Aller au contenu

Photo

Solas Thread - NOW OFFICIALLY MOVED to Cyonan's BSN (link in OP)


153434 réponses à ce sujet

#61226
phyreblade74

phyreblade74
  • Members
  • 951 messages

Popping in because I literally just saw this and thought it may be helpful to the Blight-dissection discussion (sorry if old!); 

 

tumblr_ni5net9eRQ1qlzndvo1_540.jpg

source: http://irabelas.tumblr.com/

 

Also I'll be away for a few days! Have fun, maintain the blanketfort and be excellent to eachother Solasmancers!  :lol:

 

Leaving a previously withheld personal report of my Solas experience behind:

Spoiler

 

There are no words.  Hug and hug some more.


  • Sister Squish aime ceci

#61227
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

If this is the case, then shouldn't Solas be happy the wardens are trying to kill the old gods *before* they're corrupted?

 

I mean, sure the actual plan wasn't gonna work cus Cory was ultimately behind it. But Solas seems to object to the idea of killing Old Gods at all. Or at least killing them in their sleep while untainted. He implies it will lead to unforseen consequences. 

Good point. Unless killing them at all is enough to reach their goal.

 

The unforseen consequences likely goes back to this:

 

http://dragonage.wik...d_Elven_Writing

 


"In this place we prepare to hunt the pillars of the Earth. Their workers scurry, witless, soulless. This death will be a mercy. We will make the earth blossom with their passing." For one moment there is a vivid image of two overlapping spheres; unknown flowers bloom inside their centers. Then it fades.

 

Old gods being the pillars and workers being the darkspawn.

 


  • AlleluiaElizabeth aime ceci

#61228
Rabbitonfire

Rabbitonfire
  • Members
  • 2 052 messages

If this is the case, then shouldn't Solas be happy the wardens are trying to kill the old gods *before* they're corrupted?

 

I mean, sure the actual plan wasn't gonna work cus Cory was ultimately behind it. But Solas seems to object to the idea of killing Old Gods at all. Or at least killing them in their sleep while untainted. He implies it will lead to unforseen consequences. 

 

It amuses me that no one in that crowd at the top of that pic looks happy. lol Solas is angst.

I tried my best to capture the essence of the thread. To be fair, there are some people on here who like Solas as a character and not as a romanced love interest. 

 

edit: and sometimes there are disagreements in various subjects.



#61229
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

*blinks*

 

Wait.  You're saying you're starting from the assumption that the Archdemons and the Old Gods are not the same thing?

 

That's... ugh, a lot of back theory to have to write up to counter your foundation there.  Think I'm just going to leave it be.   

 

No, they are, lol, I'm just saying that in the text, they weren't tainted. A tainted old god is what humans call an archdemon. Looking too much into it ;)



#61230
Siha

Siha
  • Members
  • 2 375 messages

If this is the case, then shouldn't Solas be happy the wardens are trying to kill the old gods *before* they're corrupted?

Why would he approve of "mass" murder?

Besides, it would mean killing "his people" and leaving him all alone. I don't see how this would be appealing?

ALSO, so far I have seen no evidence that an old god could actually be killed. Killing the archdemon always only led to the old god soul leaving the body and finding another vessel. I don't yet see how the Wardens would kill souls anyway. Go there, yes. Have a demon army, yes. And then? What do you do? How do you kill a soul? I did not get the impression they had actually thought that plan through all too carefully.



#61231
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

I'm getting closer to my answer, I suppose: Who says so where? Maybe that liquid lyrium is important, I do not want to have missed it.

Addai gave the text last time. The other one I'll see in a bit.



#61232
AlleluiaElizabeth

AlleluiaElizabeth
  • Members
  • 2 069 messages

I don't believe the wardens are trying to kill them before they are corrupted? They already know where the old gods are, but the area is always swarmed with Darkspawn. So they just wait until the corruption occurs.

 

[Regardless, I doubt killing the uncorrupted dragons would help much either unfortunately.] 

Normally, they aren't trying to do that, no. Cus its just too hard to get in there to do it to be worth it.  

 

But in Inquisition, that was Clarel's plan. Cus she thought that all the Wardens were gonna die out at once and she decided to try to end the threat of future blights by taking out the remaining old gods now, regardless of their current unblighted status. And they were gonna get past the obstacle of the teeming darkspawn around them via use of their own demon army.


  • Mims aime ceci

#61233
Siha

Siha
  • Members
  • 2 375 messages

Wait.  You're saying you're starting from the assumption that the Archdemons and the Old Gods are not the same thing?

Is he wrong? I always understood it that way. That the archdemon is just a corrupted dragon's body (I know, that is Dragon's Dogma terminology, but it fits) that harbors an old god soul. No?


  • Colonelkillabee aime ceci

#61234
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

Why would he approve of "mass" murder?

Besides, it would mean killing "his people" and leaving him all alone. I don't see how this would be appealing?

