Hmm, are the executors being lined up for some future game?
http://dragonage.wik.../wiki/Executors
But you said "Irving actively encouraged Uldred to teach and tease students with blood magic to root out potential threats," and it might be splitting hairs to say Irving encouraged Uldred to teach blood magic but not encouraged the study of blood magic. I also don't see what types of magic are studied as having much impact on how people experience a circle.
I think it's easy to seize on one or two things said later to completely rewrite what the mages' experiences were like. Unless you just assume Anders was an a**, it's hard to ignore the fact that he was so desperate to escape that he did it that many times, risking tranquility and death. People don't normally do that just for giggles. I played a couple of mage origins, and I found several of the Templars downright creepy or threatening, which was why Cullen's humanity stood out so much for me.
lol ok, but I have no idea where this conversation has gone anymore.
and now I'm just as frustrated with this as you all are..... It shouldn't matter what he thinks of the Chantry itself, the fact that he IS religious tells me that- whether Quizzie is Herald or not, should matter to him because it's like putting his faith into question isn't it?
The only thing I can possibly think of if that he just chooses to believe whatever you do. But personally I don't think he believes you're Herald.
These are exactly the same lines my thoughts are falling along. And that last looks like the view I'll be writing into my story.
This is brilliant lol. Do we know anything about Cullen and Dorian's relationship? I haven't finished the game so I'm not sure if there's content I've yet to see. I have a feeling a lot of people would think they wouldn't get along? I think Dorian would poke fun and tease Cullen senselessly, but Cullen's probably used to that from his siblings. I could see them bonding over books or something though.
Oh, there's a great scene between them. I don't want to spoil you for it, but it's wonderful and there is indeed something they bond over, and Dorian does tease him, but Cullen seems to give back pretty well. Go talk to Cullen a couple times after you get to Skyhold and visit some of the surrounding areas, and the scene should trigger.
I'd say almost certainly. Especially since they just fixed a bug in the recent patch to make that "those across the sea" mission trigger, which was a mission I don't think anyone even knew existed. Why fix it when there are so many other bugs in things we DO know about unless it's important? I'm guessing we'll maybe encounter them in the DLC?
To add to what everyone's said, I think it's obvious Cullen doesn't think much of the Chantry anymore. He might have at some earlier point, but regardless of what he thinks about the organization we can agree he's religious to some degree. If Cullen didn't believe in the Herald and you did, I think there'd be an argument somewhere if you're trying to have a relationship with him.....
I wrote a few more sentences and once I reread what I wrote I realized I backtracked and ran over my own argument, and now I'm just as frustrated with this as you all are..... It shouldn't matter what he thinks of the Chantry itself, the fact that he IS religious tells me that- whether Quizzie is Herald or not, should matter to him because it's like putting his faith into question isn't it?
The only thing I can possibly think of if that he just chooses to believe whatever you do. But personally I don't think he believes you're Herald.
Having played one Inquisitor who did believe she was Andraste's chosen (used all the dialogue options stating she did believe it, expressed disappointment after coming back from the Fade and finding out "Andraste" was just a spirit/memory/whatever Fade!Justinia was), I feel pretty safely that Cullen doesn't believe you're the Herald of Andraste. Whenever you use the faithful dialogue options, he always responds with varying degrees of, "well I don't think you're blessed or anything but if believing that brings you comfort, I can respect it."
And I think that's the key point with Cullen - more than bending his beliefs to adapt to yours, Cullen respects your beliefs without compromising his. He can respect a very pro-freedom mage Inquisitor, he can respect a very conservative Templar Inquisitor, he can respect a Inquisitor who doesn't care about either side and prefers to focus on other concerns, he can respect a Inquisitor who laughs at the Chantry and wants to see it burn, he can respect a Inquisitor who believes in the Chantry and fights to see it restored. He won't pretend to believe in something he doesn't to please you (he will challenge you on extremisms for or against either side of the war, for instance), and he won't pretend to not believe in something he does believe in either (he still holds a strong faith in the Maker even if you don't share it), but he will respect that you are who you are. He won't change his strongest beliefs for you, but he'll never demand that you change yours for him either - it's a relationship of mutual respect, above all.
