Aller au contenu

Photo

Solas Thread - NOW OFFICIALLY MOVED to Cyonan's BSN (link in OP)


153438 réponses à ce sujet

#50901
Arlee

Arlee
  • Members
  • 1 097 messages

Eluvians, yes. Lyrium...

 

Does Solas ever mention anything about lyrium? He seems pretty ignorant about dwarves in general, going by his conversations with Varric. And that's really weird. You'd think a society built on magic would be choking on lyrium. Maybe... lyrium didn't exist before the veil was put in place? The elves relied purely on their mana and blood before that?

 

Argh I don't even know.

 

 

 

I'm really scared Bioware won't be able to live up to the reunion I have in mind at this point. But they've done a really good job with Solas so far, and I trust Weekes. So. Fingers crossed.

 

That's pretty much what I am thinking. It's all tied together somehow. Solas had a conversation with Varric last night where he referred to the Dwarves as having an arm cutoff... and there was something Cole said at some point relating to it that made me think along these lines.



#50902
tsunamitigerdragon

tsunamitigerdragon
  • Members
  • 1 794 messages


  • coldwetn0se et Rabbitonfire aiment ceci

#50903
Illyria

Illyria
  • Members
  • 5 317 messages

He doesn't disapprove that strongly. He gets kinda huffy and crosses his arms, but he'll concede there's not much harm done and let it go.

 

For what it's worth, I spared the Wardens, which Solas disapproved of far more, and that didn't hurt my standing with him that much either. In fact, I spared the Wardens, prevented him from killing the mages that hurt his friend, and made Cole more human (hypocritical, I know), but I managed to make up those approval points in enough conversations, quest decisions, and elven artifact activations elsewhere that all of them combined did nothing to hurt my standing as his One True Love.

 

EDIT: Also, don't be afraid to stand up to or disagree with your beloved! Couples don't have to agree on everything to be happy and healthy in love! (Heck, come to think of it, I earned disapproval in a lot of quests and conversations. Usually minor "Solas slightly disapproves" when discussing the Dalish or something, but I managed to make it up elsewhere.)

 

I've managed to romance Fenris on the friendship path as a pro-mage apostate.

 

I find Solas approval and disapproval to be very interesting.  It gives a great deal of insight into his character (and has made me a firm believer in 'Solas is a good person')

 

EDIT: A correction: I always romance Fenris as a pro mage apostate.  I just don't like his rivalmance...


  • jellobell, coldwetn0se et dragondreamer aiment ceci

#50904
javeart

javeart
  • Members
  • 943 messages

I understand where you're coming from, honestly.  But it's really odd to talk about whether it's "necessary" to make Solas more than Fen'Harel- as if we (the goofy theory people) have any control over that at all. 

 

Solas is what Gaider made him, and that can't be changed.  He also left a careful trail of breadcrumbs toward that identity for anyone willing to follow to see where it led.  You certainly don't have to take the path now, but if even if you choose not to, the game will push you along eventually, whether you want to go that way or not.  

 

...erk.  That sounds a bit strident, and I don't mean it that way. I just can't think of a gentler way to put it.  Solas is what he is, and the full scope of his identity is accessible using canon gameplay as evidence.  You just have to find the pieces and put them together yourself, or the game will eventually do it for you.

 

I have to say, I'm not so sure about the writers leving a trail of breadcrumbs... Quite to the contrary, I feel they're still hiding crucial information from us. I mean, I don't recall anyone predicting that Flemeth was Mythal... Well, there's so many prediction that someone might have guessed right :lol:  but we knew so little about her... Even now that we know, how many things can you find in her appearance in books and games that clearly led to think that she was an elven goddes?


  • Missy_MI et Hattress aiment ceci

#50905
Lady Luminous

Lady Luminous
  • Members
  • 16 598 messages

Good morning lovelies, what's the hot topic of the day?



#50906
Illyria

Illyria
  • Members
  • 5 317 messages

 

While I want to believe that Solas is Fen'Harel and Solas is just the totally-not-subtle name of self-loathing he takes after awakening and trying to fix his mess... there IS something odd about his interactions with Cole.
 

When Cole begins interacting with Solas, Solas goes out of his way to ask Cole to remember the things that pain him or weigh on his mind, "could you.. could you do it as I would?" In doing so, Cole changes his syntax and sentence structure. It's no longer a disjointed garble of verbs, but instead complete sentences that have a subject. Him. In third person. No longer the first person in-the-moment-experiences he has with the other companions.
 

