Aller au contenu

Photo

Homosexuality in the Qun


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
187 réponses à ce sujet

#151
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

This is btw sadly why I never get the romance I want. It's always "i cant put you ahead of my people, ahead my faith, my ritual", and the protagonist is like "yah, I cant put you ahead of my heroic quest either". Which to me feels shallow. And there is no way around it.
Back on topic I think Qunari would discourage a deep relationship with a particular person, Qun and collective as a whole should come first. Being friendly is good but to everybody equally.

To clarify, I wasn't really talking about the examples you made when I talked about extreme devotion (though I think it's hard to implement in games like the ME IP, DAO and DAI. The type of story of DA2, I think, would've been better suited to your ideas). I was referring to doing extreme things if your loved one asked you to.
On qunari, I don't know. I think you're free to create deep bonds with others. They woudn't out those people above the Qun though.

#152
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

Can you have sex with the opposite sex as a gay person? Because as a straight person, I'm not sure I would be able to bring myself to arousal with the same sex, much less reach ejaculation.


They can be forced, I guess.

#153
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

Can you have sex with the opposite sex as a gay person? Because as a straight person, I'm not sure I would be able to bring myself to arousal with the same sex, much less reach ejaculation.

No choice, your genes are too valued, so your little friend better listen to the demand of the Qun...
Sad as that is, no one has a choice in a breeding program

#154
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

To clarify, I wasn't really talking about the examples you made when I talked about extreme devotion (though I think it's hard to implement in games like the ME IP, DAO and DAI. The type of story of DA2, I think, would've been better suited to your ideas). I was referring to doing extreme things if your loved one asked you to.


I know exactly what you meant before, you weren't misunderstood.
Yes, da2 could have a relationship like that, but didn't.

#155
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

They can be forced, I guess.


Well if you put a nude woman next to my same sex act, perhaps. Otherwise it's not like I have control over my body to that extent, same as I cant stop breathing.

#156
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

I know exactly what you meant before, you weren't misunderstood.
Yes, da2 could have a relationship like that, but didn't.

They even created a LI who would've been perfect for the role. Isabela.

#157
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

No choice, your genes are too valued, so your little friend better listen to the demand of the Qun...
Sad as that is, no one has a choice in a breeding program


Yeah but wouldn't a gay male by an impotent in a breeding program? A lesbian can still get pregnant with a straight male, vice verse, not sure the act could happen.

#158
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

They even created a LI who would've been perfect for the role. Isabela.


But she wasn't that type of person though.

#159
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

Yeah but wouldn't a gay male by an impotent in a breeding program? A lesbian can still get pregnant with a straight male, vice verse, not sure the act could happen.

Good question... I guess they have a way, but maybe lots and lots of "reeducation" is usef

#160
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

But she wasn't that type of person though.


I was mostly talking about a romance path where you can choose your LI over your duty. You're right on her not begin the type of person who would do anything for her loved ones (though she does return back, despite the risks for her life both by Castillon, the qunari and possibly Kirkwallers, if we has enough affection for Hawke).

#161
Guest_simfamUP_*

Guest_simfamUP_*
  • Guests

Simple question, how do you think homosexuality is treated in the Qun?

 

Different gendered relations in the Qun are prohibited, but this is mainly down to the worry that such a relationship could produce a less than adequate child who would be a waste of resources. Due to the fact that that could never happen in a same-sex relationship would a homosexual relationship be prohibited as well? Of course it could be prohibited because the Tamassrans believe any sort of relationship could get in the way of one's duty to the Qun.

 

Anyway, thoughts? 

 

I would say it's shunned because it doesn't produce anything 'useful' (or what would seem useful to the Qun anyway.) The Qunari seem like a pragmatic society, so reproduction is evidently vital to their existence. Homosexual relationships do not 'reproduce' in that way, so perhaps they'll see it as a waste and ban it.

 

Or it could just be frowned upon, the Qunari don't seem to discriminate as long as you are part of the Qun.

 

But I'll have to ask Zach on this one, Ari, so I'll be right back.


