Im on the fence with the whole Templar/Mage war. On the one head, the Templars have gotten out of hand. On the other...the mages need policed. So *Shrug* Idk.
IMO the circle in Ferelden was pretty peaceful in the origin story, then it all turned to **** when the bloodmages came along...
MY LOGIC:
Whats the deference between a bloodmage and a murder? a thief? All are dangerous. Any man, elf, dwarf, qunari, can become a murderer or a thief. But only mages can become bloodmage. Ok. Fine, lock up the mages. BUT, now you must lock up every man, so they don't steal or murder. Why should they lock up mages when a skilled murderer can be just as dangerous? I think the mages deserve freedom. However make them attend a mages school, just like any other school, go during the day go home at night, not constantly be locked up and watched by creepy old men.