This separation, or personal distance if you will, could lead credence to the concept of Fen'Harel possessing Solas at some point. Who knows? That possession could have even been before the fall of Arlathan and Solas could still be the ancient Elvhen Abelas recognizes him to be.

Moreover, in Cole's descriptions of Solas' past there is a moment in which he describes a death scene: 

Cole: It sees him ready to jump pain pulsing. A life of frustration can finally fall, to freeze.
Solas: Ah, yes.  
Cole: It holds him high, shows the hole where everything falls without him. He never needs to leave. He matters here. 
Solas: That is one interpretation, yes. 
Cole: You think it is different?
Solas: I think he fell and it held him as he died. Leaving him with images that told him his life was worth while. 
Cole: That's much sadder, but yes, calm comfort as the cold takes him away. They can only return to the maker if they become real. Why can't they be forgiven as they are? 
Solas: People say the lack the ability to learn or grow. 
Cole: Yes?
Solas: But the more contact you have with this world the more ability you gain. 

Fascinating. Why would Solas have the memory of a dead man, the sensation and thoughts he felt as he died? Moreover, their conversation flits straight to a conversation about being "real" (seriously, that's going to be my next wall of text break down - that word bothers me to no end because of its ambiguity), the necessity of becoming or interacting with the physical in order to grow, to change, to experience. It's odd.

 

 

I don't think that's from Solas' past.  The two of them have a lot of banters in which they discuss the Fade, spirits and things Cole has read in people.
 



#50907
TanisLave

TanisLave
  • Members
  • 406 messages

 

/cough

 

Doesn't super fit, BUT STILL.



#50908
phaonica

phaonica
  • Members
  • 3 435 messages

Unexpected to see someone mention EQ here! I was planning my mage Lavellan for next playthrough to be a Shenshen look alike. At least as much as I can manage with our unfortunate hair selection. She's always been one of my favorite characters.

Gotta gush a little. Because nostalgia. I remember waiting forever for our county library system to cycle the copies of the large EQ graphic novels they had around to my local branch because my parents were too broke to buy them for me. The books were falling apart and bent and battered, but there was nothing like arriving at the library and seeing that logo on the reserved shelf with my name on it. I had discovered the series when I was like, seven years old and I found my cousin's stash of comics. He had a handful of the Marvel issued original quest tucked in there. I've been a fan ever since.

I'm following the progress of the Final Quest right now. Got the first one, but I haven't read it yet. I want a good pile of them to be released and in my hands before I start so I can marathon through them. Can't read just one.

 
I was about 10 when I started reading them; about the same time my brother started getting into XMen and Marvel. I've been known to joke that, growing up, Cutter was my Superman.
 
For Final Quest, I'm doing something similar to you. I read the first few, but the pacing was killing me, so I decided to wait a whole year to let them pile up and read them all at once.
 
I couldn't help but think of EQ when the conversation is about wolves and elves.
  • Kittn aime ceci

#50909
Mims

Mims
  • Members
  • 4 395 messages

 

Solas is what Gaider made him, and that can't be changed.  He also left a careful trail of breadcrumbs toward that identity for anyone willing to follow to see where it led.  You certainly don't have to take the path now, but if even if you choose not to, the game will push you along eventually, whether you want to go that way or not.  

 

...erk.  That sounds a bit strident, and I don't mean it that way. I just can't think of a gentler way to put it.  Solas is what he is, and the full scope of his identity is accessible using canon gameplay as evidence.  You just have to find the pieces and put them together yourself, or the game will eventually do it for you.

 

While this is absolutely true, our ability to decipher all these pieces is limited. No matter how clear cut a theory is- until it is stated, it is not fact. Everyone is capable of looking at a pile of puzzle pieces and putting it together in a combination that makes the most sense to our brain. I look at scraps of evidence from the game, and I recognize immediately the place that my mind is taking me. But this 'direction' is bias by my own perception of events. 

 

For example- an innate bias most of us have is to look for reasons to justify Solas's actions, or to view him in a more sympathetic light.

 

That is not to say we are wrong in doing so. In fact I believe rather strongly that it is not. But it doesn't change the fact that my perception of the character is at least partially bias. The writer's perception of the character is also bias. They are directing the story in the direction that they see, influenced not only by the text but the direction they intend the game and the narrative to go into. 

 

What I mean to say with all of this rambling is that no theory that we have discussed, even some which can be supported by mounds of evidence, should be considered the correct path just yet. I don't think it is fair to suggest that someone just 'hasn't seen all the pieces', and that eventually the game will make it all clear. Sure, perhaps it will. But there's an equally likely chance that it won't, and that goes for every theory that has ever been concocted here.

