16177 réponses à ce sujet

[Ynqve]

Spoiler

Wait Josie doesn't get a wedding? 

 

For all our differences Hanako, I'm truly sorry for you. And for the rest of you who are disappointed. 

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Spoiler

Wait Josie doesn't get a wedding? 

 

For all our differences Hanako, I'm truly sorry for you. And for the rest of you who are disappointed. 

Nope. Only Cullen and Sera get weddings. Everyone else gets screwed. Some can talk about it, but it never even comes up in conversation with Josephine, one of the only LIs not to have even that. 

 

Thanks Ynqve. I appreciate it.

I've never felt this despondent about a romance before, especially for one that started out as appearing as a dream come true.  

[Bayonet Hipshot]

Nope. Only Cullen and Sera get weddings. Everyone else gets screwed. Some can talk about it, but it never even comes up in conversation with Josephine, one of the only LIs not to have even that. 

 

Thanks Ynqve. I appreciate it. 

 

Do we have any Josie slideshow at least ? Perhaps the Inquisitor visiting her home in Antiva ? *clutching at threads*

[Ryzaki]

Nope. Only Cullen and Sera get weddings. Everyone else gets screwed. Some can talk about it, but it never even comes up in conversation with Josephine, one of the only LIs not to have even that. 

 

Thanks Ynqve. I appreciate it.

I've never felt this despondent about a romance before, especially for one that started out as appearing as a dream come true.  

 

That's...very odd. Especially considering I can get an affirmative from Bull (who laughed in my Inquisitor's face about the idea 2 years ago) but with Josie you can't even bring it up? wut?

[Ynqve]

Nope. Only Cullen and Sera get weddings. Everyone else gets screwed. Some can talk about it, but it never even comes up in conversation with Josephine, one of the only LIs not to have even that. 

 

Thanks Ynqve. I appreciate it. 

 

Wow, that's amazingly unfair. And kind of random, why only Cullen and Sera? Blackwall, Josie and Cassandra (if not divine) would have made perfect sense.

[KitKat21]

If memory serves from the ending, the Inquisitor goes with Josephine to Antiva, where her family welcomes them and the place becomes a second home. In regards to the marriage, the Inquisitor mentions a proposal while talking with Cassandra.

[Bugsie]

Nope. Only Cullen and Sera get weddings. Everyone else gets screwed. Some can talk about it, but it never even comes up in conversation with Josephine, one of the only LIs not to have even that. 

 

Thanks Ynqve. I appreciate it.

I've never felt this despondent about a romance before, especially for one that started out as appearing as a dream come true.  

I feel for you guys - and for our differences too Hanako sorry you didn't get the ending for Josie you wanted. Of all the characters I wanted to hear about having a wedding - I wanted to see Josie decked out in wedding finery. It appears some characters are more equal than others in this instance.

[thats1evildude]

Did she survive?

Eh, I'm happy.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Do we have any Josie slideshow at least ? Perhaps the Inquisitor visiting her home in Antiva ? *clutching at threads*

Here is what is says about the romance in the Epilogue slides. 

"The Inquisitor found himself/herself warmly received by Josephine's family, and House Montilyet quickly became a second home. A place where the Inquisitor could, at last, find peace for a time, with Josephine happily by his/her side."

 

That's...very odd. Especially considering I can get an affirmative from Bull (who laughed in my Inquisitor's face about the idea 2 years ago) but with Josie you can't even bring it up? wut?

I don't get it either. 

 

Wow, that's amazingly unfair. And kind of random, why only Cullen and Sera? Blackwall, Josie and Cassandra (if not divine) would have made perfect sense.

Agreed. With how much Cassandra's and Josephine's romance arcs were written having really classical romance stuff it would be only natural to have had it be at least an option for a conclusion. And Thom and Inquisitor would have been adorable with one. 

 

I feel for you guys - and for our differences too Hanako sorry you didn't get the ending for Josie you wanted. Of all the characters I wanted to hear about having a wedding - I wanted to see Josie decked out in wedding finery. It appears some characters are more equal than others in this instance.

Thank you Bugsie. I appreciate that. 

[Bayonet Hipshot]

Perhaps a lack of Josie is due to her writers and her voice actors ? I don't mean that in a bad way. I mean Sylvia probably has other duties, perhaps busy with Andromeda and Allegra has other things she has to do. Maybe this resulted in them being unable to record that many lines for Josie ?