These are exactly the same lines my thoughts are falling along. And that last looks like the view I'll be writing into my story.
Oh, there's a great scene between them. I don't want to spoil you for it, but it's wonderful and there is indeed something they bond over, and Dorian does tease him, but Cullen seems to give back pretty well. Go talk to Cullen a couple times after you get to Skyhold and visit some of the surrounding areas, and the scene should trigger.
I'd say almost certainly. Especially since they just fixed a bug in the recent patch to make that "those across the sea" mission trigger, which was a mission I don't think anyone even knew existed. Why fix it when there are so many other bugs in things we DO know about unless it's important? I'm guessing we'll maybe encounter them in the DLC?
Wait a minute.... my next mission is Pride Wrought.... and my mind is hitting a blank... I must really be missing something because I don't remember any Cullen/Dorian scene...
Having played one Inquisitor who did believe she was Andraste's chosen (used all the dialogue options stating she did believe it, expressed disappointment after coming back from the Fade and finding out "Andraste" was just a spirit/memory/whatever Fade!Justinia was), I feel pretty safely that Cullen doesn't believe you're the Herald of Andraste. Whenever you use the faithful dialogue options, he always responds with varying degrees of, "well I don't think you're blessed or anything but if believing that brings you comfort, I can respect it."
And I think that's the key point with Cullen - more than bending his beliefs to adapt to yours, Cullen respects your beliefs without compromising his. He can respect a very pro-freedom mage Inquisitor, he can respect a very conservative Templar Inquisitor, he can respect a Inquisitor who doesn't care about either side and prefers to focus on other concerns, he can respect a Inquisitor who laughs at the Chantry and wants to see it burn, he can respect a Inquisitor who believes in the Chantry and fights to see it restored. He won't pretend to believe in something he doesn't to please you (he will challenge you on extremisms for or against either side of the war, for instance), and he won't pretend to not believe in something he does believe in either (he still holds a strong faith in the Maker even if you don't share it), but he will respect that you are who you are. He won't change his strongest beliefs for you, but he'll never demand that you change yours for him either - it's a relationship of mutual respect, above all.
I guess he really is a stand-up guy ain't he. I agree 100% with all you're saying, and it's making me think of his withdrawal scene. I understand the creators gave us black and white choices for multiple characters (IB for one, not to mention mage/templar) in that it's part of the gameplay. What must have been going through his mind that he couldn't make the decision on his own? Well... that's a dumb question isn't it. Hmm. I'm finding it hard to think straight tonight but I find that whole scene the more interesting now. I'm starting to think his symptoms/illness what have you, were affecting him a great deal more than he led on. Like his physical symptoms were the least of it. That it was much more than nightmares and headaches.
I have read all the novels multiple times over. What do you wish to know?
Which part in specific? I've read all the books, I think Elu and Monica and R2 have too, maybe we can help.
Hey, sorry for the late response to both of you, but it was about 3AM when I made the request and shortly went to bed afterwards. I'm back now though! ![]()
It's mostly to deal with the events of Asunder and the Templars breaking away from the chantry / declaring war on the mages.
I'm linking what I've written so far in the spoiler tag below. The conversation that refers to it is one of the later ones, but I would be very glad if you folks would read all of it and give feedback on the whole thing so far.
Having played one Inquisitor who did believe she was Andraste's chosen (used all the dialogue options stating she did believe it, expressed disappointment after coming back from the Fade and finding out "Andraste" was just a spirit/memory/whatever Fade!Justinia was), I feel pretty safely that Cullen doesn't believe you're the Herald of Andraste. Whenever you use the faithful dialogue options, he always responds with varying degrees of, "well I don't think you're blessed or anything but if believing that brings you comfort, I can respect it."