 

By all means, speculate! I love reading all the theories. [For me it is actually about as interesting as playing the game.] I just don't think anyone should be suggesting they've found the correct path. 


  • Brass_Buckles, Missy_MI, BoscoBread et 10 autres aiment ceci

#50910
tsunamitigerdragon

tsunamitigerdragon
  • Members
  • 1 794 messages



#50911
Rabbitonfire

Rabbitonfire
  • Members
  • 2 052 messages

Two days? I thought it was a week. All that travelling just to meet up for a weekend what a waste.

 

I can't remember which codex entry it was but in one a hunter states that the clans probably don't meet up more often because of the arguments the Keepers get into. I can well imagine it's like scholars meeting up each trying to have their say and prove their theory right. 

 

Keeper1: Sex! When Andruil  captured Fen'Harel, to spend a year and a day in her bed, it's an innuendo for sex!

 

Keeper2: You sick fucker, that's bestiality! He's there to lay at the end of the bed to warm her feet!

 

Keeper1: Have you've been to the Arlathan forest? You'll sweat your balls right off!

 

Keeper2: Not if it happened near the coasts. The sea air makes the nights chilly.

 

Keeper 3: Calm yourselves, Falons. Have you considered that the tale was about the shipping between Anaris and Fen'Harel?


  • jellobell, Ossifer, Brass_Buckles et 13 autres aiment ceci

#50912
tsunamitigerdragon

tsunamitigerdragon
  • Members
  • 1 794 messages

.


  • Rabbitonfire aime ceci

#50913
flabbadence

flabbadence
  • Members
  • 1 275 messages

Keeper1: Sex! When Andruil  captured Fen'Harel, to spend a year and a day in her bed, it's an innuendo for sex!

 

Keeper2: You sick fucker, that's bestiality! He's there to lay at the end of the bed to warm her feet!

 

Keeper1: Have you've been to the Arlathan forest? You'll sweat your balls right off!

 

Keeper2: Not if it happened near the coasts. The sea air makes the nights chilly.

 

Keeper 3: Calm yourselves, Falons. Have you considered that the tale was about the shipping between Anaris and Fen'Harel?

 

Curse you BSN like limit!


  • Rabbitonfire aime ceci

#50914
DragonRacer in Mourning

DragonRacer in Mourning
  • Members
  • 10 062 messages

Really?.. G'dangit JOSIE

 

Sometimes in life, diplomacy is a futile thing and best abandoned early when red flags rise.

 

I somehow managed to keep my clan alive and well despite not having any spoilage on the right steps/advisors. Just went with my gut after carefully reading the situation each time and carefully looking at each advisors' proposal.

 

The first step is reassuring your clan that you're all right and not a prisoner. Sending a spy or an army seems like the total opposite of "reassurance", so that was the one and only time I picked Josie.

 

After that, bandits were attacking. Logically, I sicced Cullen's troops on them.

 

Then we got a disturbing letter from a noble. Several points of it were italicized for emphasis. A clear message for "read between the lines"... something was very, very wrong but she could do no more but hint to us and hope we got the "real" message, probably because the Venatori spies were monitoring all correspondence and obviously had bewitched the duke. My LOTR senses were tingling and it seemed like Eowyn seeking help for Theodin King afflicted by Wormtongue. Trying to be diplomatic with what seemed like (to me) a clear hostage situation would go nowhere and raise suspicions. Sending an army would be overkill and alert them far before the army could even enter the city. Sending assassins to quietly take care of the spies and, then, later, the corrupted duke seemed most logical.

 

Final step was Marchers gathering to try and wage a war against the city. Obviously, at this point, troops are needed, so I called upon Cullen one last time. Go. Go save my clan and their newfound allies.

 

Everything ended happily.


  • SleepyBird, Prince of Keys, scintilla et 3 autres aiment ceci

#50915
Patchwork

Patchwork
  • Members
  • 2 585 messages

Keeper1: Sex! When Andruil  captured Fen'Harel, to spend a year and a day in her bed, it's an innuendo for sex!

 

Keeper2: You sick fucker, that's bestiality! He's there to lay at the end of the bed to warm her feet!

 

Keeper1: Have you've been to the Arlathan forest? You'll sweat your balls right off!

 

Keeper2: Not if it happened near the coasts. The sea air makes the nights chilly.

