But then again, I am sure some folks liked it, and was curious if they liked it better than the mage quest and if so, why... (really, to help me overcome my prejudice against the scene...I need some perspective!!!)
I won't take on the job of convincing you to like a quest because, eh, but I do think Champions is a better written and structured quest than Whispers in every way, has more interesting characters, a better villain, more emotional impact, Cole's introduction is better than Dorian's, etc, pretty much the opposite of every point you made there; so, really, it's all a matter of different opinions and perspectives. It's ok to not like a quest/character/any writing aspect of the game (as long as one is not dissing on people who do like it) - no one's arguments for it can force you to like Champions if you don't, just as I don't like Whispers and no one's arguments on its behalf will make me enjoy it. There isn't one objectively better or worse quest between the two, just different players with different tastes.