  • DrBlingzle aime ceci

#162
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

I was mostly talking about a romance path where you can choose your LI over your duty.


Hawke didn't really have any duty, kinda.

#163
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages

No choice, your genes are too valued, so your little friend better listen to the demand of the Qun...
Sad as that is, no one has a choice in a breeding program

But the Qunari do not connect sex with romance, so why would a gay man feel anything wrong for having to participate in the breeding program? He would do it for his people, not "just to get laid".



#164
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

But the Qunari do not connect sex with romance, so why would a gay man feel anything wrong for having to participate in the breeding program? He would do it for his people, not "just to get laid".

We were talking about gay people not wanting to do woohoo with the opposite sex. Or even simply not able (turn off for men)

#165
Shark17676

Shark17676
  • Members
  • 567 messages

It was not confirmed they were a couple. What David Gaider actually said:

 

So when it comes up outside of the player's personal experience, it's going to be either vague or implied (such as Wade & Herren, Branka & Hespith or the Viscount's son).

 

Vague?  Implied?  Heh, I always thought the game couldn't have been more blatant about Branka & Hespith's relationship.  :lol:



#166
DRTJR

DRTJR
  • Members
  • 1 806 messages
I actually doubt Qunari have sex it the sence to people making whoopie sense. They probibly have a proses to extract the semen and make sure it enpregnates the "mother." I doubt the push two Qunari in a room and tell them to have at it.

#167
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

But the Qunari do not connect sex with romance, so why would a gay man feel anything wrong for having to participate in the breeding program? He would do it for his people, not "just to get laid".


But how can he do it if the body doesn't function that way?

#168
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

I actually doubt Qunari have sex it the sence to people making whoopie sense. They probibly have a proses to extract the semen and make sure it enpregnates the "mother." I doubt the push two Qunari in a room and tell them to have at it.

They push them in a room, observe and give advice
Not sure if hilarious or creepy

#169
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

But how can he do it if the body doesn't function that way?

Maybe some potions, drugs etc?

#170
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

They probibly have a proses to extract the semen and make sure it enpregnates the "mother.".


How?

#171
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

Maybe some potions, drugs etc?


Do we have an analogue of that irl? I want some, it would broaden my potential partner choice by 50%. Lol

#172
Chari

Chari
  • Members
  • 3 380 messages

Do we have an analogue of that irl? I want some, it would broaden my potential partner choice by 50%. Lol

Viagra and such stuff?

#173
KainD

KainD
  • Members
  • 8 624 messages

Viagra and such stuff?


Viagra doesn't help one to ejaculate, only to get it up, you can rub it all you want, but pure physical stimulation isn't enough, you have to have a mental image in front of you or in your mind. Or atleast that's my experience.

#174
daveliam

daveliam
  • Members
  • 8 436 messages

Viagra doesn't help one to ejaculate, only to get it up, you can rub it all you want, but pure physical stimulation isn't enough, you have to have a mental image in front of you or in your mind. Or atleast that's my experience.

 

No, ejaculation is a physiological response that can be triggered by physical stimulation, regardless of who is providing that stimulation.  A gay qunari man could reproduce.  Gay men have been reproducing with women for generations (think of the nobility, who also have pressure of "lineage" production).  It's possible.  It might not be preferable, but it's possible. 



#175
ElitePinecone

ElitePinecone
  • Members
  • 12 936 messages

I don't thnk develoopers ever actually confirmed anything regarding Saemus and Ashaad, but the dialogue in the quest heavily implies such a relationship. Take from that what you will. Personally I have always just pictured it that Saemus was in love with Ashaad, but Ashaad wasn't in Saemus, but he was being friendly towards another person "worthy of his time".

 

David mentioned it once in an interview as an example of same-sex content in their games. I believe the questioner had asked about presentations of same-sex couples outside of the party (as in, "just in the world") and he mentioned that they put in a subtle relationship between Seamus and that qunari. 

 

Also, the Wiki page says other characters commented on it.