Aller au contenu

Photo

Sister Nightingale: Leliana in DA:I Appreciation&Discussion (Nope, still not romanceable)


15912 réponses à ce sujet

#15376
Kukuru

Kukuru
  • Members
  • 161 messages

I think the feeling that she bends better with a female or/and elf is because of the few extra lines on their dialogue. Aside that the romance is exactly the same.

 

I find kinda stupid to "force" people into believing that the "correct" way to romance her is with a certain gender/race, if we have the option any is correct.

 

Heartfire, I stopped reading comments on Tumblr because of it, i'd go insane with all the crap some people say lol Sometimes is better to just ignore them.


  • ThePhoenixKing et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15377
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

Maybe there isn't much Leliana/M!Warden on tumblr because many people feel like there's always less f/f content around than f/m or even m/m content, so they try to balance things out with fanart and fanfiction (and headcanons that some of you have called "weird"). In the end they're just expressing a preference, it doesn't automatically mean they all hate men or think Leliana does. Yes, there are also those who write rude comments and attack people for making different choices but let's not act like it's just a tumblr thing, they are everywhere and this forum makes no exception. All you can do about it is surround yourself with decent/trusted people and enjoy the content that you like, ignoring the rest.

Personally I never thought the M!Warden/Leliana romance was rapey or condescending, it's just different and I feel that difference adds more to Leliana's character. I just happen to prefer female characters and female OCs, so my attention is usually focused on f/f romances. I can't bring myself to care too much about a dynamic that never worked for me if I can choose one that works.

 

But this thread needs both, so here's more Leliana x Elias Amell  ^_^

 

tumblr_nxf9063Her1t93xito1_500.jpg

 

http://commander-sha...he-inquisitions

 

This looks more and more like a crossover  :P


  • Kukuru et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15378
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

That's the sad thing.. if people think it's condescending or "rapey". I can understand her having a preference somewhat, but that's harsh. I had nothing but warm fuzzy feelings about this back in 2009/2010.

 

Then I had to go and interact with other people. :lol:


  • LadyStoneheart aime ceci

#15379
introverted_assassin

introverted_assassin
  • Members
  • 2 230 messages
i wasn't even aware of the conflict of romancing her with a male, tbh. I'm not really insulated in the fandom like that and this is part of the reason why.
  • Kukuru et straykat aiment ceci

#15380
N7_Heartfire

N7_Heartfire
  • Members
  • 377 messages

I think the feeling that she bends better with a female or/and elf is because of the few extra lines on their dialogue. Aside that the romance is exactly the same.

 

I find kinda stupid to "force" people into believing that the "correct" way to romance her is with a certain gender/race, if we have the option any is correct.

 

Heartfire, I stopped reading comments on Tumblr because of it, i'd go insane with all the crap some people say lol Sometimes is better to just ignore them.

 

I know right!

 

I mean, m!Warden x Leliana is my jam but I accept that Leliana is bisexual and that it's normal for a bi person to have a preference for one gender over the other. I have a bi friend who prefers males over females, for example. It's completely normal for the romance to have a different tone depending on whether it's male or female Warden. I tried explaining this to someone on Tumblr but all of a sudden I was attacking the person and disrespecting their opinion. So i just gave up.

 

Some people on Tumblr find everything offensive. That's why I'm hesitant to post headcanons/fan art of my m/f pairings for Dragon Age and Mass Effect. I have f/f as well, but most of them are m/f. I tend to avoid Tumblr now because people are currently riled up by the new N7 trailer for ME and why there's Femshep's VA in the trailer.

 

As someone who has Maleshep as her canon it irritated me when someone said all of us Maleshep players should delete their saves and start playing as the canon Shepard.


  • ThePhoenixKing et Kukuru aiment ceci

#15381
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

tumblr_nxhgs1XAHs1r0l8dzo1_400.jpg

 

http://ricoshrimp.tu...omanced-leliana

 

tumblr_nxhojkVI3p1spzcvio1_500.jpg

 

http://coffeedtea.tu...902/sister-birb

 

tumblr_nxioacOjUl1u5q6djo1_500.png

 

http://ovrthewall.tu...-because-i-like

 

tumblr_nxipbx7UYD1rjxs7do2_r1_1280.jpg

 

http://shalalalin.tu...behind-so-heres

 

tumblr_nxipln390F1ui29uqo1_500.jpg

 

http://artingpidgeon...-robes-from-dao

 

I tend to avoid Tumblr now because people are currently riled up by the new N7 trailer for ME and why there's Femshep's VA in the trailer.

 

As someone who has Maleshep as her canon it irritated me when someone said all of us Maleshep players should delete their saves and start playing as the canon Shepard.