 

Say what you will about Cassandra but she does get many lines in Trespasser. Your Inquisitor can also still flirt with Cassandra and still propose to her. Cassandra and Varric still get funny banters too. With Josie, all you have is attending a grand concert. The concert is probably nice, amazing even, especially for Inquisitors who had not experienced the fine things in life but there was not much else.

[Jaron Oberyn]

I thought her romance content in the dlc was more than enough. Probably not as much as Cassandra's given her extra in the field dialogue, but it was still pretty good. The part after she learned you were dying was especially touching. And at least it was a happy ending, the inquisitor moves in with her in Antiva. That's more than some people got (A moment of silence for the Solasmancers)

 

 

 

Perhaps a lack of Josie is due to her writers and her voice actors ? I don't mean that in a bad way. I mean Sylvia probably has other duties, perhaps busy with Andromeda and Allegra has other things she has to do. Maybe this resulted in them being unable to record that many lines for Josie ?

 

Say what you will about Cassandra but she does get many lines in Trespasser. Your Inquisitor can also still flirt with Cassandra and still propose to her. Cassandra and Varric still get funny banters too. With Josie, all you have is attending a grand concert. The concert is probably nice, amazing even, especially for Inquisitors who had not experienced the fine things in life but there was not much else.

 

If you come back to her when she's stationed at the top of the stairs every now and then, she has new romance dialogue. She also has romance dialogue upon learning of the mark trying to kill you.

[ComedicSociopathy]

I'd imagine the reason why Josephine doesn't marry you at the Winter Palace like Cullen and my lovely Sera is because she'd much rather prefer to marry you at her home in Antiva with all her family around to see it and enjoy it. 

 

Of course, that then begs the question as to why the epilogue slides don't show evidence of a wedding. 

[Bayonet Hipshot]

I thought her romance content in the dlc was more than enough. Probably not as much as Cassandra's given her extra in the field dialogue, but it was still pretty good. The part after she learned you were dying was especially touching. And at least it was a happy ending, the inquisitor moves in with her in Antiva. That's more than some people got (A moment of silence for the Solasmancers)

 

 

If you come back to her when she's stationed at the top of the stairs every now and then, she has new romance dialogue. She also has romance dialogue upon learning of the mark trying to kill you.

 

Video clips. Naow.

[karushna5]

As soon as I saw my wedding with Sera, I was sure Josephine would get a whole huge scene! It doesn't make sense that Cassandra or Josephine wouldn't have one. My other Inquisitor romanced Josie and it is strange they don't get married.

[Qunquistador]

I'd imagine the reason why Josephine doesn't marry you at the Winter Palace like Cullen and my lovely Sera is because she'd much rather prefer to marry you at her home in Antiva with all her family around to see it and enjoy it. 

 

Of course, that then begs the question as to why the epilogue slides don't show evidence of a wedding. 

Maybe they were already married...or maybe they haven't yet discussed getting married...or maybe they showed up to plan getting married. Maybe the Inquisitor's just a bonehead who hasn't thought to ask, you know being distracted with saving the world and keeping peace. It's up to everyone to decide, I guess

 

From the conversation with Cassandra, the quiz can at least announce that they've thought about it. It sounded to me like mine had bigger things on her mind and they've both been too busy to consider their relationship (judging from the Opera scene). Just another push toward making a decision about the future.

 

Cassandra's advice and Josephine's earlier date scene/meltdown scene were, to me, basically obvious ways to say that disbanding the Inquisition would be mean the quiz would have time to focus on normal relationship stuff and marriage, and Josephine would be happier for it...though her ending slides are happy anyway.

 

What decisions did you all make and why? Seems like all the roads led to the same place in the slides, honestly. They played it safe, in that regard. 

 

Spoiler

Totally called killing Iron Bull (very anticlimactic, but I was never a big Bull fan ) or Solas, wish I could have gotten Solas instead

[Hanako Ikezawa]

http://afragmentcast...phine-Montilyet

[thats1evildude]

You know, having watched the marriage scenes with Cullen and Sera, I think the perception of marriage in Thedas is generally that it's a legal arrangement. You marry to mark an alliance between houses, or to produce heirs that can legally take over property and titles. When people are in love in Thedas, they just stay together.

