Aller au contenu

Photo

Sister Nightingale: Leliana in DA:I Appreciation&Discussion (Nope, still not romanceable)


15912 réponses à ce sujet

#3901
Lenimph

Lenimph
  • Members
  • 4 561 messages

The men leave their underwear on and the women don't.

 

 

It's made pretty explicit when Raleigh says "Orlesian harlot, if you wanted any more of my men, you need only have asked!"

When does he say that? I don't remember it. 

 

I do think Leliana was taken advantaged of, but I don't really look at it as cold hard fact.



#3902
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

When does he say that? I don't remember it. 

 

I do think Leliana was taken advantaged of, but I don't really look at it as cold hard fact.

One of the fights with various mooks as you head up the coast. The... third, I think.



#3903
Lenimph

Lenimph
  • Members
  • 4 561 messages

Oh if that was the context that I probably took it as "I have plenty of more men to spare" mixed in with a bit of good old verbal sexual harassment for good measure, I don't even think he was there to know what happened in the dungeon...

 

Honestly the only line that really does suggest it to me is the "they did terrible things to me" one.



#3904
Divine Justinia V

Divine Justinia V
  • Members
  • 5 863 messages

I'm not going to argue with someone confusing real life and a fictional universe. Nvm.


  • Lenimph, Zjarcal, Bayonet Hipshot et 2 autres aiment ceci

#3905
myahele

myahele
  • Members
  • 2 728 messages
She was tortured and they'd do anything to break her.

#3906
jlb524

jlb524
  • Members
  • 19 954 messages

And the other bodies in Fort Drakon?

 

My Warden just never wears underwear.

 

Wait...there's a mod that does that?

 

It's the same mod...I just delete all the male files from the override folder.



#3907
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 425 messages

 

It's the same mod...I just delete all the male files from the override folder.

 

Ooooooh.

I'm too lazy for that XD



#3908
I SOLD MY SOUL TO BIOWARE

I SOLD MY SOUL TO BIOWARE
  • Members
  • 17 347 messages

My Warden was Dalish. She doesn't know what underwear is. 

 

/headcanon



#3909
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

My Warden was Dalish. She doesn't know what underwear is. 

 

/headcanon

 

those leaves she made :P



#3910
bairdduvessa

bairdduvessa
  • Members
  • 726 messages

i don't feel good and am going to bed way early for me, but before i do, my two cents.  the developer said a placeholder design was used as to not spoil anything, that is it.  she could be wearing a templar robe, or morrigan's outfit for all we know; she could be bloodied, bandaged or get this NOT actually in that scene.

 

so people please relax.

 

 

I was under the same impression in Origins. It seemed like Leliana dealt with a terrible ordeal when she recalled what happened, and I think she was still struggling with it to that day (when she confided in The Warden).

 

I'd imagine it's possible to avoid Leliana getting tortured by pursuing a path with one of the other advisers when dealing with Redcliffe; perhaps a military incursion might be recommended by Cullen, or diplomacy with one of the leaders could be advised by Josephine.

makes sense, she then starts to hear the voices in order to deal with the drama...


  • LobselVith8 et Magdalena11 aiment ceci

#3911
I SOLD MY SOUL TO BIOWARE

I SOLD MY SOUL TO BIOWARE
  • Members
  • 17 347 messages

those leaves she made :P

 

Nah man, commando. 



#3912
Guest_Trojan.Vundo_*

Guest_Trojan.Vundo_*
  • Guests

those leaves she made :P

maybe they use werewolf fur :P
  • AresKeith aime ceci

#3913
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

maybe they use werewolf fur :P

 

Hope his Dalish Warden didn't get fleas :P



#3914
Guest_Trojan.Vundo_*

Guest_Trojan.Vundo_*
  • Guests

Hope his Dalish Warden didn't get fleas :P


Maybe that's where pubic lice came from in thedas..haha
  • AresKeith aime ceci

#3915
Allan Schumacher

Allan Schumacher
  • BioWare Employees
  • 7 640 messages

It invokes powerful feelings in the player, so yes, it is a good story.

 

I'm going to interject here somewhat.  I consider it complicating that we've been tuned so much to see the physical abuse towards women as being something that invokes powerful feelings in people, because it can lend itself to things like benevolent sexism (overly trying to protect women from physical threats - violent or otherwise - simply because they're women and we get strong emotional reactions to seeing women, specifically, get hurt).  I think it also plays a reinforcement that feeling strong emotional reaction to violence towards women has a potentially negative perspective to how we perceive violence towards men.  As such "he can take it" and so forth (despite perhaps the fact that he cannot) and an undermining and dismissal towards challenges a man may have by virtue of him being a man and having unreasonable universal roles and expectations assigned to him that may not actually be necessary.