I follow a few Maleshep players and they seemed to take that comment as a sarcastic response to people actually claiming Maleshep was the canon Shepard, which is as wrong as saying Femshep is. Maleshep has been all over the place for years, so when suddenly the focus is on Femshep (long after the end of the trilogy, in this case) the least one could do is be cool with it, let it slide. But what did we get instead? The usual rants about "feminists ruining the trilogy" and "Bioware hating heterosexual men", all for a trailer where Femshep isn't even physically present. Can you really blame people for replying "yeah whatever, delete your saves if you really feel they were invalidated by a single trailer"? I know I can't.

Of course if we're talking about different comments feel free to ignore this post entirely. Or ignore it anyway  :P


  • Ava Grey, ThePhoenixKing, Kukuru et 2 autres aiment ceci

#15382
Mr Plow

Mr Plow
  • Members
  • 520 messages

I am all man (probably) and any time I can hear the wonderful Jennifer Hale's voice is fine with me 


  • GrinningRogue et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15383
N7_Heartfire

N7_Heartfire
  • Members
  • 377 messages

TBH, I couldn't care less whether it's Maleshep or Femshep represented in the trailers/games. I love both versions of Shepard and I don't understand why people constantly waste time and energy into that pointless argument over and over again. Seriously, why do people have to argue and hate everything?! Tumblr got no chill...

 

In my own canon universe of ME both versions of Shepard exist as brother and sister. I hope that if Mass Effect ever becomes a TV series/movie, that's the direction they go.


  • Kukuru aime ceci

#15384
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

TBH, I couldn't care less whether it's Maleshep or Femshep represented in the trailers/games. I love both versions of Shepard and I don't understand why people constantly waste time and energy into that pointless argument over and over again. Seriously, why do people have to argue and hate everything?! Tumblr got no chill...

 

In my own canon universe of ME both versions of Shepard exist as brother and sister. I hope that if Mass Effect ever becomes a TV series/movie, that's the direction they go.

 

It's because the male demographic does get shunned lately. And bridges get burned. And the less open minded now feel they have an excuse to lash out at innocent things, like a trailer. It's just a mess on both sides, really.

 

Here's one example, from a respected industry pub: http://www.gamasutra...rs_are_over.php

 

 

Not trying to derail though. Or picking that side. I'll be in Fallout tomorrow, playing a female myself. Never played Femshep.. but that's mostly because I use Sheploo and their CCs are whack. :P


  • ThePhoenixKing aime ceci

#15385
Lenimph

Lenimph
  • Members
  • 4 561 messages

*peaks in* 

Well back in my day I had to argue that Marjolaine and Leliana were more then gal pals before Leliana's Song came out so the fact that people actually recognize her preference makes me so happy.  

*slithers out* 


  • Kukuru et LadyStoneheart aiment ceci

#15386
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

Going back on topic, what's your opinion on Charter? According to a theory that's been going around recently she could be an agent of Fen'Harel, if not the agent responsible for the whole Trespasser mess. I hope it's not true, not only because I would like Charter to be on our side (if not in our party) in the future but also because otherwise it would be another instance of "Leliana has to screw up somehow for the story to move forward", and frankly I've had enough of that.



#15387
Wulfram

Wulfram
  • Members
  • 18 948 messages
I really hope they don't go too far with the whole Elf = Traitor thing. It would get unfortunate.
  • ThePhoenixKing et Kukuru aiment ceci

#15388
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

Yeah and I liked that while the other elves serving the Inquisition mostly went away she decided to stay and was chosen as one of Leliana's successors. It would be a shame if it was just another one of Solas' plots we could do nothing about.

Plus I don't think Leliana would react well to another of her friends betraying her.


  • Kukuru et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15389
Kukuru

Kukuru
  • Members
  • 161 messages

That's why i love and check this thread regularly, there are more open minded people posting here than in other threads. 

 

 

TBH, I couldn't care less whether it's Maleshep or Femshep represented in the trailers/games. I love both versions of Shepard and I don't understand why people constantly waste time and energy into that pointless argument over and over again. Seriously, why do people have to argue and hate everything?! Tumblr got no chill...

 

In my own canon universe of ME both versions of Shepard exist as brother and sister. I hope that if Mass Effect ever becomes a TV series/movie, that's the direction they go.

 

Lol! On my own canon they are siblings too! MaleShep is the big bro.

 

 

Going back on topic, what's your opinion on Charter? According to a theory that's been going around recently she could be an agent of Fen'Harel, if not the agent responsible for the whole Trespasser mess. I hope it's not true, not only because I would like Charter to be on our side (if not in our party) in the future but also because otherwise it would be another instance of "Leliana has to screw up somehow for the story to move forward", and frankly I've had enough of that.

