he was lucky enough to avoid it.

 

It makes sense there. It is pretty much a oppressive environment (prison was a bad way of putting it) with a severe power imbalance.

 

I don't see it as a fetish as much as it's common and easily seen as indefensible so it's a quick way of creating conflict, negativity towards an institution or an antagonist.

 

Well I was surprised it wasn't there. But in DA2 they add that in because they skipped it in DAO and probably to help get us to side with him given what is to come.



#658
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

DA2 has pretty much everyone look bad. Templars are abusing their powers and mages are using bloodmagic. At the end of that game I'd gladly take nuke them all and have the Maker sort em out solution.


  • Jeffonl1 et Cobra's_back aiment ceci

#659
Cobra's_back

Cobra's_back
  • Members
  • 3 057 messages

I'm using information from DA2. Anders does state the Templars raped the mages and he was lucky enough to avoid it.

 

It makes sense there. It is pretty much a oppressive environment (prison was a bad way of putting it) with a severe power imbalance.

 

I don't see it as a fetish as much as it's common and easily seen as indefensible so it's a quick way of creating conflict, negativity towards an institution or an antagonist.

 

Doesn't this make Wynne look incredibly stupid? She supports the imprisonment of mages that are sexually abused. 


  • Ryriena aime ceci

#660
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

Doesn't this make Wynne look incredibly stupid? She supports the imprisonment of mages that are sexually abused. 

Something that our side wonders about a great deal.



#661
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Doesn't this make Wynne look incredibly stupid? She supports the imprisonment of mages that are sexually abused. 

 

Sexual abuse happens just about everywhere. It's a dark side of the someone having power and influence over anyone else (parents, teachers, military, so on) especially someone who is either too scared or ashamed to tell someone who could possibly put a stop to it what happened. Then of course are the cultures (of which the sad majority is) that look down upon victims who do try discouraging the rest form even attempting it via victim blaming. There are ways to minimize it (which I feel the templars have failed at thus why I want reformations) but eventually humanities dark side rears it's ugly head.

 

Bleeeh I haven't had nearly enough to eat to voice this properly.


  • Cobra's_back et Ryriena aiment ceci

#662
Cobra's_back

Cobra's_back
  • Members
  • 3 057 messages

Sexual abuse happens just about everywhere. It's a dark side of the someone having power and influence over anyone else (parents, teachers, military, so on) especially someone who is either too scared or ashamed to tell someone who could possibly put a stop to it what happened. Then of course are the cultures (of which the sad majority is) that look down upon victims who do try discouraging the rest form even attempting it via victim blaming. There are ways to minimize it (which I feel the templars have failed at thus why I want reformations) but eventually humanities dark side rears it's ugly head.

 

Bleeeh I haven't had nearly enough to eat to voice this properly.

 

Very true and if the stupid women had half a brain she wouldn't support mages locked up. I would have let the people stay with their families and go to a mage school. It doesn't end the problem but it will cut it down because you have someone to go to your family. Not keep them there 24/7.

 

They have created a breeding ground for abomination. When these people are raped who will defend them? Family is the first group that sees red and wants to hang someone. This all makes me really angry. There are times in the game I just want to slap someone or kick them in the nuts. God knows I want to slap Wynne and kick Cullen in the nuts. I hate that the nice Templars die and the dirtbags live.

 

Anders was correct in wanting freedom. it was his method I didn't agree with and made things worst not better. They didn't free the mages. They actually cracked down harder. It is BW way of making everything stink.



#663
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

I already voiced my thoughts on how the Circles should be tweaked. But they defintely need to be there 24/7 until they pass their harrowing/ have lived for a few years in the tower.

 

Well depends on the family really there's some where there's a good chance many if not all call you a liar.

 

I...disagreed with Anders. Rivaled him just about everytime I don't kill him. The PC's that "friend" him (which is usually just because they're rivaling Fenris and dragged Anders around for haste bot) usually barely tolerate him.

 

But yeah the mage/templar issue (which honestly I really hope is marginalized in DAI. I was already tired of it by DA2.) was meh. Too many idiots on both sides and the moderates kept getting killed off by idiots and forced into corners by extremists.


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#664
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

Wynne sucks. She's almost not even worth siding with mages in the Broken Circle quest. I almost want to side with Morrigan on that place. All because of Wynne's role later on.


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#665
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Wynne sucks. She's almost not even worth siding with mages in the Broken Circle quest. I almost want to side with Morrigan on that place. All because of Wynne's role later on.