 

Keeper 3: Calm yourselves, Falons. Have you considered that the tale was about the shipping between Anaris and Fen'Harel?

 

To quote Tumblr -

"there is literally no difference between academic scholars discussing their interpretations of a text and a bunch of people yelling YOUR HEADCANON IS WRONG at each other"


  • jellobell, dragondreamer, laurelinvanyar et 2 autres aiment ceci

#50916
NeverlandHunter

NeverlandHunter
  • Members
  • 1 627 messages

I have to say, I'm not so sure about the writers leving a trail of breadcrumbs... Quite to the contrary, I feel they're still hiding crucial information from us. I mean, I don't recall anyone predicting that Flemeth was Mythal... Well, there's so many prediction that someone might have guessed right :lol:  but we knew so little about her... Even now that we know, how many things can you find in her appearance in books and games that clearly led to think that she was an elven goddes?


People did theorize that Flemeth was Mythal way before Inquisition was released :D I believe it was the fact that her amulet was takento Mythal's alter at Sundermount that led people to connecting those two.
  • cleosilver et Sister Squish aiment ceci

#50917
javeart

javeart
  • Members
  • 943 messages

People did theorize that Flemeth was Mythal way before Inquisition was released :D I believe it was the fact that her amulet was takento Mythal's alter at Sundermount that led people to connecting those two.

 

Oh, my bad then  :blush:  :lol: The most poplar theory always seemed to me that she was the formless one. 

 

I still think they're probably hiding crucial information, though, even if my example was so terrible   :P



#50918
Sylvanfeather

Sylvanfeather
  • Members
  • 264 messages

 

 

 

GAH so sorry I'm only replying now, was backreading (and I've finally caught up, WOOHOO! happy very belated 2k pages Solas thread!).

 

To answer your question, no you aren't missing any Solas content. I just took the breakup's aftermath as an argument of sorts, because my Lavellan picked the bewildered option where she sort of spat, "and we're done?". So, really, that's all there is to it. I'm sorry if I raised your hopes futilely in any way.

 

 
Spoiler

 

I went off on a bit of theorycrafting yesterday on reddit after listening to sashimi_taco’s cleaned up audio from the Well of Sorrow and have more ideas on everything.

So, what I mostly heard in the hidden audio was:

"Mythal speaks the calling. The call speaks from the blood. …Bound to the same, travel far. … She speaks the truth. She saw the lost. Go to the Warden.”

I think that Mythal was infected and killed by the Blight.

During the time she was infected, she asked her friend Fen’Harel to lock away all the Gods as a quarantine measure. Maybe she asked this of him as a trusted friend, or because he was the most trusted on both sides of the pantheon. Did she finally succumb to the Blight while plotting these measures with Fen’Harel, and thus the belief that he was responsible for her death? Or, perhaps Mythal even asked him for a mercy kill because she could no longer control the corruption. (Recalling the scene with Ser Wesley, Flemeth at least knows this is one way to deal with the corruption).

It’s starting to make sense to me that the other gods may also have been infected and locking them away in uthenera was the only way to slow the effects of the corruption. Which leads me to believe that the Elven Gods are the Old Gods. The corruption in their blood is calling to the darkspawn from uthenera to set them free.

[edit: ALSO, Thinking on how Flemeth saves the Warden in DAO and pushes Morrigan to join them (armed with the knowledge of the Dark Ritual which will preserve the Old God soul). Wardens are considered the experts in Thedas on darkspawn and the Calling. Flemeth needs the Wardens as a means to help her cure the Gods, and as a means to prevent the death of another one]

The elven artifacts you activate for Solas are actually locks to the prison where the Gods sleep. In the Lost Temple of Dirthamen, one of these same artifacts is already activated when you arrive but then when you deactivate it, The Highest One is released. The Highest One had wanted to lock away his followers in a prison but they turned the tables on him instead. When you open the lock to his prison, he is set free. A prison strong enough to lock away Gods would need to have many locks.

So for all of this, Solas doesn’t want the Gods to be freed, at least not just yet. He needs to help them by finding a cure to their corruption. We still don’t know who created the corruption, but my first guess is The Maker. Could it be that simple? “The Maker of the Blight”. The first action of a victor would be to erase any signs of your predecessor(s); make it heresy and treason to worship those old gods.

Whatever the case, I believe it’s all going to come back around to the Blight.


Modifié par Sylvanfeather, 09 janvier 2015 - 04:05 .

