917 réponses à ce sujet

[KainD]

na na chill

 

[AresKeith]

"You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because you joined a violent gang."

 

Lol.

 

Nice strawman

[Mockingword]

Nice strawman

It's pretty much a completely correct assessment of the situation. ):

[KainD]

One you won't easily get rid of either. To this day.

 

But you can stop the actions.

 

The actions to which religion calls you can also stop, and let's be honest, it's not a religion if it doesn't have a particular way of life in mind that it tries to spread and impose. I don't care about simple beliefs, that of course would be silly. 

[Hanako Ikezawa]

"You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because you joined a violent gang."

 

Lol.

So I guess we should punish all Andrastians too, huh? I mean, they haven't done anything to stop it either. Or anyone in the Free Marches for that matter. Heck, everyone on Thedas who haven't tried to free mages should be punished.

 

lol.

[EmissaryofLies]

i feel like you're sly digging me tbh

 

I am unsure as to why. I've been very sincere and open ever since I started posting on this forum.

[KainD]

Nice strawman

 

That was not a strawman.

[EmperorSahlertz]

You're wasting time trying to explain logic to some of these people.

I.... You know what? I won't even deign this with an answer.

 

I am washing my hands of this, and the amount of stupidity this thread has perpetrated for far too long.

,

I'm out..

[KainD]

So I guess we should punish all Andrastians too, huh? I mean, they haven't done anything to stop it either. Or anyone in the Free Marches for that matter. Heck, everyone on Thedas who haven't tried to free mages should be punished.

 

Sure, if that's how you fell then go for it. ( Not talking about YOU, but you get the idea. ) 

[Lord Raijin]

It's cool that you know that they're not the solution. I agree.

 

But then, bombing isn't much of a solution either. They just bomb you back. Next thing you know, you bomb their mother. Then they your mother. Then your dog. And uncle's cat. And your mailman.
 

 

Yeah it does. IIRC it was 7 years that Anders waited for Elthina to change things, to make things better but it got progressively worst, and not for the better. In ACT 3 the environment was very hostile and it was only matter of time before the Templar's and the mages finally lashed out at each other. Meredith was already planning to slaughter the mages in the circle by requesting ROA. Elthina should've realize that she had an unstable Knight-Commander but she did nothing.

 

If you disapprove of what Anders did then perhaps you should suggest at what Anders should of done differently in such hostile environment? Where Meredith was nearly impossible to communicate, especially since the Idol was causing her to be insane.

[Lord Raijin]

I.... You know what? I won't even deign this with an answer.

 

I am washing my hands of this, and the amount of stupidity this thread has perpetrated for far too long.

,

I'm out..

 

Bye bye.

[AresKeith]

It's pretty much a completely correct assessment of the situation. ):

 

Yea, because anybody who joins the Chantry automatically becomes the problem and hates all mages    

[Darth Krytie]

So I guess we should punish all Andrastians too, huh? I mean, they haven't done anything to stop it either. Or anyone in the Free Marches for that matter. Heck, everyone on Thedas who haven't tried to free mages should be punished.

 

lol.

 

The Chantry has had...exactly how many Exalted Marches since its creation? Seven? I think. So, yes, you can see, even if you don't take the mages into consideration, that the Chantry has condoned and committed violence on a very large scale.

[KainD]

Yea, because anybody who joins the Chantry automatically becomes the problem and hates all wants   

 

Well if you are against the chantry then.. YES, everyone who joins the chantry become a problem. 

[Shadow Fox]

...... 

Yeah that's my reaction to a lot of his posts too.

 

"You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because you joined a violent gang."

 

Lol.

More like "You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because your brother is."

[Mockingword]

So I guess we should punish all Andrastians too, huh? I mean, they haven't done anything to stop it either. Or anyone in the Free Marches for that matter. Heck, everyone on Thedas who haven't tried to free mages should be punished.

 

lol.

Of course not, that would be impractical.

 

Besides, random ignorant peasants are just as much victims of the Chantry as anyone else.

[AresKeith]

The Chantry has had...exactly how many Exalted Marches since its creation? Seven? I think. So, yes, you can see, even if you don't take the mages into consideration, that the Chantry has condoned violence on a very large scale.

 

Their Exailed Marches are provoked

[Divine Justinia V]

"You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because you joined a violent gang."

Lol.

So with that mindset Meredith was right with invoking the RoA. Awesome.

[GreyLycanTrope]

It's pretty much a completely correct assessment of the situation. ):

Yeah it even draws a false conclusion that being a member of a group automatically makes you a violent member of said group, way to point out the flawed logic.

[Mockingword]

Yeah that's my reaction to a lot of his posts too.

 

More like "You're not guilty of being a violent gang member just because your brother is."

Pretty sure Templars are part of the Chantry, and the Chantry is in charge of them.

 

The fact that the Chantry failed to keep control over them is grounds for further condemnation, not pity.

[Divine Justinia V]

I am unsure as to why. I've been very sincere and open ever since I started posting on this forum.

Stop it

[Shadow Fox]

The Chantry has had...exactly how many Exalted Marches since its creation? Seven? I think. So, yes, you can see, even if you don't take the mages into consideration, that the Chantry has condoned and committed violence on a very large scale.

...So has every major religion and nation in the world.

[Mockingword]

So with that mindset Meredith was right with invoking the RoA. Awesome.

No, don't be dumb.

 

How many times do I have to explain that being born with a trait you can't help is not at all on the same moral plane as willingly choosing to join a violent organisation?