 

 

I agree that it's more powerful to take characters we care about, but I don't think it's unreasonable and step back for a moment to critique this in the context of historical depiction of violence against people and wonder "is there unforeseen consequences to something like this?"


  • Cat Lance, Alan Rickman, Ailith Tycane et 7 autres aiment ceci

#3916
Allan Schumacher

Allan Schumacher
  • BioWare Employees
  • 7 640 messages

People finding suffering enjoyable is pretty dang terrible

 

By extension:

 

Enjoyable may not be the best word, but within the context of a fictional, interactive experience, I do "enjoy" feeling strong emotional responses to what is happening on the screen.  Not that I "enjoy" seeing bad things, but I really like that a fictional game world can bring out such powerful emotions towards me:

 

 

Walking Dead, Season 1 ending spoilers

Spoiler


  • Alan Rickman, Fortlowe, CrimsonN7 et 3 autres aiment ceci

#3917
Cat Lance

Cat Lance
  • Members
  • 1 119 messages

I'm going to interject here somewhat.  I consider it complicating that we've been tuned so much to see the physical abuse towards women as being something that invokes powerful feelings in people, because it can lend itself to things like benevolent sexism (overly trying to protect women from physical threats - violent or otherwise - simply because they're women and we get strong emotional reactions to seeing women, specifically, get hurt).  I think it also plays a reinforcement that feeling strong emotional reaction to violence towards women has a potentially negative perspective to how we perceive violence towards men.  As such "he can take it" and so forth (despite perhaps the fact that he cannot) and an undermining and dismissal towards challenges a man may have by virtue of him being a man and having unreasonable universal roles and expectations assigned to him that may not actually be necessary.

 

 

I agree that it's more powerful to take characters we care about, but I don't think it's unreasonable and step back for a moment to critique this in the context of historical depiction of violence against people and wonder "is there unforeseen consequences to something like this?"

Don't forget desensitizing people to it. I find a lot of people just...get used to seeing it all the time when they consume that kind of media and sadly I've seen first hand how that can lead to not thinking anything of the enacting those same types of behaviour eventually. *smh*

 

And just to clarify, this is purely as a response/addition to the post I am quoting.



#3918
Allan Schumacher

Allan Schumacher
  • BioWare Employees
  • 7 640 messages

Also: I removed a shwack of off topic posts in this thread as well.


  • Ailith Tycane aime ceci

#3919
Fortlowe

Fortlowe
  • Members
  • 2 555 messages

By extension:

 

Enjoyable may not be the best word, but within the context of a fictional, interactive experience, I do "enjoy" feeling strong emotional responses to what is happening on the screen.  Not that I "enjoy" seeing bad things, but I really like that a fictional game world can bring out such powerful emotions towards me:

 

 

Walking Dead, Season 1 ending spoilers

Spoiler

 

Very much agreed. It's not remarkable that art can make us feel bad. It is remarkable that art can make us feel at all. I was astonished by the depth of feeling that scene welled up in me and so many others that played the game. Video games are only just realizing their potential as an art form, I think.



#3920
Chernaya

Chernaya
  • Members
  • 5 136 messages

By extension:

 

Enjoyable may not be the best word, but within the context of a fictional, interactive experience, I do "enjoy" feeling strong emotional responses to what is happening on the screen.  Not that I "enjoy" seeing bad things, but I really like that a fictional game world can bring out such powerful emotions towards me:

 

 

Walking Dead, Season 1 ending spoilers

Spoiler

 

That's the only part of any game that's ever had me not just tear up, but tears-streaming-down-my-face crying. Perfect example to what you said. 


  • Fortlowe aime ceci

#3921
drummerchick

drummerchick
  • Members
  • 291 messages

I'm going to interject here somewhat.  I consider it complicating that we've been tuned so much to see the physical abuse towards women as being something that invokes powerful feelings in people, because it can lend itself to things like benevolent sexism (overly trying to protect women from physical threats - violent or otherwise - simply because they're women and we get strong emotional reactions to seeing women, specifically, get hurt).  I think it also plays a reinforcement that feeling strong emotional reaction to violence towards women has a potentially negative perspective to how we perceive violence towards men.  As such "he can take it" and so forth (despite perhaps the fact that he cannot) and an undermining and dismissal towards challenges a man may have by virtue of him being a man and having unreasonable universal roles and expectations assigned to him that may not actually be necessary.

