It really is the flaws in his character which make him so intriguing for me.
Solas Thread - NOW OFFICIALLY MOVED to Cyonan's BSN (link in OP)
#28902
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 02:13
He's a great character for all of those flaws! One of my favorite things about him is that he talks as if he's a different elf, like he's learned from his past experiences and is wiser and more understanding.
But then he says certain things and acts rashly still and I'm just like "Are you, Solas? Are you really?"
For a "god", or at least an immortal being that has lived for a long, long time, he's painfully human(elf/qunari/dwarf) ain't he?
- Nyaore, caridounette, Mims et 3 autres aiment ceci
#28903
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 02:23
It's pretty graphic but not as much as I intended. My last fic included Sebastian, Anders, Lady Hawke, and marble statue. THAT was graphic. Hahah.
NSFW.
- Sable Rhapsody, Lillian Sword-Maiden, madrar et 14 autres aiment ceci
#28904
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 02:35
Alright so. I'm done and thought I'd share. It's really, really rough, I haven't had anyone look at it or edit it or check it for grammar or spelling but it's late and now I'm..well, now I have to go find my husband. For reasons.
NSFW.
Spoiler
Oh my~
You captured his tone of voice perfectly, so good!
- Lillian Sword-Maiden, Nyaore, Seregwen et 4 autres aiment ceci
#28906
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 02:38
So did anyone else get completely taken in by Solas during their first game and then rather maliciously go and check his stats to see what his cunning was. I did when I rolled my Solas-romancing rogue and pretty much just said 'yeah - not nearly as clever as you think you are, babe!' ![]()
I know it's all gameplay/story segregation really but I felt much better about things after doing so anyway. ![]()
- nightwolf667 et Renmiri1 aiment ceci
#28908
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:15
This ain't Solas, but I saw this on Tumblr and I figured that the sentiment still applies.
- nightwolf667 et Birdy aiment ceci
#28909
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:19
This banter with Solas sounds HILARIOUS out of context!
http://darthempress....nce-featuring-a
Also, his laugh at the end.
I love the little snort at the end of it, so cute!
- slmisfit, Doveberry, Nyaore et 12 autres aiment ceci
#28910
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:23
This banter with Solas sounds HILARIOUS out of context!
http://darthempress....nce-featuring-a
Also, his laugh at the end.I love the little snort at the end of it, so cute!
*dead*
#28911
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:25
This banter with Solas sounds HILARIOUS out of context!
http://darthempress....nce-featuring-a
Also, his laugh at the end.
I love the little snort at the end of it, so cute!
"Sleep well?" He says in the smuggest of voices. Damn you, Solas. ![]()
- Tielis, Nyaore, Seregwen et 8 autres aiment ceci
#28912
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:33
Yeah but,
Spoiler
Lavellan may have no clue, but if she has arcane knowledge from the Secrets perk, she knows it will make her a slave to the will of the people who left their wisdom behind in the Well. Even if Mythal doesn't exist, she would still be enslaved. And being strong-willed doesn't mean you'll be able to defy the orders of a god when you are under a compulsion to do so. My concern about how it may harm a relationship came from the thought that we don't know if the obedience to the will of Mythal is something automatic or only done on command. If it's automatic, then Lavellan may do whatever the voices of the Well think is most appropriate to the will of Mythal.
Spoiler
Solas might be able to free Lavellan, it's true. But, he also might not. And if he had the power, what's to say he can even prevent using it? As I said above, it might just be automatic--the Well's voices forcing Lavellan to do whatever they think Mythal wants. Consent could be a potentially major issue, and without consent it is not a relationship. Not to mention that Solas would hate having slaves, especially someone he respects and cares about as much as he does Lavellan.
Spoiler
This is an interesting insight, and yet considering what Cole says about the Inquisitor being "bright" even beyond the Mark, I sort of have a sneaking suspicion that either Solas is literally able to see people's souls, or he means a literal spirit of wisdom (but doesn't share that, lest Lavellan not be aware of it). It's hard to say. Still, it very well could be he's afraid he's inadvertently made Lavellan more like himself--which would mean that his attraction might be false, or narcissistic.
