Hey, can I ask you guys a question about Tumblr?
For ha-ha's I did a search for Cullen and within the first 5min I found what looks to be two of my flycam shots (what's worse is they've been color-altered). Are there any guidelines around that stuff? I know with artwork it's a taboo, but what about screenshots? I can understand simple cutscene shots (anybody can grab the same shot), but flycam shots are a bit different. It's very hard to completely replicate the same angle 100%. Screenarchers put a lot of work into that sort of thing that I would hazard to say it could be construed as art.
Thoughts?
Tumblr is actually pretty supportive when it comes to protecting fan-creations or alterations. Much of Tumblr's culture is based on gifs, which, in the context of games, are basically moving screenshots that are edited/color tweaked by the fans and don't technically contain content that belong to the giffers, either. At the very least they will police copies/reposts of your material if you show them the permalink to your original post with the earlier timestamp on Tumblr. I know you posted your original outside of Tumblr, but if you send an email to support@tumblr.com with the URL to the permalink version of the stolen screenshot on the reposter's blog and a link to your original post online, they might still remove the offending image.
Also, don't feel bad about watermarking your edits/screenies. It's pretty much a given on Tumblr that what is edited belongs to official companies and not to us, and people use watermarks because reposting is rampant. Even though watermarking color edits of other peoples' fanart is taboo, I think there is much less of a power imbalance when it comes to watermarking things like screenshots of in-game footage because everyone knows that the company has the real power - and if they really are offended at the usage, can legally do something about it. The way I see it, since fancreators have no real legal power over their images it's lamer to victimize them by using their creations without permission because it's more exploitative. At least, that's my take on things - I don't know what Bioware's opinion on the issue might be. I hope they don't mind. Either way it's pretty much the norm to find watermarked gifs and edits on Tumblr. Some people spend hours coloring/composing incredibly intricate gifsets, so most people understand that effort is put into editing snapshots of the game and that there needs to be some level of protection.
Thanks for the heads up!
Sob ;-; I wanted to post this one particular fanart for the 5k celebration but now I'm thinking maybe I should submit this for the contest and draw something else Culleny for the 5k...would submitting a Cullen fanart to the contest be weirdly specific? I mean cosplaying one character and submitting that is rather specific too, but...oh man. I'm feeling indecisive.