 

What she do?

 

I wish my mage could just facepalm at Morrigan right there honestly.



#666
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

What she do?

 

I wish my mage could just facepalm at Morrigan right there honestly.

 

Nothing I want to kill her over. I just entertain the idea. She's a stranger who crowns herself moral advisor right away, but all she does is repeat children's stories and naive ideals. She expects you to break romances with other characters.. for whatever reason. I guess she thinks you're supposed to be a Warrior monk who doesn't care about enjoying life. She doesn't know anything about the Wardens, but wants to "thank" me for sacrificing so much for the "rest of us". Something about that really gets me. That there are people like her who expect you to give up everything and sacrifice for them.

 

It's one thing to sacrifice and give things up of your own will. Another to have it expected. lol


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#667
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 424 messages

Oh yeah that. My Human Noble was kind of just sighing at that. (And he was the noble good guy but he had enough of being backstabbed and the warden revelations that his reaction to her "noble and good" tripe was to rub his temples). And yeah it bugs me too. Especially since the PC might not have even wanted to become a warden. I guess the DR is just one way of tweaking your nose at all that tripe.



#668
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

 I guess the DR is just one way of tweaking your nose at all that tripe.

 

It is one way at least. If Wynne's schtick is sacrifice, then Morrigan's is survival.

 

To bring the thread back to the original point though, I'd rather bypass both and go with Loghain. I don't know what he represents. Throwing people under the bus, I guess?


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#669
ShadowLordXII

ShadowLordXII
  • Members
  • 1 245 messages

It's canon that two Wardens will never have children together, IIRC. It's just barely possible as it is for a non-Warden to have a child with one, and Morrigan was very obviously using magic to ensure conception (which you can't ensure from sex between ordinary people anyway).

 

Actually the exact words are "next-to-impossible"



#670
Cobra's_back

Cobra's_back
  • Members
  • 3 057 messages

Nothing I want to kill her over. I just entertain the idea. She's a stranger who crowns herself moral advisor right away, but all she does is repeat children's stories and naive ideals. She expects you to break romances with other characters.. for whatever reason. I guess she thinks you're supposed to be a Warrior monk who doesn't care about enjoying life. She doesn't know anything about the Wardens, but wants to "thank" me for sacrificing so much for the "rest of us". Something about that really gets me. That there are people like her who expect you to give up everything and sacrifice for them.

 

It's one thing to sacrifice and give things up of your own will. Another to have it expected. lol

She does one more thing. Miss preachy brings a child into the world and lets the Templars take that child away. The Chantry has her convinced that sleeping around is fine. You just can't have a family. 



#671
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

They're pretty airtight when it comes to suppressing your Warden's future prospects. No children, no legacy, and now missing in action.

 

You do get a statue in Weisshaupt if you do everything like a good boy or girl and just die. I guess statues are supposed to be cool. Or something. Although I'd rather my Warden died without his soul getting destroyed. That sounds bad.


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#672
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 944 messages

She does one more thing. Miss preachy brings a child into the world and lets the Templars take that child away. The Chantry has her convinced that sleeping around is fine. You just can't have a family. 

I think mage sex is discouraged, actually. Anders notes that you want to have it done quickly, so that the Templars don't catch you. Hence the robes. (Wynne also notes mage unions are discouraged, though her words could have been construed to just refer to marriage.)


  • Cobra's_back aime ceci

#673
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 944 messages

You do get a statue in Weisshaupt if you do everything like a good boy or girl and just die.

Well thanks for telling me, because I was sure as hell never going to know.


  • Ryzaki et Cobra's_back aiment ceci

#674
Cobra's_back

Cobra's_back
  • Members
  • 3 057 messages

I think mage sex is discouraged, actually. Anders notes that you want to have it done quickly, so that the Templars don't catch you. Hence the robes. (Wynne also notes mage unions are discouraged, though her words could have been construed to just refer to marriage.)

 

Kinda makes her a big hypocrite. She made in clear in several conversations that she had woke up to younger man and they had the magic bullet to stop pregnancies. I guess it doesn't work all the time because she had a child.



#675
Guest_StreetMagic_*

Guest_StreetMagic_*
  • Guests

Well thanks for telling me, because I was sure as hell never going to know.

 

Yeah. You get to be just like Garahel and everything.

 

Although no one remembers Garahel or talks about him much.