ALSO, so far I have seen no evidence that an old god could actually be killed. Killing the archdemon always only led to the old god soul leaving the body and finding another vessel. I don't yet see how the Wardens would kill souls anyway. Go there, yes. Have a demon army, yes. And then? What do you do? How do you kill a soul? I did not get the impression they had actually thought that plan through all too carefully.

 

Personally I think the old gods without the taint are weak enough to be killed, like Solas and mythal are supposedly now, minus Mythal trickery like she did with the amulet. I think Corypheus shows that they gain power when tainted. He got his directly from the black city though, which made a human into a god, while the old gods are already. So just being tainted is enough.



#61235
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Good point. Unless killing them at all is enough to reach their goal.

 

The unforseen consequences likely goes back to this:

 

http://dragonage.wik...d_Elven_Writing

 

 

 

Old gods being the pillars and workers being the darkspawn.

 

That's clearly what you're supposed to think, but it's not an entirely satisfying fit (what are the "flowers" in this scenario?) and should be discarded as obvious bait.

 

I believe the Titans are the intended reference to the "pillars of the world".  The workers are the dwarven race, their "mindlessness" a reference to their early hive mind connection to the Stone.  Spreading red lyrium in both the physical world and the fade (the overlapping circles) is the objective.  No immune system, disease spreads like wildfire.  Stone succumbs.  Sun wins.  Everyone else loses.  No?



#61236
Little Mama

Little Mama
  • Members
  • 423 messages

I think it's a shame that Solas wasn't there during the Wicked Grace scene. I wonder..did they invite him to play and he declined or did they not even bother?  He looks like he's having so much fun in this picture.

 

http://mariagrantz.d...ullen-509009844

 

He was busy painting?

 

That's almost as possible as meeting the maker

 

 

And who says that's impossible/so unlikely? We've already been allowed to do that once in ME3



#61237
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

That's clearly what you're supposed to think, but it's not an entirely satisfying fit (what are the "flowers" in this scenario?) and should be discarded as obvious bait.

 

I believe the Titans are the intended reference to the "pillars of the world".  The workers are the dwarven race, their "mindlessness" a reference to their early hive mind connection to the Stone.  Spreading red lyrium in both the physical world and the fade (the overlapping circles) is the objective.  No immune system, disease spreads like wildfire.  Stone succumbs.  Sun wins.  Everyone else loses.  No?

Personally I like to keep things simple until I have good enough reason to think otherwise. Solas' reaction combined with that's a good enough fit for me. The flowers blossoming to me is new life being born. The combination of magic with all living things creating what wasn't there after the fade was split from thedas.

 

In other words, immortality returns.

 

It's just a theory, you're all fine to dismiss or accept ;)


  • Ajna aime ceci

#61238
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Is he wrong? I always understood it that way. That the archdemon is just a corrupted dragon's body (I know, that is Dragon's Dogma terminology, but it fits) that harbors an old god soul. No?

 

No, that's completely correct- but it sounded like he thought one of the OGSes was hanging out bodiless.   Without its dragon vehicle.  It's not exactly impossible- as Mythal demonstrates several times over the course of history- but at the very least, it would be an extremely poor fit for what the Wardens encounter in the Deep Roads.  Souls trapped on the physical side of the world, even Pantheon OGS ones, have relatively very weak will, very weak Song.  Given what we think we know about Song and the DA universe, it doesn't seem possible a 'free' unblighted OGS could be that loud.  



#61239
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

It's just a theory, you're all fine to dismiss or accept ;)

 

Yeah, think we're going to have to shake hands and walk away at this point.  ^w^   No worries.



#61240
Siha

Siha
  • Members
  • 2 375 messages

No, that's completely correct- but it sounded like he thought one of the OGSes was hanging out bodiless.   Without its dragon vehicle.  It's not exactly impossible- as Mythal demonstrates several times over the course of history- but at the very least, it would be an extremely poor fit for what the Wardens encounter in the Deep Roads.  Souls trapped on the physical side of the world, even Pantheon OGS ones, have relatively very weak will, very weak Song.  Given what we think we know about Song and the DA universe, it doesn't seem possible a 'free' unblighted OGS could be that loud.  

To be honest, I've never thought about this. I had just taken it as given that "the song" is emitted by the old god souls. :blush:



#61241
Pinax

Pinax
  • Members
  • 139 messages

Personally I think the old gods without the taint are weak enough to be killed, like Solas and mythal are supposedly now, minus Mythal trickery like she did with the amulet. I think Corypheus shows that they gain power when tainted. He got his directly from the black city though, which made a human into a god, while the old gods are already. So just being tainted is enough.

 

I think Grey Wardens being able to kill the Archdemon has something to do with a tainted soul jumping into a non-darkspawn body. Maybe again this something to do with the blood, like tainted soul not able to suffer the non tainted warden's blood, effect for 2 parties: death.

 

Only choice to preserve the soul, but cure the taint => Morrigan and her ritual.



