40 réponses à ce sujet

[AkiKishi]

I did this for the romance stats on another thread and someone asked for the other stats, so here they are. I suggest you look up PS3 trophies org or something similar since I'm only posting the names, not what they trophy means.

•  
• Ultimate Reward 1.4%
• Last of your line 55.7%
• Corrupted 27.9%
• Conscripted 21.7%
• Harrowed 37.5%
• Casteless 15.6%
• Kinslayer 16.6%
• Last of the Wardens 72.8% (meaning almost 30% of players never got to Ostigar)
• Standard Bearer 35.5%
• Hero of Redcliffe 42.1%
• Rabble Rouser 33.0%
• Mercenary 23%
• Recruiter 10.3 %
• Hopelessly Romantic 3.5% (That's players who did all possible LI's).
• Perfectionist 10%
• Educated 33.7%
• Ultimate Sacrifice 16.8% (ending)
• Dark Promise 24.3% (ending)
• Magic Sympathiser 39.8% 
• Annulment Invoker 19.9%
• Slayer 6.8%
• Poacher 44.8%
• Sacrilegious 14.2%
• Ceremonist 41.4%
• Bhelens Ally 17%
• Harrowmonts Ally 31.8%
• Liberator 33%
• Pragmatist 15.2%
• Heavy Hitter 13.3%
• Bloodied 77.2%
• Traveler 11%
• Master of Arms 16%
• Shadow 13.1% Archmage 10.1%
• Dragon Slayer 22.8%
• Pilgrim 60.1%
• Grey Warden 65.1%
• Master Warden 24.8%
• Blight Queller 12%
• Defender 29.5%
• Tinkerer 47.8%
• Pursuasive 44.5%
• Silver Tongue 20.2%
• Bully 28.5%
• Menacing 11.3%
• First Knight 8.6%
• Witch Gone Wild 24%
• Easy Lover 10.1%
• Wine Women and Song 11.8%
• Veteran 46.6%
• Elite 38.3%

[metatheurgist]

• Hopelessly Romantic 3.5% (That's players who did all possible LI's).
• First Knight 8.6%
• Witch Gone Wild 24%
• Easy Lover 10.1%
• Wine Women and Song 11.8%

Ha! I think that puts those claims that romance is a huge part of the game to the sword.

[Andraste_Reborn]

What I find most curious is that this doesn't match up with what David Gaider has said about Zevran being the least popular love interest. (And I thought that someone, somewhere, had said that Leliana was the most popular? Although my google-fu failed to turn up a reference for that one.) Do people who played on PlayStation just not like Alistair for some reason ...?

 

The percentage of people who got the dwarf origin trophies is also way, way higher than I would have expected, given what has been said about the percentages of players that chose each race.

[NoForgiveness]

Ha! I think that puts those claims that romance is a huge part of the game to the sword.

 

Not at all... if my calculations(yes im a nerd) are correct. Then this means that at the very least 24% of people romanced and at the most 54.5% have. Now combine this with the fact that almost 30% of people never finished ostagar and 41.1% have finished the game(2 ending trophies combined) and that leaves the number of people who romanced higher then the number of people who finished the game or basically equal to. Its shocking what one can do when they think for a second right?

[jlb524]

What I find most curious is that this doesn't match up with what David Gaider has said about Zevran being the least popular love interest. (And I thought that someone, somewhere, had said that Leliana was the most popular? Although my google-fu failed to turn up a reference for that one.) Do people who played on PlayStation just not like Alistair for some reason ...?

 

The percentage of people who got the dwarf origin trophies is also way, way higher than I would have expected, given what has been said about the percentages of players that chose each race.

 

I think these are just for the PS3 and not reflective of the stats BW would have access to (for all platforms).  

[AlanC9]

I think these are just for the PS3 and not reflective of the stats BW would have access to (for all platforms).

True. It'd be interesting to see the differences. The ME2 tracking data showed differences between console and PC playstyles.

[AlanC9]

Now combine this with the fact that almost 30% of people never finished ostagar and 41.1% have finished the game(2 ending trophies combined)

Two ending trophies aren't on the list. I don't see Perfectionist either.

Do you get The Ultimate Sacrifice whoever dies in the ending? Meaning, do you get both TUS and Warden Commander if Alistair dies?

[berelinde]

Two ending trophies aren't on the list. I don't see Perfectionist either.

Do you get The Ultimate Sacrifice whoever dies in the ending? Meaning, do you get both TUS and Warden Commander if Alistair dies?

You only get US if the Warden refuses the Dark Ritual and kills the archdemon personally. If Alistair dies, you get Warden Commander, but no US.

[NoForgiveness]

There is no warden commander on ps. Im fairly certain you get US for having Alistair/Loghain kill it.

[Wulfram]

What I find most curious is that this doesn't match up with what David Gaider has said about Zevran being the least popular love interest. (And I thought that someone, somewhere, had said that Leliana was the most popular? Although my google-fu failed to turn up a reference for that one.) Do people who played on PlayStation just not like Alistair for some reason ...?

 

You get the trophies for sleeping with an LI, which is quite a bit easier for Zev/Morri than it is for the other two.

 

Not at all... if my calculations(yes im a nerd) are correct. Then this means that at the very least 24% of people romanced and at the most 54.5% have. Now combine this with the fact that almost 30% of people never finished ostagar and 41.1% have finished the game(2 ending trophies combined) and that leaves the number of people who romanced higher then the number of people who finished the game or basically equal to. Its shocking what one can do when they think for a second right?

