532 réponses à ce sujet

[BMcDill]

That was her name!  Thanks

[Hanako Ikezawa]

That was her name!  Thanks

No problem.

[Lord Raijin]

Why should anyone support the Chantry? They're so inhumane!

[wolfhowwl]

because they're the good guys.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Why should anyone support the Chantry? They're so inhumane!

This coming from a guy whose avatar is a person that blew up a civilian building full of innocent people, set a large city ablaze, and sacrificed an entire Circle to send a message.

[Kira_Sadi]

Why should anyone support the Chantry? They're so inhumane!

 

I have no love for the Chantry but you applying reasoning from this era not that one, it was hardly considered in humane back then but I understand where your coming form.

[Kira_Sadi]

This coming from a guy whose avatar is a person that blew up a civilian building full of innocent people, set a large city ablaze, and sacrificed an entire Circle to send a message.

 

in Anders defiance it wasn't his idea....kind of O.o....

[Hanako Ikezawa]

in Anders defiance it wasn't his idea....kind of O.o....

If you have him as a Friend, he is in complete control of his actions so yes it is. 

[Lord Raijin]

because they're the good guys.

 

Wrong. They're not the good guys.

 

This coming from a guy whose avatar is a person that blew up a civilian building full of innocent people, set a large city ablaze, and sacrificed an entire Circle to send a message.

 

Lets talk about how many people died for voicing against the Chantry? How many innocent lives had parish due to the fact that they do not want to live their lives under chantries rulings? Apostates are hunted because they wont submit to the Chantry, and apostate sympathizers are executed. Anders is a freedom fighter. The Chantry started the war against the mages, not the other way around. All of the blood is on their hands.

 

I have no love for the Chantry but you applying reasoning from this era not that one, it was hardly considered in humane back then but I understand where your coming form.

Doesn't matter. The Chantry has blood on their hands for all of the past crimes that they did against the mages. They deserve to burn down, or force those old ladies out and let the mages take control of it, and make it their new home.

[Saints]

Let's not make this into a Mage vs Chantry thread please.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Wrong. They're not the good guys.

Your opinion =/= fact. 

 

This is the Pro-Chantry thread. Go post in the Anti-Chantry thread. 

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Let's not make this into a Mage vs Chantry thread please.

I'm not. We all know this won't go anywhere, so why waste everyone's time right?

[Kira_Sadi]

Wrong. They're not the good guys.

 

 

Lets talk about how many people died for voicing against the Chantry? How many innocent lives had parish due to the fact that they do not want to live their lives under chantries rulings? Apostates are hunted because they wont submit to the Chantry, and apostate sympathizers are executed. Anders is a freedom fighter. The Chantry started the war against the mages, not the other way around. All of the blood is on their hands.

 

Doesn't matter. The Chantry has blood on their hands for all of the past crimes that they did against the mages. They deserve to burn down, or force those old ladies out and let the mages take control of it, and make it their new home.

 

the Chantry is not good I agree but it IS needed! the Chantry  is the only for lack of a better word School for magic granted they go to far most of the time. and yes that means I also think Templars are necessary if only to PROTECT Mages from themselves but that doesn't mean locking then in a tower.

 

and as for having blood on there hands so do mages who go ta far!  

[BloodyTalon]

Given who the right hand and the left hand of the divcine are hope so.

[Exaltation]

"Faith" is for the weak minded.

[Lord Raijin]

Your opinion =/= fact. 

 

This is the Pro-Chantry thread. Go post in the Anti-Chantry thread. 

 

That's why I'm here

[Hanako Ikezawa]

That's why I'm here

This thread is for those who have positive things to say about the Chantry. You have shown you don't. Thus you are offtopic. 

[Lord Raijin]

the Chantry is not good I agree but it IS needed! the Chantry  is the only for lack of a better word School for magic granted they go to far most of the time. and yes that means I also think Templars are necessary if only to PROTECT Mages from themselves but that doesn't mean locking then in a tower.

 

and as for having blood on there hands so do mages who go ta far!  

 

Explain to me why the Chantry is needed? All they've done was create chaos and wars. They created discriminatory of a class who are different, and spreads fear about them to the public so they can gain their full support of doing what they do in the name of the Maker. They're nothing more than a bunch of bullies. Instead of helping mages they imprison them and create resentments.

[Kira_Sadi]

Explain to me why the Chantry is needed? All they've done was create chaos and wars. They created discriminatory of a class who are different, and spreads fear about them to the public so they can gain their full support of doing what they do in the name of the Maker. They're nothing more than a bunch of bullies. Instead of helping mages they imprison them and create resentments.

 

I already said Why re read my post and my other reasons have nothing to do with mages so there not relevant
 

[Nimlowyn]

I'd like this option, and I think its one we're likely to have. I've yet to play a religious character, but I think playing a devout Andrastian mage or elf would be interesting.

[Saints]

I'm not. We all know this won't go anywhere, so why waste everyone's time right?

Because it still happens anyway. I mean, it's already happening to the other thread.

[Lord Raijin]

This thread is for those who have positive things to say about the Chantry. You have shown you don't. Thus you are offtopic. 

 

Ok lets go on topic, shall we? Now elaborate to me why I (As an anti Chantry and a staunch mage player) should support them after what they've done to the Mages? Can you give me some positive things that they've done? I can only thing of 1 thing, to their credit. Divine Justinia V in Asunder.

[Saints]

Ok lets go on topic, shall we? Now elaborate to me why I (As an anti Chantry and a staunch mage player) should support them after what they've done to the Mages? Can you give me some positive things that they've done? I can only thing of 1 thing, to their credit. Divine Justinia V in Asunder.

The topic is actually asking if we can support it, not why should we support it.

[Hanako Ikezawa]

Ok lets go on topic, shall we? Now elaborate to me why I (As an anti Chantry and a staunch mage player) should support them after what they've done to the Mages? Can you give me some positive things that they've done? I can only thing of 1 thing, to their credit. Divine Justinia V in Asunder.

Well, besides the services their allies the Templars do which are protect people from actually dangerous mages and magic-related things as well as protect mages from things like angry mobs:

 

Chantries deliver practical services to the community, caring for the sick and collecting alms for the poor. The Chantry provides hospitality to travelers and a public network of communications. Should an illiterate commoner need to send word to another town, the Chantry's educated priests write and send the letter for him.

[wolfhowwl]

Ok lets go on topic, shall we? Now elaborate to me why I (As an anti Chantry and a staunch mage player) should support them after what they've done to the Mages? Can you give me some positive things that they've done? I can only thing of 1 thing, to their credit. Divine Justinia V in Asunder.

No. How about you get the Right of Annulment invoked instead, mage scum.