 

 

I agree that it's more powerful to take characters we care about, but I don't think it's unreasonable and step back for a moment to critique this in the context of historical depiction of violence against people and wonder "is there unforeseen consequences to something like this?"

In addition, I think it also says something about our culture and the inherent sexualization of women when we assume a character like Leliana has suffered sexual abuse, in addition to the physical and psychological. It is never actually stated that Leliana was sexually abused when Marjorlaine betrayed her, and without context, we cannot know if the same is true for the torture scene in Inquisition. But we assume she had to be sexually abused, even with ambiguous dialogue, because we have come to expect it to happen. We see women as natural victims.

Do we assume a man in a torture scene has been sexually abused? Probably not, without some context. But when a woman is put in a vulnerable situation, we almost automatically expect sexual trauma. As if the regular torture weren't enough.   

The only example I can think of atm is from The Walking Dead. (Sorry if Spoilers)

Spoiler


Sorry for the ramble, but I do think cultural and personal introspection is exactly what we should demand from our experience with art and entertainment (aside from the actual "being entertained" bit). 

ps I think Leliana is a very strong person; she's gonna get through this.


Modifié par Allan Schumacher, 16 juillet 2014 - 06:16 .
Added the spoilers tags


#3922
Allan Schumacher

Allan Schumacher
  • BioWare Employees
  • 7 640 messages

Just as a heads up, I added spoiler tags to your spoiler.

 

You can do so by typing out [ spoiler] SPOILER TEXT HERE [ /spoiler]

 

Just remove the space after the [ for the open and end tag.



#3923
Maria Caliban

Maria Caliban
  • Members
  • 26 094 messages
In regards to gender and how we interpret violence, I'll say two things.

One, we are more likely to suspect that a woman has been sexually assaulted because that is a reality many of us live in. Female players are aware that this is something that happens frequently to women, whether because we are warned it might happen to us, because we have female friends and family members who have been assaulted, or because we'd had to deal with it ourselves.

Two, Dragon Age has included implications of male victims: Cullen, Fenris, and the mage outside the Kirkwall circle who talks about being abused by a Templar. It sounds odd, but I'm glad they've done so. Not simply to shake the "Rape: It's for women!" mindset many dark fantasy setting are fond of but because it's harmful to not acknowledge men are also victimized.
  • Cat Lance, DalishRanger, Tower of Hanoi et 2 autres aiment ceci

#3924
Ailith Tycane

Ailith Tycane
  • Members
  • 2 422 messages

I understand fantasy settings use aspects of reality as inspiration, but rape and sexual assault is something I would be entirely happy with DA especially never ever bringing up or even exploring in any way shape or form. Ever.

 

It's not necessary at all to any plotlines, and at best it will just make people uncomfortable, at worst it can potentially make actual rapists feel justified and cause panic attacks for actual real life victims of sexual abuse and assault.

 

This is really a topic that doesn't need to be discussed here or brought up in DAI or any future games, and I would please ask that we change the subject. 

 

And as far as The Walking dead is concerned since it's been brought up, I cried like a baby. A hungry, angry baby.



#3925
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

By extension:

Enjoyable may not be the best word, but within the context of a fictional, interactive experience, I do "enjoy" feeling strong emotional responses to what is happening on the screen. Not that I "enjoy" seeing bad things, but I really like that a fictional game world can bring out such powerful emotions towards me:


Walking Dead, Season 1 ending spoilers

Spoiler

To enjoy means to "take delight or pleasure in (an activity or occasion)"
Unless one is a masochist negative emotions such as sadness, anger or pain are not enjoyment. Excitement, maybe. But not enjoyment
I guess Lee deserved peace, it wasnt as terrible as if he would
Spoiler

I guess as much as I enjoy Telltale games this rule of
Spoiler
of TWD is why I dislike the series. There is no hope, no any kind of justice. I look at these characters and realise they have no hope of survival, no hope for even revenge often. I despise Rick for how coldhearted he became in third season of TV series: leaving some quite innocent people to die and even looting them. I agree with Dale from 1 and 2 seasons : "'Cause at least I can say when the world goes to ****, I didn't let it take me down with it."