 

It would be very disappointing if she end up being a traitor.

I didn't play Trespasser yet so i have no idea if there are some clues leading to think that she could be involved somehow.

 

I don't even know if i will ever play it, the huge loading screens between maps and cutscenes on PC are discouraging me, it's a pity because everything else runs smoothly.


  • N7_Heartfire aime ceci

#15390
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

It would be very disappointing if she end up being a traitor.

I didn't play Trespasser yet so i have no idea if there are some clues leading to think that she could be involved somehow.

Nothing except that she's elven and didn't leave. I think that theory is mostly based on what The World Of Thedas vol.2 has to say about Charter: apparently she is a "notorious master in false identities" known as The Black Hart and she was looking for a steady employment when Leliana asked her to work for the Inquisition under the name of Charter. The author concludes with "It is almost certain that he or she has shed that nickname for another by the time of this writing", but the only clues I found in Trespasser seem to go in the opposite direction. For example there's the note you can read in the Winter Palace right before heading to the final battle, where Charter says she'll understand if after the "oversight" with the Qunari spies a better agent gets promoted (as Leliana's successor?) in her place; then Leliana reassures her and jokingly (?) points out that she has enough scandalous gossip on her to know she can trust her, which can't be said about many other agents. That and the fact that it was Leliana who first contacted Charter (and not the other way around, like in the case of the elven spies "seeking refuge" in the Inquisition) convince me that this time Leliana knows who she's dealing with.

 

I don't even know if i will ever play it, the huge loading screens between maps and cutscenes on PC are discouraging me, it's a pity because everything else runs smoothly.

The only issues I had with playing Trespasser on my old laptop were during the Deep Road section. I don't know why but after a few minutes there the game started lagging so badly I couldn't even open my inventory, let alone fight or climb a ladder, and then it started crashing every five minutes. It's a miracle I managed to get out and finish the playthrough.


  • Kukuru et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15391
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

I said I was gonna play Fallout, but I just ended up distracted with DAO.... again. I'll get to Fallout soon. Never played the PC/Modded version of DAO before. I love the sacred ashes mod for Leli.. this armor should've been in the game. They even portray her that way in the Keep.

 

 

*peaks in* 

Well back in my day I had to argue that Marjolaine and Leliana were more then gal pals before Leliana's Song came out so the fact that people actually recognize her preference makes me so happy.  

*slithers out* 

 

I never thought anything of it either way. I was in my own little world. If anything, I just liked her because I saw a little of myself in her. I used to be kind of a thug, and then turned to spirituality. And I'm a musician. lol. So you could just say I gravitated to someone I identified with, storywise. And as a guy, I never saw the big deal with Morrigan. If that's supposed to my option. I think she's awful, tbh. What can I say? :P



#15392
GrinningRogue

GrinningRogue
  • Members
  • 278 messages

I am all man (probably) and any time I can hear the wonderful Jennifer Hale's voice is fine with me

 
Spoiler tag cos probably not appropriate for this forum

Spoiler


  • LadyStoneheart aime ceci

#15393
ThePhoenixKing

ThePhoenixKing
  • Members
  • 615 messages

I know right!

 

I mean, m!Warden x Leliana is my jam but I accept that Leliana is bisexual and that it's normal for a bi person to have a preference for one gender over the other. I have a bi friend who prefers males over females, for example. It's completely normal for the romance to have a different tone depending on whether it's male or female Warden. I tried explaining this to someone on Tumblr but all of a sudden I was attacking the person and disrespecting their opinion. So i just gave up.

 

Some people on Tumblr find everything offensive. That's why I'm hesitant to post headcanons/fan art of my m/f pairings for Dragon Age and Mass Effect. I have f/f as well, but most of them are m/f. I tend to avoid Tumblr now because people are currently riled up by the new N7 trailer for ME and why there's Femshep's VA in the trailer.

 

As someone who has Maleshep as her canon it irritated me when someone said all of us Maleshep players should delete their saves and start playing as the canon Shepard.

 

Yeah, there's no point in trying to appease the unappeasable. As a liberal progressive LGBT-friendly feminist guy myself, it's really frustrating to see social justice movements trying to solve real problems be drowned out by this self-indulgent white noise from the professionally offended. I wouldn't march to the beat of their drum; they're going to be angry no matter what you do, so what's the point in wasting time and energy trying to reason with them? Personally, I'd love to see your headcanons/fan art. You shouldn't have to be ashamed of the good work you do.

 

If anything, Leliana is an extremely loyal partner. I can't imagine her cheating on the Warden or anyone she's romantically involved with.

 

that's the thing about Leli that is glossed over a lot, I think. She stays down for you...neither distance or time would change that about her.