And I think that's the key point with Cullen - more than bending his beliefs to adapt to yours, Cullen respects your beliefs without compromising his. He can respect a very pro-freedom mage Inquisitor, he can respect a very conservative Templar Inquisitor, he can respect a Inquisitor who doesn't care about either side and prefers to focus on other concerns, he can respect a Inquisitor who laughs at the Chantry and wants to see it burn, he can respect a Inquisitor who believes in the Chantry and fights to see it restored. He won't pretend to believe in something he doesn't to please you (he will challenge you on extremisms for or against either side of the war, for instance), and he won't pretend to not believe in something he does believe in either (he still holds a strong faith in the Maker even if you don't share it), but he will respect that you are who you are. He won't change his strongest beliefs for you, but he'll never demand that you change yours for him either - it's a relationship of mutual respect, above all.
This is exactly how I'm writing him with my elven Inquisitor who believes in her own gods and tries to tell everyone she's absolutely not the Herald. Mutual respect, her respect for his faith and his for hers. They may not believe in the same gods, but it doesn't matter. They even try to learn more about each others beliefs and gods, even tease each other goodnaturedly occasionally about those things, but neither of them changes their beliefs or seeks to change the others. Cullen accepts and respects you, but he doesn't bow to you. He loves you, but he doesn't worship at your feet. I just... some people write him off as boring because he's sweet, I guess? But there's SO much strength and a sense of self, of individuality beneath that sweetness.
Hmm, are the executors being lined up for some future game?
http://dragonage.wik.../wiki/Executors
Anyone have somewhere that has a summary of the books? I only read the one with Maric, Rowan and Loghain, but not Asunder or any others. I don't know if I really want to take the time to read them, but would like to know what is in them since there are some references in the game to them.
What if Cullen was a party member in a DLC!?!
Well I whipped this conversation up...enjoy!
Cole: Two bodies lay pressed upon one another, naked as they day they were born. Strange sounds come from her lips, but they are not of pain they are…
Cullen Cole!
Dorian: Our young friend certainly knows how to break-up the silence during our trek through Maker knows what.
The Inquisitor: I am not listening to this.
Dorian: Well I am! Don’t mind these two. Please Cole, you have my full attention, by all means continue.
Cullen: Maker’s Breath!
I need this in my game. More flustered Cullen! MOAR!
Cole: His fingers trace along inky lakes and mountains. Her eyes tell him she wants them to trace her instead...she cant wait and neither can he.
Cullen: Cole, remember what we talked abou-
Cole: Strong, sturdy, secluded. Rules fade away. Just for her. Only for her. A toppled marker remains. Their little secret. Have the others noticed it yet?
Cullen: 0_0
Cass:
...Really knight commander? The War Table?
Dorian: HA! And I bet its seen its fair share of conquests too!
Cole: Oh yes! Many!
Cullen: *groan*
http://arkadycosplay...llen-cosplay-it

http://assassinating...hhhh-dragon-age

http://nerime.tumblr...rmour-kindaaaaa

http://galagraphia.t...but-when-duncan
“I always wanted to be a templar. But when Duncan recruited me, I figured it must have been the Maker’s will.” Warden-Commander Rutherford.
An AU where Duncan recruited the wrong templar, who later became the Hero of Ferelden.

http://lionsandclove...03/cute-moments

http://lionsandclove...llen-rutherford

lol ok, but I have no idea where this conversation has gone anymore.
Spoiler
But I'm perfectly happy to drop the topic too. I'd much rather hear speculation about the Executors in future games and how funny it was to actually hear Cullen get told "hush, just look pretty." Though with the stupid helmet clipping Solas's nose and cheeks, I'd rather have danced with Cullen last night, sigh. Also, I think Cullen looks really fantastic in the vanilla red uniform, though I've seen a dark blue version that's also flattering on him.
It's mostly to deal with the events of Asunder and the Templars breaking away from the chantry / declaring war on the mages.
I'm linking what I've written so far in the spoiler tag below. (...)
I think you're good on background, specially since you're telling it from one man's point of view, which is always slanted by his own understanding of events. The two things that gave me pause were:
So I can still buy the scenario your character presents, because it's not coming from the neutral narrator, but the character himself - he may not have all the facts just right, but he's telling what he knows of the war from his point of view, and that's as valid as anyone's account.
tl;dr I think you're good, thumbs up. ![]()
Anyone have somewhere that has a summary of the books? I only read the one with Maric, Rowan and Loghain, but not Asunder or any others. I don't know if I really want to take the time to read them, but would like to know what is in them since there are some references in the game to them.
