-More hair styles all around. African hair, beards, sideburns, braids. At least 30 styles, preferably 50 or more, not gated by gender. No restrictions on color and the option to add highlights. Hair elements that can be added separately to the hairstyle, like a padawan braid added to a pixie cut or ornaments that can be placed in the hair.
-Complexion options. Scars galore, beauty marks, FRECKLES(!!!), burns, laugh lines, bags under the eyes, pockmarks... And make it so that we can have multiple selections from the multiple options - at least three - so we can have a big scar, freckles(!!!), and a tiny scar all at the same time.
-Tattoos. Far more options for tattoos and war paint, and not just on the face either. Let us slap them on our arms and legs as well, and our chests and backs if there are armor/clothing options that could show parts of our ink.
-Better presets. Option 1 for any race tends to be pretty good, but the rest of the faces are nearly always composed of randomness and derp. Give us multiple starting points and make sure none of them look like they're missing chromosomes. And give us multiple starting points for various ethnicities as well.
-More slider control. Yes, I like having preset eyes, noses, mouths, etc. to start from, but I like having more control over them than just size and spacing. Let me play with the nose sellion, the eye depth, and the angle of my elf ears. I don't mind if there aren't extremes, but I do like being able to fine-tune