 

You both bring up an excellent point, and it's one of the reasons I love their relationship. Too often in fiction, one's love life and one's career/duty/calling are set up as mutually exclusive conditions; you can either be with someone, or stay committed to your cause, but not both. I love how Leliana and the Warden actively defy that. Their committment to each other hasn't changed, and indeed is stronger than ever despite the distance between them, but neither are going to abandon the things they believe in for each other either. It's... unusually mature.

 

I'm actually kinda reminded of SFDebris' Let's Play/analysis of the first game (which you should all definitely check out: http://sfdebris.com/...dragonage.php):"Can our hero fight both the Darkspawn and a treacherous ruler while still finding time to screw Claudia Black? Trick question, you make the time!" It's not Morrigan, but the same principle applies.

 

tumblr_nx5qr2dOdd1r1go1ko1_500.jpg

http://ellieraptor.t...copic-on-marker

 

tumblr_nx8hofmETT1uj8ddvo1_1280.jpg

http://commandersres...the-inquisition

 

tumblr_nx9bvoccgC1usi2i8o1_500.png

http://skyholdbarbec...drawing-leliana

 

 

 

 

I have yet to see a good fan art of Sigrun. It's a pity she didn't get much attention.

 

Awesome artwork, particularly the one with Leliana as a samurai archer type. You're right, there's a bit of a paucity of Sigrun art, but still, ask and ye shall receive:

 

http://aimo.devianta...igrun-318377454

http://captainmoutch...er-10-567637344

http://merwild.devia...igrun-534427609(NSFW, boobs)

 

I really hope they don't go too far with the whole Elf = Traitor thing. It would get unfortunate.

 

Me too. It would be the kind of lazy shortcut they might do, unfortunately, and I'm especially worried they might turn Merrill or Shianni into villains for the next game for the sake of cheap drama/raid bosses. Here's hoping otherwise.


  • Kukuru et N7_Heartfire aiment ceci

#15394
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

 

You both bring up an excellent point, and it's one of the reasons I love their relationship. Too often in fiction, one's love life and one's career/duty/calling are set up as mutually exclusive conditions; you can either be with someone, or stay committed to your cause, but not both. I love how Leliana and the Warden actively defy that. Their committment to each other hasn't changed, and indeed is stronger than ever despite the distance between them, but neither are going to abandon the things they believe in for each other either. It's... unusually mature.

 

I know nothing of this. My Warden is dead. :(

 

She's married to the Maker now, I guess. :P


  • Kukuru aime ceci

#15395
GoldenGail3

GoldenGail3
  • Members
  • 3 779 messages

I know nothing of this. My Warden is dead. :(

She's married to the Maker now, I guess. :P

Lol. Lol. Lol. Lol. Or maybe the Warden spirt.

My guy is a dead Dalish elf.....
  • straykat aime ceci

#15396
introverted_assassin

introverted_assassin
  • Members
  • 2 230 messages
wait who is Charter? the one at Caer Bronach?

#15397
thats1evildude

thats1evildude
  • Members
  • 11 001 messages

wait who is Charter? the one at Caer Bronach?


Yes. The redhead with Queen Anora's voice.

#15398
LadyStoneheart

LadyStoneheart
  • Members
  • 225 messages

If I remember correctly she's the one who recruited Harding. In Trespasser she acts like Leliana's second in command and keeps her updated on the scouts' activities throughout the quest. Oh she also guards our storage chest and wardrobe in the Winter Palace. :P

 

Me too. It would be the kind of lazy shortcut they might do, unfortunately, and I'm especially worried they might turn Merrill or Shianni into villains for the next game for the sake of cheap drama/raid bosses. Here's hoping otherwise.

Yeah, many people seem convinced that Merrill would gladly help Solas with his plan but it doesn't make much sense to me.


  • ThePhoenixKing aime ceci

#15399
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

I wonder if we'd ever see Merrill again. It sounds like they had bigger plans at one point, for the expansion for DA2 (the Mythal stuff).



#15400
Kukuru

Kukuru
  • Members
  • 161 messages

 

Awesome artwork, particularly the one with Leliana as a samurai archer type. You're right, there's a bit of a paucity of Sigrun art, but still, ask and ye shall receive:

 

http://aimo.devianta...igrun-318377454

http://captainmoutch...er-10-567637344

http://merwild.devia...igrun-534427609(NSFW, boobs)

 

 

Nice, thank you! That last one looks like the human version of Sigrun.

 

 

I know nothing of this. My Warden is dead. :(

 

She's married to the Maker now, I guess. :P

 

Lol, Leliana would be proud of your Warden.


  • ThePhoenixKing et straykat aiment ceci