  • Missy_MI, CapricornSun, nranola et 16 autres aiment ceci

#50919
vierrae

vierrae
  • Members
  • 434 messages

The one you want is here:

 

https://www.youtube....AzdsOqy4A#t=150

 

took me a while to find it myself. I am displeased at its omission from the OST.

That's it! Oh, you are a wonderful, wonderful person!



#50920
Illyria

Illyria
  • Members
  • 5 317 messages

Thanks for that catch! Any idea who it could be attributed to?

 

I don't know.  I get the feeling with those banters that we're only getting a fragment of whatever it is they've been discussing.  Other companions will often join in with these chats, but normally to say how freaked out they are (except Dorian.  He think they're both fascinating to listen to).  Viv gets the best interjection:

 

Cole: <says something really weird>

Solas: <replies with something weird>

Vivienne: You shouldn't encourage that thing.

Cole: Solas isn't a thing!

Solas: Well said.


  • slmisfit, NightSymphony, Mims et 4 autres aiment ceci

#50921
Mims

Mims
  • Members
  • 4 395 messages

 

Whatever the case, I believe it’s all going to come back around to the Blight.

 

I was talking to a friend recently who bemoaned the lack of darkspawn and the blight in the past two games. But more and more, I am getting the sense that it isn't that the writers are backtracking from the danger of the blight. But that the blight is actually significantly larger and has the potential to be even more devastating than we realized. 

 

The fact that even 'gods' [and if they aren't truly gods, assuredly some of the strongest beings on Thedas], can contract the red lyrium corruption...how do you stand against that? That is seriously ominous. 

 

Edit: Not to mention- we started out with one red lyium idol and a couple of ore deposits in DA2. Now in DA:I, we have entire zones like emprise du lion being overrun with the stuff. Surely it will slow down in growth without the templars to cultivate it...but its still there. Just a massive amount of blighted crystals waiting to latch onto something. 


  • Sylvanfeather, scintilla, Vhenan In Fen'Harel et 1 autre aiment ceci

#50922
SleepyBird

SleepyBird
  • Members
  • 206 messages

Sometimes in life, diplomacy is a futile thing and best abandoned early when red flags rise.

 

I somehow managed to keep my clan alive and well despite not having any spoilage on the right steps/advisors. Just went with my gut after carefully reading the situation each time and carefully looking at each advisors' proposal.

 

[snip]

 

Everything ended happily.

I lucked into saving my clan on my first playthrough for the exact same reasons at pretty much every step. Oh gods I stressed over that last mission sending in the troops. It was a 20 hour mission and I spent  the whole next day at work worried I might have started a war. SUCH a relief when it all worked out allright. 


  • Missy_MI et NeverlandHunter aiment ceci

#50923
madrar

madrar
  • Members
  • 880 messages

Madrar's Nutbag Theory of Magic, the Triad, and What Solas Plans To Do Next

 

Sticking this madness under spoiler tags to keep it easy to skip for the uninterested.  ^w^

 

Spoiler

  • Silver77nz et vierrae aiment ceci

#50924
HatUmbra

HatUmbra
  • Members
  • 36 messages

That's it! Oh, you are a wonderful, wonderful person!

You are welcome...and thank you. :)

I listen to it while reading, uh, literature, yeah, that's what it is called. *wink*


  • vierrae aime ceci

#50925
BoscoBread

BoscoBread
  • Members
  • 2 651 messages

I was talking to a friend recently who bemoaned the lack of darkspawn and the blight in the past two games. But more and more, I am getting the sense that it isn't that the writers are backtracking from the danger of the blight. But that the blight is actually significantly larger and has the potential to be even more devastating than we realized. 

 

The fact that even 'gods' [and if they aren't truly gods, assuredly some of the strongest beings on Thedas], can contract the red lyrium corruption...how do you stand against that? That is seriously ominous. 

Agreed.  That line of Flemeth's all the way back into DA:O has sort of stayed with me through the last 3 games - when Flemeth is warning Morrigan the dangers of the blight and how it will consume her and drops into a more normal and serious tone for the first time - "Yes. Even I." and Morrigan is taken aback.   And Solas is practically un-hinged with the Warden quest. I never talked to him after the ritual tower in the Western Approach, but did this last playthrough.  HE IS FREAKING OUT.  You also get a flirt option.   I don't think he knows EXACTLY what happens if the Wardens carry out their plan, but he knows it's something terrible.

 

EDIT: I hope the Architect comes back - I didn't kill him.  He was such an interesting character.


  • Sister Squish et laurelinvanyar aiment ceci