21 réponses à ce sujet

[JasonPogo]

So I was thinking about this today.  If Bioware would give us the option to play as a Silent Sister it would be perfect for me.  I love Dwarves and HATE the voiced protagonist.  So with a Silent Sister I get to play my Dwarf and there is a built in excuse to use a Silent protagonist.  Make it happen Bioware!

[Dubya75]

Nope, not gonna happen.

[smoke and mirrors]

I would rather be a Legion Of The Dead , BW can come up with a good excuse as to why i am not in the Deep Roads .

[Zazzerka]

So do you like... gesture or something?

 

Cassandra: "Inquisitor, we're surrounded! What do we do?!"

 

Inquisitor:

[SerCambria358]

You can mute your TV

 

Seriously though how would you communicate? No one would follow a mute

[Pateu]

Play Dragon Age Origins.

 

Or, well, mute your PC and pretend your character is doing sign language.

[Kimberly]

We haven't heard the American voice yet have we? You may like it better then the Brittish one.

[Sylvius the Mad]

Play Dragon Age Origins.

Or, well, mute your PC and pretend your character is doing sign language.

BioWare has yet to allow us to mute the PC without muting the other characters.

Personally, I'd like to mute the PC and turn off the subtitles. If I could still hear the NPCs then the game would play almost like DAO.

[Cutlass Jack]

The Inquisition: "We have ways to make you talk...just don't ask us to talk back."

[JasonPogo]

It amazes me that people took this so seriously. I was mostly joking with this suggestion. While yes I would LOVE for them to implement it I don't expect that it ever would be.

[Dubya75]

It amazes me that people took this so seriously. I was mostly joking with this suggestion. While yes I would LOVE for them to implement it I don't expect that it ever would be.

 

Didn't you know we don't tolerate joking here, serah?

[DarthLaxian]

So I was thinking about this today.  If Bioware would give us the option to play as a Silent Sister it would be perfect for me.  I love Dwarves and HATE the voiced protagonist.  So with a Silent Sister I get to play my Dwarf and there is a built in excuse to use a Silent protagonist.  Make it happen Bioware!

 

Hey...

 

I don't like this idea (partly because I think someone cutting out his tongue is crazy to put it mildly (completely bonkers, three fries short of a happy meal etc. is more like it))

 

I would love the mute protag back, too but I would not want to go down this route to get it (I don't play crazy characters...)

 

greetings LAX

[Deebo305]

So I was thinking about this today. If Bioware would give us the option to play as a Silent Sister it would be perfect for me. I love Dwarves and HATE the voiced protagonist. So with a Silent Sister I get to play my Dwarf and there is a built in excuse to use a Silent protagonist. Make it happen Bioware!

You realize they don't talk at all right? Not sure what good a leader who gestures and points would do

[In Exile]

BioWare has yet to allow us to mute the PC without muting the other characters.

Personally, I'd like to mute the PC and turn off the subtitles. If I could still hear the NPCs then the game would play almost like DAO.

 

Bioware could just give a silent option. TellTale games have done this without really radically altering their cinematics - often the NPC just keeps talking as if you haven't said anything. 

[thats1evildude]

Bioware could just give a silent option. TellTale games have done this without really radically altering their cinematics - often the NPC just keeps talking as if you haven't said anything.

But the silent option is still, in most cases, a response in and of itself, especially when NPCs ask you a question. For instance, when Beast asks Bigby about Beauty in TWAU, he interprets your silence as hostility.

[Trikormadenadon]

So I was thinking about this today.  If Bioware would give us the option to play as a Silent Sister it would be perfect for me.  I love Dwarves and HATE the voiced protagonist.  So with a Silent Sister I get to play my Dwarf and there is a built in excuse to use a Silent protagonist.  Make it happen Bioware!

Interesting idea however with all the effort of VA's in the game and the magnitude and complexity that will likely be involved with running the inquisition I don't see it happening.

[NoForgiveness]

I don't get the fascination with a silent protagonist. I mean, Its not like having the silent protagonist allows you to write your own lines. Bioware still wrote all the pc lines in origins. And now there's customization for the pc's voice. So its not like anyone will be stuck with a voice they hate(like I was with male hawke), unless I suppose they hate both. In which case... tough ****?  The only actual problem I see is not actually with the voice but the dialogue wheel/paraphrasing and all that. 

[Pasquale1234]

Love the idea, OP - but I doubt it would ever happen.

 

Bioware has chosen to make their games very cinematic, which means you will be watching and listening to the PC as much as actually playing the character.  It does tend to put a damper on that initial golden playthrough, when all of the content is fresh and new, at least for me.  Since I never know what the character will say or do, I find I have to attempt a few plays to figure out who the character is before I can attempt to really role-play them.

 

 

[DaySeeker]

I would like to see the silent sisters in the game. Especially if they were sistas-even better. They could be the silent sister/sisters. If they got the taint the could be twisted sisters.

[aTigerslunch]

@Exile  I find situations like that in real life, then I butt in.