Spoiler
Forget DLC where you can meet him again, I want DLC that puts him permanently back into my party post-game. Barring that, modders, help me out here!
Maybe it's because... the Dalish don't have bed-beds? Maybe? Or chairs. Well, not throne-like chairs, anyway. IDK.
EDIT: Birdy already said it basically, but yeah. lol
There's nothing to prevent a bed or a throne from being in the style of Dalish artistry, though, or having elements of Dalish things to it. I imagine my Inquisitor would rather be sleeping on a pile of furs on the hard floor than in bed. I can imagine someone walking in to find her curled up on the rug at the foot of the bed, like an animal. Talk about losing your dignity...
As for a Dalish themed throne, it could be styled sort of aravel-shaped, with sails to the side. Maybe a halla carving topper.
But there's not even Dalish decor, and that's a shame too--you know the Dalish carve statues and such for their campsites, and figureheads and god symbols for their aravels.
Oh, forgot about that.
So he gets mad at the Inquisitor for using it. But the entire time we're at the Temple he's like, "Ew, Morrigan." and doesn't seem to think she'd be best to use it either (even though he gets an approval increase if you let her use it). However, he still thinks someone should use the Well. Just not himself (we all know why)... or the Inquisitor... or Morrigan.
WHO IS SUPPOSED TO USE IT THEN, SOLAS? Pls make up ur mind.
Perhaps he wants Dorian or Vivienne to drink it? Doesn't seem to be an option for non-magi. Vivienne is never happy if I don't drink it. If she wants me to have it so badly, I wonder if she'd be okay with it herself?
They are all over the game! So, what about Dirthamen and Falon'din? Why is the Dread Wolf depicted so heavily in their temples? Dirthamen being the god of secrets and Falon'din being the god of the spirits and fadey-ness. I just need to know. Am I reading too heavily into the constant duplicity of the Dread Wolf being shoved into our faces?
In the Emerald Graves, as others mentioned, it was to represent the Emerald Knights' wolf companions. It's interesting that they had such, because the implication is that the wolf was once revered. Had Fen'Harel been a bad thing at that time, I doubt wolves would have received quite that much adulation. So either he wasn't around, or more likely he was once a more important god - likely under a different name. And I do use the term god, because while Solas says that the other elven gods weren't really gods because of their posturing, he never says they were just the nobles and rulers. They were something more than normal elves, but less than what he would consider a god--and yet, there's a bit of evidence that Solas considers himself a god (not much, but a little, watch his reaction if you immediately claim to be the Herald of Andraste for instance). I guess you have to be a seriously supreme deity to impress him?
Ah
Anyone else realize that in real time, it would take Solas and Lavellan a couple days to travel to Crestwood?
So, Solas basically was like, "come with me, my love!"
Then went on a hike for a couple days. Then dumped her, and walked back home by himself. So sad Lavellan had a couple-days-long walk-of-shame back to Skyhold.
That's cold, Solas. So cold.
I actually had thought of that, myself. It would probably take even longer than that - mountain travel, and it's quite a bit of distance to Crestwood from Skyhold even if the road were perfectly smooth. Either they were actually in the Fade, as another suggested, or yeah, he's kind of a jerk to ride all the way there. Or, the other person who suggested that maybe the scene was meant to be somewhere else (presumably on the Skyhold grounds or nearby), but the Crestwood environment was used for it, could also be right.
You'd really think Solas wouldn't have taken the mark if he could?
I think he could take the mark and he didn't. He wasn't powerful enough to confront Corypheus on his own. The Inquisitor had gotten the mark, and Solas was the only one who could stabilize it or remove it, since it was his own power. So, I actually believe that the reason the mark had become part of the Inquisitor wasn't because the Inquisitor had been using it, but because Solas had made sure it couldn't be stolen away. He would have had a couple of reasons for this: One, he didn't know the Inquisitor and bore him/her no ill will at that time (maybe later, if the Inquisitor is mean to him), so why let him/her die? Solas tends toward compassion for people until he feels they don't deserve that compassion. And two, the mark could potentially help him out in getting what he wanted, which was to retrieve the orb, if he played his cards right. And we know how well he plays Wicked Grace.
