Yeah, that was kind of out of left field. I thought the Dalish were losing their magic and mage children were important? Honestly, it feels like it was added so Vivienne could be right about something if she was arguing with a Dalish mage.
This was a couple pages back, but I just got home from work. This did irk me immensely, yes. I never got the impression the Dalish kicked out anyone, let alone mages, nor that they disliked mages to any degree. Merril was moved to a clan that needed a(nother) mage, and the Dalish in DA2 accepted Feynriel no questions asked. Merril even said "it's your humanity that would set you apart, not your magic." They even endured torture to protect him (you can come across some Templars and Dalish hunters arguing at the front of the camp; one of the Dalish said they "used fire" to hurt one of their hunters trying to get info on Feynriel- my Hawke was always "eff this sh-" once he heard that and sides with the Dalish, or diffuses the fight so they both part).
So why would they toss out mages to die? My boy was pretty offended on Minaeve's behalf and maintains that his clan never did anything like that. It was also beyond irritating when Viviene got to say "well you Dalish throw out your mage children to die neener neener" and there was no option to express that some Dalish might do that, but that they are wrong to do so. I was left feeling completely bewildered by that exchange and the lack of ability to defend the culture left a bad taste in my mouth.
It just seems so very contradictory to what we've already been shown and told, and adds fuel to the anti-Dalish fires. "Oh them? They put children out into the wild to die when they have too many mages, see how much they suck and why their culture sucks and why elves suck."
I also had that issue with her on my Qunari mage when she says "well your people cut out their tongues." Uh, no. My people don't do that. Qunari do that. (I have a very visceral hate for that woman, and she despises my Dalish inquisitor, he feels the same for her, and nothing will ever come of this very strained business relationship between them XD).
So yeah. BW why you no give me good retort to snooty mage lady who disdains everything my Lavellan says and does? 