I should note that the concept of marrying for love is a relatively modern one.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

You know, having watched the marriage scenes with Cullen and Sera, I think the perception of marriage in Thedas is generally that it's a legal arrangement. You marry to mark an alliance between houses, or to produce heirs that can legally take over property and titles. When people are in love in Thedas, they just stay together.

I should note that the concept of marrying for love is a relatively modern one.

The fact that Sera, who has no house to speak of and is a lesbian thus cannot have kids with the Inquisitor, gets married disproves that. Also we had Malcolm, an apostate mage, and Leandra, a disowned woman, marry solely for love. 

[thats1evildude]

But after Sera proposes, the Inquisitor points out that marriage is "done for contracts and heirs. It really has nothing to do with love." That's a human Inky saying that.

That's not to say it NEVER happens. Aveline married Donnic and Wesley. Cullen proposes to the Inquisitor out of love.

But then, my City Elf Warden was entered into an arranged marriage, and Alistair can be coaxed into marrying Anora. The Inquisitor can arrange to marry over the Thibault daughter to prevent conflict. Dorian's parents despise each other. So there are plenty of examples of marriage as a strictly legal arrangement.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

But after Sera proposes, the Inquisitor points out that marriage is "done for contracts and heirs. It really has nothing to do with love." That's a human Inky saying that.

That's not to say it NEVER happens. Aveline married Donnic and Wesley. Cullen proposes to the Inquisitor out of love.

But then, my City Elf Warden was entered into an arranged marriage, and Alistair can be coaxed into marrying Anora. The Inquisitor can arrange to marry over the Thibault daughter to prevent conflict. Dorian's parents despise each other. So there are plenty of examples of marriage as a strictly legal arrangement.

That wasn't my point. I know there are a lot of marriages in Thedas that are for those reasons, but there are ones not for that reason as well thus there is no reason for marriage not to be a viable option for the other love interests, including Josephine. 

[karushna5]

You know, having watched the marriage scenes with Cullen and Sera, I think the perception of marriage in Thedas is generally that it's a legal arrangement. You marry to mark an alliance between houses, or to produce heirs that can legally take over property and titles. When people are in love in Thedas, they just stay together.

I should note that the concept of marrying for love is a relatively modern one.

 

Nah that's a modern myth, people have always married for love and only the upper elements in history and some cultures marry for only legal status. But sense we base history on the higher ups, we often forget that among lower classes, marrying for love  has always been very common.

 

So nobles often were arranged because they had property and titles, and cared who was allied with whom, and thought their blood was special. But most people worked on land they didn't own, and heirs were less important than help with the work. This is less true of Dwarves due to their society. But so far, it seems a lot of people marry for love, Sera and Morrigan for one, Iron Bull for another. 

 

Alistair on the other hand when made prince is a different story because Nobles don't marry for love. Add in what we know of the Orlesian court and what Dorian says about Tevinter, and this seems likely? But as the Herald, I think we would be a good match for josephine. Vivienne snides to Sera that marrying my dwarf is a step up for her, and this is talking about a carta hit-woman, so it still doesn't make much sense?

[Iakus]

If memory serves from the ending, the Inquisitor goes with Josephine to Antiva, where her family welcomes them and the place becomes a second home. In regards to the marriage, the Inquisitor mentions a proposal while talking with Cassandra.

I interpret that as leaving it open to the player what happens next exactly.  Which I'm fine with.  If you want the Inquisitor and Josephine to be married, then they got married.  Later.

 

Sure I would have been happy with something on-screen, but really, that almost never happens in a Bioware game, so I don't think I got "screwed"

 

Just ask people who romanced Blackwall how their romance went...

 

Really, Josephine, Cassandra, et al is no worse than, say Leliana's romance.

[PrinceLionheart]

I interpret that as leaving it open to the player what happens next exactly.  Which I'm fine with.  If you want the Inquisitor and Josephine to be married, then they got married.  Later.

 

 

Until DA4 where Josephine appears and Bioware pulls a "My beloved disappeared _______ ago and I haven't seen them since." 

[Iakus]

Until DA4 where Josephine appears and Bioware pulls a "My beloved disappeared _______ ago and I haven't seen them since." 

That's a problem for then.

 

Because I swear if my Inquisitor pulls a Hawke and ditches his LI...

[Joe25]

That's a problem for then.

 

Because I swear if my Inquisitor pulls a Hawke and ditches his LI...

If they pull that card I want Josephine to higher a Crow to slap the Inquisitor.