Was that headcannon or is there truth to the possibility that the "gods" were locked away in the Eluvians?
There are hints in the dialogue, but we honestly don't know for certain.
- nightwolf667 aime ceci
#28913
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:40
Hahaha ... That would be amazing.
Now imagine Solas as a hippy stoner sitting around with his ancient elvhen brethren.
"You know what's like messed up, man? Slaves."
Takes a drag.
"Like someone should do something about that."
I laughed waaaaaay harder than I should have.
Actually, this is a pretty perfect song for Solas...
Spoiler
OH GOD, this was my reaction, too.
Alright so. I'm done and thought I'd share. It's really, really rough, I haven't had anyone look at it or edit it or check it for grammar or spelling but it's late and now I'm..well, now I have to go find my husband. For reasons.
It's pretty graphic but not as much as I intended. My last fic included Sebastian, Anders, Lady Hawke, and marble statue. THAT was graphic. Hahah.
NSFW.
Spoiler
- DarthEmpress et Cheerios789 aiment ceci
#28914
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:41
I used to love my Lavellan with her tattoos. But I watched some of my romance scenes today on youtube, and I guess at this point I've been running around without tattoos for so long, that I hate seeing them.
So, thank you Solas, I guess. Thank you for making me prettier and then leaving me with no one to be pretty for....
- Seregwen, chibielf, HurricaneGinger et 1 autre aiment ceci
#28915
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:41
I, uh, damn.
Um ... there were words ... I remember how they go.
**** guys, I decided to start playing again and leave the forum and return to this?
*sigh*
Well done on the fiction though. A+ I especially like the physical vagueness and emphasis on metaphor and emotion. It was very fade-like. ![]()
I was listening to some banter with Solas and Bull and it got me thinking. He's not wrong to criticize the Imperium and the Qun, but he never offers a solution. He only criticizes. So does he have a solution? Does he just want everyone to be free? That doesn't work though. There has to be some government. Anarchy is an interesting idea, but it has no practical application.
But he can't truly be an Anarchist as he has nothing negative to say about the Inquisitor seizing power across the whole of Thedas. He's only concerned when she/he is too aggressive towards their charges. He doesn't want Democracy either. Since he made that comment that sharing power would never work. So what does he want? A monarchy where the monarch is a "good" person who holds the reigns of the entire kingdom?
That can't be right.
Or is it that his "solution" is so far-fetched that it would never work in "this" Thedas. Thus he never shares it. For instance ripping the world apart and rebuilding it from the ashes?
#28916
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:47
- Cheerios789 aime ceci
#28917
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:49
Exactly. Despite all his faults, that's what makes me admire him. He really does try. He listens to you when you explain yourself, and if you make a good point then he concedes it. Hell, he does that for everyone. It makes me sad when people talk about him as being arrogant because that really isn't an arrogant thing to do. I definitely think he was once arrogant and overbearing, but you can tell that he's tried to correct that. I think Solas's harshest critic is himself.
That's what I love about him. He'll blow up on someone, then he will apologize later; and even if someone says "no, i deserved it", Solas will still apologize for not seeing their perspective. He is trying so so hard.
What hits close to home is the fact he is used to being alone. And, nothing wrong with that. I enjoy being alone, I'm comfortable in it. When Wisdom dies, Solas withdraws into himself; I make it a point to tell him "you do not have to hurt alone". Ever. I loved being able to say that to him.
- Tielis, jellobell, zambixi et 6 autres aiment ceci
#28918
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:54
I think he does have some solution in mind. Whether it's a good one is anyone's guess. Take his banter with Sera, for instance. He tries to help her come up with a plan for what she'll do in the aftermath of her peasant revolution... he's very insistent that chaos for the sake of chaos is pointless, that she needs to have a plan.
Excellent point. I forgot that dialogue.
So not an Anarchist like I said. So what is he? He doesn't like supreme power, but then he does. He doesn't want gods, but then goes out of his way to set the Inquisitor up as a demi-god. What is his plan?