The wikia has summaries of the each novel under their entries: The Calling, Asunder, Masked Empire, Last Flight; and the comics trilogy Silent Grove, Those Who Speak and Until We Sleep.
I'd always recommend actually reading them because there is a lot you miss out with just the encyclopedic overview (you miss the nuances of events being shown from different points of view, you miss the emotional connections you can form with the characters, etc). But of course time, money and even disposition can be factors, so if you're just looking for a quick account of events, the wiki entries should do it.
This is like the fifth time I've gone to Redcliffe before the ally quest, and this is the first time I've actually noticed what they meant when they started banging on about the rifts manipulating time.
This is like the fifth time I've gone to Redcliffe before the ally quest, and this is the first time I've actually noticed what they meant when they started banging on about the rifts manipulating time.
Took me three or four playthroughs to get it, too.
But once I got it, I now totally abuse the rings that increase attack speed with strategically placed rangers, both at the Redcliffe gates and later inside the Chantry with Dorian.
Took me three or four playthroughs to get it, too.
But once I got it, I now totally abuse the rings that increase attack speed with strategically placed rangers, both at the Redcliffe gates and later inside the Chantry with Dorian.
Glad I'm not the only one!
They could have made it so much clearer, like a little cutscene showing people caught in some weird loop or something.
Oh wow, the Connor cameo is working for the first time ever! Yay!!
Yeah, I honestly never noticed the difference my first time through. It would have probably made more sense if they dropped a giant zone where time flowed differently instead of much smaller mini zones.This is like the fifth time I've gone to Redcliffe before the ally quest, and this is the first time I've actually noticed what they meant when they started banging on about the rifts manipulating time.
Ha,ha, thanks for sharing. Fontofnothing put the files together and shared them with us, so yes, they came from someone in this thread. Funny, how popular they became and how we came full circle now
.
You have probably seen/heard this - who knows maybe one of you put this together! But just in case ...
(click on the picture)
love it!
http://femgamers.tum...urnei-geeky-jez
Here is my thought:
It could have been nice if one of two things happened:
Ask Cullen if he wants to spend sometime alone---> Cullen and your Inquisitor take a small walk on the Battlements outside his office. Cullen says these dialogue bits with filler from The Inquisitor. If in a romance Cullen gives your character a smooch and heads back to his office.
OR
Ask Cullen if he wishes to get some "sleep"----> Upon waking up the following day, Cullen and your Inquisitor share the above banter in bed. Followed by Cullen and The Inquisitor giving each other a kiss. And your Inquisitor rolls out of bed to start the day. If not in a romance with Cullen, you'll have a walk on the battlements with him instead.
Well that is what my mind drummed up. ![]()
OK Cullen thread, got a fun question for ya!
I have always loved Fereleden...whenever I get poetic or I want to write in the Dragon age universe, I feel like a Ferelden. I put on my tunic and lambswool, reach down and pet my trusted mabari, and dust the dried mud from my leather boots. I look out my window and see a grey sky hinting at rain and I smile. I have to get to the tavern soon, and I plan to drink until I am singing. I am Ferelden to the bone (but my momma was Rivani...so I,of course, have a hidden necklace under my tunic that was blessed by a seer). ![]()
But I wonder. what about the rest of you? Are there some Free Marchers out there, who love freedom and independence above all? Or some Orlesians, who love the game and all its subtleties? Or perhaps a few Rivanis or Antivans? Any Qunari?
So my question is, which place calls to you? Where would you live? Which flags decorated your hall? Where are you and Cully going on vacation?
Also...do you guys think this would be a fun question for the BSN page? It makes me nervous to post anything...out there...
EDIT - OK..I did it...I hope people are nice! ![]()
You have probably seen/heard this - who knows maybe one of you put this together! But just in case ...
(click on the picture)
love it!
http://femgamers.tum...urnei-geeky-jez
Ha,ha, thanks for sharing. Fontofnothing put the files together and shared them with us, so yes, they came from someone in this thread. Funny, how popular they became and how we came full circle now
.