This is a delayed response on my part, but I might be alone in being glad that there was no major negative consequence for Cullen not taking lyrium (short of him going through withdrawal, which I would have liked to have seen more of too). I just don't like the life lesson that gives... :/
Agreed, pretty much. I don’t like happy endings that don’t feel “earned”, but after everything Cullen’s been through I think he deserved it even if most of the angst part occurs in the previous two games. If resources were no issue it might have been cool if having him quit unlocked an alternative military advisor for the middle part of the game while Cullen got the worst of it out of his system, or something to that effect, but I wouldn’t have wanted to choose between “Cullen loses his mind or maybe dies” and “Cullen hates himself for failing and then eventually probably loses his mind anyway”.
I for one have no romantic bone in my body in real life, but even I foresaw issues with this romance. But my views ARE my opinions just as yours are. Disagree or agree it matters not. What matters is opinions are just that opinions.
Totally, and I don’t mean to bag on you here! But I replied to your first post because equating "the game doesn't have some content I’d have liked to see" with "the developers were lazy" is a pet peeve for me, and I wanted to reply to parts of your reply to clarify, because I think you misread some of what I was saying. I’m done after this:
Doubtful. You assume that everyone chose a Mage as their main character in DAO. I chose this, however I am not expecting nor want more dialogue in regards to that. If I want that, I’ll load up DAO. Cullen’s time in the Circle Tower is what is important not his damn feelings towards a Mage. What I would have liked to hear is: How long was he in that cage? Does he regret asking the Hero of Fereldan to kill all the Mages? What did they torture him with? These are questions I was expecting answers too, not the same dribble that was mentioned in the previous game. Revelations into a character’s life make that character deeper.
That’s exactly the opposite of what I’m assuming. Regardless of whether Amell or Surana survived Jowan’s escape to become the HoF in a particular player’s worldstate, one or both of them existed; it's not a stretch to think he may have crushed on them even if they weren't the PC and therefore that any further discussion of his torture would have involved one of them. This would have made everyone who thinks the existing mentions are too many (this group does not include me) angrier.
More importantly, I’m not sure what there is to be gained from hearing more about the rest of it. For one, some things are scarier left in the shadows; for another, he’s really uncomfortable talking about it and
might not want to relive it in detail just to satisfy the curiosity of someone he loves; and for another, personally, of all the ways I’d love to know more about him, that isn’t one of them. (
EDIT: Also, the rest of your points are addressed as it is: he said in DA2 that he doesn't know how long it was and IIRC something about how asking to kill the mages was the wrong call, and in DA:I if your HoF was a fem!mage he says he regrets what he said to her, presumably including that.)
Yes, we were. But perhaps you are simply missing body language in the scene.
Rather than missing it, I think I just wholeheartedly disagree with you about what this body language is conveying.
So you rather them spend the time and money, by adding in ridiculous crap like, Shards or those Astranirums? It could have been something simple as walking up to your romance and going to bed. I did not mind the fade to black in DAO nor did I mind it in Fable. That at least would give me a direction and the feeling they had some intimate time aside from just some kiss on the battlements whenever and if you choose too.
While I’m sure a sex scene designed by someone whose expertise is in puzzle design or shard-hiding and not 3D animation could have been fantastic in its own way, cinematics zots are cinematics zots. As for the last sentence there, I’d rather headcanon everything than have canon give me the impression that she has to initiate it every time.