Solas, you beautiful man ... use your words and speak clearly for once.
#28919
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:55
I think he does have some solution in mind. Whether it's a good one is anyone's guess. Take his banter with Sera, for instance. He tries to help her come up with a plan for what she'll do in the aftermath of her peasant revolution... he's very insistent that chaos for the sake of chaos is pointless, that she needs to have a plan.
This. But also Sera points out that if she does take over, it'll just be her people on top doing the same bullcrap that the people who were on top before did. And Solas concedes that Sera has a point there.
I'm not sure he really does have a solution. He knows there's a problem but he can't figure out how to solve it, other than I suppose completely changing government from time to time before it becomes corrupt. He is very insistent--he says it more than once--that organizations cannot avoid corruption, even if individuals can.
I'm thinking his way would mean warfare to overthrow and replace the government every so often. This view is not unheard of, but it IS terrifying. It's a big-picture view that may look nice when you're cozy and safe on the outside of the conflict, but in practice it leads to a whole lot of war, to shattered lives and shattered families and lots of corpses. Solas seems to be okay with carnage on a grand scale in warfare, but not on an individual basis with people he knows about. So it would make sense if he advocated this viewpoint, and it would also make sense for him to do so as the elven god of rebellion--peace and justice can only last for so long, in his opinion, before it ends and another revolution must occur to prevent corruption.
Kind of a pessimistic way to view things, to think there's no solution other than another war and another uprising. But, it does seem to me to fit what Solas might be wanting.
Edited to add: It's also a really weird point of view when you consider he doesn't like for people to suffer, and he wanted to end the perpetual warfare of his people... but I can't help but think about his solution to the noble problem that he was bantering to Sera about...
- Tielis, caridounette, scintilla et 1 autre aiment ceci
#28920
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 03:55
OH GOD, this was my reaction, too.
Ha!
It's a great song.
I was listening to some banter with Solas and Bull and it got me thinking. He's not wrong to criticize the Imperium and the Qun, but he never offers a solution. He only criticizes. So does he have a solution? Does he just want everyone to be free? That doesn't work though. There has to be some government. Anarchy is an interesting idea, but it has no practical application.But he can't truly be an Anarchist as he has nothing negative to say about the Inquisitor seizing power across the whole of Thedas. He's only concerned when she/he is too aggressive towards their charges. He doesn't want Democracy either. Since he made that comment that sharing power would never work. So what does he want? A monarchy where the monarch is a "good" person who holds the reigns of the entire kingdom?
That can't be right.
Put him in a party with Vivienne or just listen to their banter. She calls him out on exactly this. I love their mutual burns.
I think he's got a plan, but I do think he has difficulty with expressing concrete solutions.
#28921
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 04:03
Ha!
It's a great song.
Put him in a party with Vivienne or just listen to their banter. She calls him out on exactly this. I love their mutual burns.
I think he's got a plan, but I do think he has difficulty with expressing concrete solutions.
I don't actually know if he has a plan. That's kind of what got him into this mess, isn't it?
He saw a problem with how the world was, and "fixed it." But didn't really have a plan for what happened next, other than going to sleep and seeing what happened when he woke up?
Now he just sees that things are "worse," so he's trying to undo his last mistake. But chances are, he still doesn't have a plan for what happens when he succeeds. He's just gonna see what happens and (probably) leave it as a mess for someone else (future protagonist) to clean up.
- scintilla aime ceci
#28922
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 04:05
This. But also Sera points out that if she does take over, it'll just be her people on top doing the same bullcrap that the people who were on top before did. And Solas concedes that Sera has a point there.
I'm not sure he really does have a solution. He knows there's a problem but he can't figure out how to solve it, other than I suppose completely changing government from time to time before it becomes corrupt. He is very insistent--he says it more than once--that organizations cannot avoid corruption, even if individuals can.
I'm thinking his way would mean warfare to overthrow and replace the government every so often. This view is not unheard of, but it IS terrifying. It's a big-picture view that may look nice when you're cozy and safe on the outside of the conflict, but in practice it leads to a whole lot of war, to shattered lives and shattered families and lots of corpses. Solas seems to be okay with carnage on a grand scale in warfare, but not on an individual basis with people he knows about. So it would make sense if he advocated this viewpoint, and it would also make sense for him to do so as the elven god of rebellion--peace and justice can only last for so long, in his opinion, before it ends and another revolution must occur to prevent corruption.