#61242
jellobell

jellobell
  • Members
  • 3 001 messages

Leaving a previously withheld personal report of my Solas experience behind:

Spoiler

 

qWPyYwY.gif

 

And if we're still doing Solavellan dances, the chemistry and passion in this one is absolutely perfect. That kiss~

 


  • Sister Squish et k_drake aiment ceci

#61243
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 467 messages

To be honest, I've never thought about this. I had just taken it as given that "the song" is emitted by the old god souls. :blush:

That's what I figured. While they're asleep, their minds are the only things active. The wardens said the song was that loud. No longer just in their head on their search as they approached the old god.

 

I'll have to find the text.



#61244
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

I think Grey Wardens being able to kill the Archdemon has something to do with a tainted soul jumping into a non-darkspawn body. Maybe again this something to do with the blood, like tainted soul not able to suffer the non tainted warden's blood, effect for 2 parties: death.

 

Only choice to preserve the soul, but cure the taint => Morrigan and her ritual.

 

I think we're well past the point of believing that OGSes get obliterated by Warden death, though. ...assuming you're on board with Andruil = Sera and June = Sandal?  

 

The Dark Ritual was a way to avoid the song/memory-cleansing effect of a soul passing through the veil, preserving Ghil's "self" as well as her core OGS.  That's the key difference between the two.  (Further underscored via its connection to Mythal's unbroken sense of self as she passes from daughter to daughter- she doesn't get redirected via the Fade.  No loss of Song, no loss of self.)  Make sense?



#61245
LliiraAnna

LliiraAnna
  • Members
  • 495 messages
That's what I figured. While they're asleep, their minds are the only things active. The wardens said the song was that loud. No longer just in their head on their search as they approached the old god.

 

I'll have to find the text.

 

tumblr_nghqvd3ukx1ts23yuo1_1280.jpg

 

This one?


  • AlleluiaElizabeth, Colonelkillabee et KarateKats aiment ceci

#61246
Ser_Lurk

Ser_Lurk
  • Members
  • 27 messages

I have been wondering about Loranil's comment. Since the Dalish, and I quote, "Dalish clans rarely encounter each other in order to protect themselves; their diaspora is as much of a blessing as is a curse. Since Dalish don't—if ever—keep in contact between other clans...", does his comment mean that the Dalish have recently hold a Arlathvhen after the Breach opened? 

 

There are Dalish agents and emissaries at Skyhold, such as Cillian and Neria. They likely send news back to their clans.

 

It's not unprecedented for clans to be in contact with each other during a crisis. During the Fifth Blight, Zathrian's clan sent runners to contact the other clans in Ferelden. They banded together to help fight the Archdemon. The Breach is an extraordinary circumstance. It would make sense that the Dalish are contacting each other for information, and discussing what (if anything) they should be doing about the Breach and the Inquisition.


  • Tielis, LobselVith8 et dragondreamer aiment ceci

#61247
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

<snip>

 

This one?

 

That's probably the reference killabee is looking for.  I hate to underscore the Wardens' ignorance here, but they have no idea what they're dealing with and are trying to fit what they're encountering into a context that makes sense given how they think the world works.  Unfortunately for them and their whole plan to save the world by killing off Archdemons, they're very much mistaken.  

 

*rubs her temples* 

 

ugh, this requires multi-page theory to get into, and I'm still in bed with flu.   I promised we'd shake and go our separate ways.   Sticking to it.    



#61248
drake2511

drake2511
  • Members
  • 907 messages

Popping in because I literally just saw this and thought it may be helpful to the Blight-dissection discussion (sorry if old!);

tumblr_ni5net9eRQ1qlzndvo1_540.jpg
source: http://irabelas.tumblr.com/

Also I'll be away for a few days! Have fun, maintain the blanketfort and be excellent to eachother Solasmancers! :lol:

Leaving a previously withheld personal report of my Solas experience behind:

Spoiler


I'm so glad you found some comfort here. <3 *hugs*
  • Ser_Lurk et Sister Squish aiment ceci

#61249
slmisfit

slmisfit
  • Members
  • 526 messages

Where would one find such a backup? Because I'll probably not read all of it till next Friday.

http://www.reddit.co..._download_here/



#61250
Pinax

Pinax
  • Members
  • 139 messages

I think we're well past the point of believing that OGSes get obliterated by Warden death, though. ...assuming you're on board with Andruil = Sera and June = Sandal?  

 

The Dark Ritual was a way to avoid the song/memory-cleansing effect of a soul passing through the veil, preserving Ghil's "self" as well as her core OGS.  That's the key difference between the two.  (Further underscored via its connection to Mythal's unbroken sense of self as she passes from daughter to daughter- she doesn't get redirected via the Fade.  No loss of Song, no loss of self.)  Make sense?

 

To be honest, I do believe the gaming world allows to have things "lost forever", OGS as one of them.

 

Makes sense though, even if not too in line with my headcanon.