Aller au contenu

Photo

Cole discussion, speculation, and fan thread: "How do you know?"


6175 réponses à ce sujet

#5801
Wolfen09

Wolfen09
  • Members
  • 2 913 messages

 

 

iron bull tries to get cole laid... lol


  • Obvious_Shining aime ceci

#5802
Milan92

Milan92
  • Members
  • 12 001 messages

If it's the same video I just listened to, it might be datamined from the files. The Sound quality seems really clean, no background ambient noises. It might not be an option available to us in the game. But I'm not really sure...

 

It was datamined.

 

I guess its possible they cut that from the game itself, but that its still available in the files.



#5803
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

The thing is, benevolent Spirits are rare indeed, but a spirit like Cole who can physically and even mentally become a human is unique. I love Solas, but he is not perfect, his experience and knowledge formed a stereotype that made him forget that Cole is different, Cole is more than a common compassion. However this time, a child of stone like Varric viewing Cole as Cole himself, without any labels, is even more open minded than Solas. I could understand why Solas wanted to simplify Cole, why he worried that the suffering of being a human could led him to astray. But I also believe that Cole is much more stronger and determined than Solas believed, he can overcome this by growing and learning in a human way, not by simply forget and be numbed in a spirit way.

Cole is still unique even if he remains more spirit, and he doesn't really forget what happens- he resolves it. It's just a matter of how you resolve it. I don't consider one superior to the other, just different sides of the same being.

#5804
Wheels

Wheels
  • Members
  • 212 messages

Hello Cole Thread. I just came here to say that I love Cole. He *might* even be my favorite character in the whole franchise by now.

It's fascinating to listen to him... Amazing writing :)



#5805
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

The thing is, benevolent Spirits are rare indeed, but a spirit like Cole who can physically and even mentally become a human is unique. I love Solas, but he is not perfect, his experience and knowledge formed a stereotype that made him forget that Cole is different, Cole is more than a common compassion. However this time, a child of stone like Varric viewing Cole as Cole himself, without any labels, is even more open minded than Solas. I could understand why Solas wanted to simplify Cole, why he worried that the suffering of being a human could led him to astray. But I also believe that Cole is much more stronger and determined than Solas believed, he can overcome this by growing and learning in a human way, not by simply forget and be numbed in a spirit way.

 

btw, i got banter between Cole and Sera today (my banter bugged in my first play through), i just know that she is not detest him, she's just a mundane girl who is not comfortable with the thing that is too complicated to understand. She even called him "him" in the end, and i think she was actually enjoy playing words game with Cole.

Why is being a human inherently superior to being a spirit?



#5806
Yermogi

Yermogi
  • Members
  • 988 messages

Why is being a human inherently superior to being a spirit?

I don't believe it's superior personally... but Cole became a human to help others and ease their suffering. The issue is, that in order to help humans, you have to be able to understand them, to relate to what they're going through. A Spirit cannot do that. They are not human, nor do they think like humans. This is the main reason why Cole went around killing mages in the White Spire instead of trying to help them through their issues. He believed that he truly was helping them overcome their pain, i.e., being compassionate. Rhys had to explain to Cole why that was wrong before he understood. Cole is unique among spirits because, in his human form, he has the opportunity to help humans AS a human, to understand their minds so that they overcome their  problems in a way that doesn't make them forget, and instead encourages them to grow.

 

I do not have a problem going either way. Solas's thoughts on the matter make complete sense- Cole is a Spirit. No matter how much he may emulate a human, he isn't one. It would be wrong to change Cole's nature and cause him to be more human, because that goes against what he was created for. But Varric also has a point- Cole wanted to become a human, so let him BE one. Either way works very well for story purposes.



#5807
Dust

Dust
  • Members
  • 254 messages

Why is being a human inherently superior to being a spirit?

I was not saying that one is superior to the other, I was saying that coming to this world and being a human is more like his choice, a choice that I will respect & support. If there is a way to follow his mind without denying anything he holds then I will take it. He is more than a human indeed, but his nature could be even more complex than a common spirit. Cole has this potential to grow and learn in a mundane world, then we should trust him and let him be. As for Spirit nature, they represent pure virtues of this world, I love them too. But I believe knowledge itself is pure, belief as well, so things like faith and wisdom are perfect containers for spirits. However resolving pain is never that unworldly, it might take time or even take risks, but the painstaking is why it will truly works, and why it worth the efforts.