Kind of a pessimistic way to view things, to think there's no solution other than another war and another uprising. But, it does seem to me to fit what Solas might be wanting.
Edited to add: It's also a really weird point of view when you consider he doesn't like for people to suffer, and he wanted to end the perpetual warfare of his people... but I can't help but think about his solution to the noble problem that he was bantering to Sera about...
Omg you just reminded of one of my first thoughts as I was playing the game.
So it was right after the break-up and I was wandering around Skyhold kicking walls and being angry. You know ... as we do. I was trying to figure out Solas and it occured to me that he might be a spirit (then after I met Flemeth I wanted to march back up to him and demand if he was Fen'harel. Does it bother anyone else that we can't tell him about Flemeth? I imagine Lavellan marching up and snidely commenting that he was wrong, because she just met an elvhen god.).
Anyways, I digress, what if Solas is a catalyst for change? Like he wakes up every so often and shakes up the status quo. Maybe he did it back with Andraste too. It would explain why he is so knowledgeable, but doesn't know everything. Like he wasn't awake for hundreds of years. The books he checks out are mostly recent history with a couple of esoteric elvhen titles.
I dunno I'm rambling I'll stop.
- NekOoNinja aime ceci
#28923
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 04:07
@ Brass Buckle
I like the idea of Lavellan drinking from the well because it would lead to a more interesting story. That's all. Otherwise, we don't really know the extent to which the well can control you.
#28924
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 04:08
I don't actually know if he has a plan. That's kind of what got him into this mess, isn't it?
He saw a problem with how the world was, and "fixed it." But didn't really have a plan for what happened next, other than going to sleep and seeing what happened when he woke up?
Now he just sees that things are "worse," so he's trying to undo his last mistake. But chances are, he still doesn't have a plan for what happens when he succeeds. He's just gonna see what happens and (probably) leave it as a mess for someone else (future protagonist) to clean up.
You may be right. But he's also a pessimist in certain regards. He doesn't think any government or organization can escape corruption forever, no matter how vigilant. Considering he lives on Thedas, he might be right---Thedas is where Everything Goes Wrong. It's not a whole lot easier in the real world.
And yet, I can't help but think he's got SOMETHING in mind--he's spent all this time planning to get the orb back (he failed, but he planned it), and we know he's good with strategy (Wicked Grace, chess, banter with Sera). The problem is, as others pointed out, he's willing to make tremendous sacrifices in order to succeed.
Has he not already sacrificed his love for Lavellan for whatever plan he has in mind?
The real question is not whether he plans, but whether he plans for the long term. Perhaps he expects the other elven gods to do that for him?
- NeverlandHunter aime ceci
#28925
Posté 08 décembre 2014 - 04:08
I was listening to some banter with Solas and Bull and it got me thinking. He's not wrong to criticize the Imperium and the Qun, but he never offers a solution. He only criticizes. So does he have a solution? Does he just want everyone to be free? That doesn't work though. There has to be some government. Anarchy is an interesting idea, but it has no practical application.
He's an academic! ![]()
Nah, but really, Solas reminds me so much of my discipline sometimes. I'm an Anthropology student. It's absolutely fascinating, but when you try to talk about it to people who don't know all the jargon it's a bit of a rude awakening when they have no idea what you're talking about. And it makes so much sense! Well, to me. And to other people who've done all the supplemental reading. These ideas have such important real-world applications, too, but it's difficult to pitch them to people who aren't quite as idealistic as you are.
And one of the things that Anthropologists take very seriously is criticism; pulling apart established modes of thinking in order to expose the problems, because you can only find solutions once you know what's wrong. Perhaps he doesn't actually have a solution yet, but that doesn't mean he shouldn't point out when something isn't working.
- HurricaneGinger et Hedinve aiment ceci





Retour en haut






