16 réponses à ce sujet

[geth47]

From favorite to least favorite (story-wise, not gameplay-wise), what would be your order?

[geth47]

My personal list:

 

1 Garrus

2 Tali

3 Wrex

4 Liara

5 Ash

6 Kaidan

7 Jenkins (lol)

[SporkFu]

Strictly ME1: Wrex, Tali, Ash, Liara, Garrus, Kaidan.

[Sequin]

This list always changes for me. At the moment:

 

1. Liara

2. Garrus

3. Ashley

4. Tali

5. Jenkins (his wide-eyed optimism would have been good for the team)

6. Wrex

7. Kaiden

[RedCaesar97]

1. Wrex

2. Kaidan

3. Ashley

4. Jenkins

5. -

6. -

7a. Liara

8. Garrus

9. -

10. Tali

 

I never understood the fascination with Tali or Garrus in ME1. Garrus got better as the series went on. I still do not get the fascination with Tali. She is okay in ME2.

[The Sarendoctrinator]

Garrus, Wrex, Tali, Kaidan, Ashley/Liara 

 

I can't decide if Ashley or Liara should be last. I didn't like either one of them. If we're counting Jenkins, he's ahead of them and behind Kaidan. 

[InventorRaccoon]

1.Tali

2.Garrus

3.Liara

4.Wrex

5.EDI

6.Javik

7.James

8.VS

 

I never played ME1, but from what I've seen Wrex is pretty cool. I always use Tali and Garrus, and Tali and some other person if I have to.

[Lady Sif]

1. Ash

2. Kaidan

3. Wrex

4. Liara

5. Garrus

6. Tali

[SwobyJ]

1. Kaidan

2. Ashley

3. Liara

4. Garrus

5. Wrex

6. Tali

 

This is based on the ME1 writing and design. Over time:

-Ashley lowered and lowered, and letting her die on Virmire helped in that.

-Kaidan stayed around 'upper tier' overall, but never the top. He was always missed potential.

-I've never loved nor loathed Liara. She's just good, whatever she is in whatever game.

-Always been cool with Garrus, but never as buddy with him as other players are.

-Ironic how I liked Wrex himself more over time, yet felt his character (in terms of the story) become worse and worse with each game.

-I liked Tali much more later on (still not my favorite by far), which inspired me to even do a Wrex+Tali fight against Saren in a later playthrough; a 'redeeming species' theme to it all.

 

I liked them all in ME1. No hate (if anything, the only henchman I hate is Jacob, and not always). I did enjoy taking humans with me more often, but took Liara with me sometimes, Garrus and Wrex with me occasionally, and Tali for Decryption/etc, but then more sparingly.

 

Final team normally: Kaidan and Liara

Wrex lives. Ashley dies.

Garrus, Wrex, Tali sidequests done.

No one romanced but I suppose 'feelings' for Kaidan.

[Liadan]

1. Kaidan

2. Wrex

3. Garrus

4. Liara

5. Ashley

6. Tali

[Purple Gorilla]

Just finished this phenomenal game for the first time. I don't want to make an ordered list so I just separated them into tiers based on how well I liked/disliked them.

 

High Tier

Ashley

Kaidan

Wrex

 

Mid Tier

Tali

 

Low Tier

Garrus

Liara

 

The two Alliance members I liked the most because I found their development to be spectacular and they definitely had the most interesting conversations out of all the companions, despite being humans (which I feel helped their case quite a bit because they had more leeway to become more fleshed-out characters rather than walking codices). Which means the Virmire choice was a pain. I went with Ashley in the end because I'm following the romance path. Very tempted to do another playthrough of the opposite gender if I ever have time.

 

Wrex is also up there because he has the most humorous lines in the game and I tend to lean heavily towards the badass merc characters. Great conflict towards the end, as well. Awesome, awesome character.

 

I became very uninterested in Garrus because I feel like he didn't have very much to say outside of his disillusionment with CSec. It just felt like we were having the same conversation over and over. And Liara wanted to pounce on me by our 2nd or 3rd conversation, which really put me off. I also think the Asari are my least favorite race, at least so far. Kind of an annoying character whom I don't care for at all.

 

Tali is okay, not the most fun to talk to but nothing I dislike about her either.

 

Very much looking forward to ME2.

[Barquiel]

1. Liara
2. Wrex
3. Garrus
4. Ashley
5. Kaidan
6. Tali

[Kenshen]

From just a story perspective it would be:

 

1.  Wrex

2.  Liara

3.  Garrus

 

I have zero interest in the others

[themikefest]

Ashley

Kaidan

Jenkins

Garrus

Wrex

Tali 

Liara

[Vazgen]

Kaidan

Tali

Wrex

Ashley

Garrus

Liara

 

If Jenkins is included he would've lower than Garrus but higher than Liara

[Livi14]

Liara/Wrex (don't make me choose) > Ashley/Garrus > Kaidan >>>>>> Tali