#5808
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

I was not saying that one is superior to the other, I was saying that coming to this world and being a human is more like his choice, a choice that I will respect & support. If there is a way to follow his mind without denying anything he holds then I will take it. He is more than a human indeed, but his nature could be even more complex than a common spirit. Cole has this potential to grow and learn in a mundane world, then we should trust him and let him be. As for Spirit nature, they represent pure virtues of this world, I love them too. But I believe knowledge itself is pure, belief as well, so things like faith and wisdom are perfect containers for spirits. However resolving pain is never that unworldly, it might take time or even take risks, but the painstaking is why it will truly works, and why it worth the efforts.

But he didn't come to be human. That's not what he says, it's what Varric says. To me it felt more like Varric's wish than Cole's.
  • Exile Isan et Xilizhra aiment ceci

#5809
Sports72Xtrm

Sports72Xtrm
  • Members
  • 616 messages

But he didn't come to be human. That's not what he says, it's what Varric says. To me it felt more like Varric's wish than Cole's.

It's not all about Cole however. What of the templar who he made forget that he killed a young boy? That event changed him just as it did the spirit. With out that guilt, would the templar be as compassionate to mage boys in the future if he didn't learn from that event? He eased his pain, but he doesn't change if he's made to forget. Spirits I've been told are spirits because they seek something more than just instant gratification. Shouldn't spirits aspire to change lives instead of providing temporary comfort?



#5810
Zyrxi

Zyrxi
  • Members
  • 5 messages

So, I finished the game today and have a question

 

Spoiler



#5811
Kisari

Kisari
  • Members
  • 452 messages

So, I finished the game today and have a question

 

Spoiler

Spoiler



#5812
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

It's not all about Cole however. What of the templar who he made forget that he killed a young boy? That event changed him just as it did the spirit. With out that guilt, would the templar be as compassionate to mage boys in the future if he didn't learn from that event? He eased his pain, but he doesn't change if he's made to forget. Spirits I've been told are spirits because they seek something more than just instant gratification. Shouldn't spirits aspire to change lives instead of providing temporary comfort?

The templar had already left the order because of his guilt. There was no point in living under that burden forever. Cole doesn't make people forget the events of their lives, just his intervention. He explains that he shakes loose the "pearl of pain," which I interpret to be the mental and emotional traps that people are caught in that lead them to fixate on useless agony. That does change them, at least in regards to that one trauma.

Spoiler for Clan Lavellan war table quest.
Spoiler

  • _Lucinia aime ceci

#5813
Sports72Xtrm

Sports72Xtrm
  • Members
  • 616 messages

The templar had already left the order because of his guilt. There was no point in living under that burden forever. Cole doesn't make people forget the events of their lives, just his intervention. He explains that he shakes loose the "pearl of pain," which I interpret to be the mental and emotional traps that people are caught in that lead them to fixate on useless agony. That does change them, at least in regards to that one trauma.

Spoiler for Clan Lavellan war table quest.

Spoiler

Either Cole made him forget an integral part of his past that he could use to learn from or he made the templar numb to the death of the young boy he left to die as if to be callous to his accountability to the suffering of another. Either way, it seems wrong to me. Pain does have a purpose for mortals, to teach something- like being burned by fire teaches them not to touch fire. It isn't useless agony. Spirit Cole doesn't understand that, more human Cole would. If Isabela did not feel guilt about her past, would she have saved those slaves she was transporting? I don't think so. As Isabela says, "Are mistakes make us who we are."

 

Most of the time, cole plays therapist by helping people rationalize and come to term with their pain. In this case, he just erases it like magic. People shouldn't deal with trauma like that.



#5814
Faerah

Faerah
  • Members
  • 589 messages
After choosing human, this is how Cole describes spirits.
 
Inquisitor: "What's the difference between you an a spirit now?"

 

Cole: "Spirits are...they just are. Most of them sense something that interests them and stick to it. They don't remember much. It keeps them pure, but it also keeps them from learning, from growing. I wanted to help people, but I only knew enough to do it in the simplest way. Now I can see more. I also want to hit people a lot. Varric is helping with that."