 

The amount that finished is at most 33%, the number that completed the Landsmeet

[Nefla]

I have all of them (plus DLCs and Awakening) except "enthralling" I didn't want to play darkspawn chronicles again :/

[AlanC9]

You only get US if the Warden refuses the Dark Ritual and kills the archdemon personally. If Alistair dies, you get Warden Commander, but no US.

That's what I thought. Anyway, the 41.1 % figure doesn't work since one player can have both. I see Wulfram already caught that.

[AlanC9]

There is no warden commander on ps. Im fairly certain you get US for having Alistair/Loghain kill it.

Maybe because DA:O PC had too many achievements?

[NoForgiveness]

Maybe because DA:O PC had too many achievements?

 

maybe. could also be they replaced warden commander with the platinum. Idk if that is on the xbox/pc...
 

[Wulfram]

So about 3/4 of those who finished did the ritual at least once, 1/2 did the US at least once.

 

98% of people who cured Arl Eamon left the Urn untainted at least once.  Which perhaps explains why Leliana's "death" didn't take

 

Between 13% and 15% of those who completed the Dalish quest decided to kill the Dalish (13% assumes that no one got both "Slayer" and "Poacher", 15% assumes that everyone who got "Slayer" also got "Poacher".  Obviously, the truth is going to be somewhere in between)

 

41% of those who romanced Alistair romanced all the others

[metatheurgist]

Not at all... if my calculations(yes im a nerd) are correct. Then this means that at the very least 24% of people romanced and at the most 54.5% have. Now combine this with the fact that almost 30% of people never finished ostagar and 41.1% have finished the game(2 ending trophies combined) and that leaves the number of people who romanced higher then the number of people who finished the game or basically equal to. Its shocking what one can do when they think for a second right?

Given the possible combinations of girl/guy, girl/girl, guy/guy romances and the diehard romantics playing every romance and doubling and tripling up. The only reliable figure I see is 24%. Which is low (and the one everyone calls a betrayal!). Whether they finish the game or not is irrelevant, since the romances can be completed before the game.

[In Exile]

Given the possible combinations of girl/guy, girl/girl, guy/guy romances and the diehard romantics playing every romance and doubling and tripling up. The only reliable figure I see is 24%. Which is low (and the one everyone calls a betrayal!). Whether they finish the game or not is irrelevant, since the romances can be completed before the game.

 

The fact that 41% finished the game is a huge deal, because that would suggest by your logic that having an ending isn't popular, since less than 50% of the players even cared to see it. 

[AlanC9]

And, again, 41% is an overcount. The real figure can't be higher than 33%. I find it hard to imagine that many people got all the way to the Landsmeet and didn't finish the game, so I figure 33% is probably fairly close to the real figure.

[metatheurgist]

The fact that 41% finished the game is a huge deal, because that would suggest by your logic that having an ending isn't popular, since less than 50% of the players even cared to see it.

It's true, apparently a majority of people didn't bother to finish the game (maybe because they didn't like it? Given the large number of posts wanting Bioware to write action games and change their formula?) and an even larger number didn't bother with romance. Be interesting to see the figure for DA2.

[AkiKishi]

It's true, apparently a majority of people didn't bother to finish the game (maybe because they didn't like it? Given the large number of posts wanting Bioware to write action games and change their formula?) and an even larger number didn't bother with romance. Be interesting to see the figure for DA2.

 

Again only applies to the PS3 version but here you go.

 

Flirtatious (started a a romance) 46.6 % 

Romantic (concluded a romance , ie saw the sex scene) 24.4% 

 

Champion of Kirkwall (finished the game) 37%

[AlanC9]

The DAO figure that surprises me is the 37% of players who played through Ostagar but didn't finish the Landsmeet. Aren't the origins long enough to figure if you'll like the rest of the game? Or was DAO just too damn long?

 

I see that DA2's completion figure is a bit better than DAO's, which is something Bio folks have said on occasion.

[In Exile]

It's true, apparently a majority of people didn't bother to finish the game (maybe because they didn't like it? Given the large number of posts wanting Bioware to write action games and change their formula?) and an even larger number didn't bother with romance. Be interesting to see the figure for DA2.

 

My point is just that going by % of players that viewed the content isn't useful, because by that logic you'd have an equally good argument the game shouldn't even have an ending, it should just cut to black at some point. 

[AkiKishi]

My point is just that going by % of players that viewed the content isn't useful, because by that logic you'd have an equally good argument the game shouldn't even have an ending, it should just cut to black at some point. 

 

So that's where Mass Effect 3 came from  

 

Joking aside. It's more useful when it comes to side content and difficulty. While we know that 63% of people never finished DA2, we don't know why. It could be that they got bored, or it could be that the game was just beyond their abilities. 

If you look at the JRPG stats the rate of platinum is far higher (10-15%) and the completion rate is almost 100% , the logical conclusion being that more core gamers play these games and they have the skillz needed.

 

Even Ni No Kuni which takes 100's of hours and TON of grinding to complete has a plat rating of 2.5% (I'll check the completion rating next time I'm on the PS4). 

[Andraste_Reborn]

I don't find the figures about how many people finished the game especially surprising - in my gamer-heavy social circle, there are eight people who played DAO. Only two of us finished it. (And the other guy only finished it once. I'm the statistical outlier who played the whole thing nine times.)

 

Apparently this is not unusual - on average, most people don't finish most games. I find this incomprehensible, since I'm compelled to finish any game I've played for more than an hour or so, but there it is.

[AkiKishi]

Mass Effect 3 is slightly higher 38 something.Assassins Creed2 is around 50 % (48.?%) 

 

I left off 4 since I only own the PS4 version and I don't own 3.