 

After choosing spirit, Cole forgets/"lets go" of what happened to the original Cole. He refers to that knowledge/experience as "shackles" and that he's free now. He also "washes clean" of current unsavory things he has to do, like killing venatori or bandits. He makes himself forget so he can be clean/free of the shackles.

 

Either way, he gains something that's good for him. Human side: he can comprehend and learn. Spirit side: he can let things go, be free of them to return to the Fade if he desired. One isn't better than the other if you think about them objectively. It's a difficult choice that he should technically be making about himself, not us. But since this is a game of choice, it would obviously fall to us. So it's all up to personal preferences and morals in the end. There's no right answer.


  • AtreiyaN7, Kisari, SgtSteel91 et 2 autres aiment ceci

#5815
Liedeke

Liedeke
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Did Cole's personal quest again in my second run, both ways to compare them again, now I'm sure why I prefer the human path.

It's that little smile when you talk to him after, so worth it (for me at least). :)



#5816
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

I think that the ultimate reason I want to keep Cole as a spirit is that the world already has enough flawed humans; having a pure spirit around, willing and able to actually do good in the physical world is far, far rarer.



#5817
Dust

Dust
  • Members
  • 254 messages

I got the full text document of DAI, I’ve been working on retrieving Cole’s banter, Cole & Blackwall comes first. Enjoy!

Spoiler

Well, despite how I agree with Cole should be a human. I have to admit spirit Cole did a great job on giving solace to Blackwall. Human Cole did it in a much harder and colder way, though.


  • JenErik aime ceci

#5818
Faerah

Faerah
  • Members
  • 589 messages

So I just noticed there is a third part of the Cheese and mint thing of "Odd Things". Starts in the kitchen, then by the bar in the tavern, and the third part is back in the kitchen. OP updated. Not really sure how I didn't find that until now.


  • Kisari aime ceci

#5819
Dust

Dust
  • Members
  • 254 messages

 

Spoiler

 

Spoiler

 

Spoiler

  • JenErik aime ceci

#5820
Hobbes

Hobbes
  • Members
  • 540 messages

So, I finished the game today and have a question

 

Spoiler

I've been wondering that myself, it was definitely an interesting outcome, I'm curious how else it can turn out.

 

I have to say though, after finally finishing game, that I really enjoyed Coles character.  I loved watching him grow and change and the guidance you could offer him along the way, it was great.  His character really does have a lot of heart.

Cole.png

Lots of hugs for Cole.



#5821
Kisari

Kisari
  • Members
  • 452 messages

I've been wondering that myself, it was definitely an interesting outcome, I'm curious how else it can turn out.

 

I have to say though, after finally finishing game, that I really enjoyed Coles character.  I loved watching him grow and change and the guidance you could offer him along the way, it was great.  His character really does have a lot of heart.

Cole.png

Lots of hugs for Cole.

I already answered this exact quote, but if you don't do his personal quest Cole will not go to the final battle. His card get's an "x" over it. At least I'm like 80% sure of this.



#5822
Hobbes

Hobbes
  • Members
  • 540 messages

Ahh, yeah I did read that, but I thought it was perhaps speculation.

It would makes sense at the very least, otherwise Cole could get in a lot of trouble lol.



#5823
Kisari

Kisari
  • Members
  • 452 messages

Ahh, yeah I did read that, but I thought it was perhaps speculation.

It would makes sense at the very least, otherwise Cole could get in a lot of trouble lol.

Oh I guess it's mostly an educated guess as people in other parts of the forum have mentioned they ignored Cole and couldn't bring him to the final battle. My game crashes too much for me to make a new playthrough to test this out honestly though.

Spoiler



#5824
Faerah

Faerah
  • Members
  • 589 messages

Not sure how often this happens to other people...but it happens to me all of the time. Cole is too powerful with his Shadow Strike.


  • robertmarilyn et Liedeke aiment ceci

#5825
Liedeke

Liedeke
  • Members
  • 201 messages

He is obviously helping it. :)

 

This hasn't happened here. Other strange things, yeah, plenty. Like Cole pushing my inquisitor off cliffs and killing goats for no apparent reason.

But the strange things do seem to happen with Cole more than with the others...