This thread has definitely changed, though I wouldn't necessarily say for the worse? I've been here a long while and compared to most of the BSN, this place is still incredibly civil and on topic.
I think it's mostly that way back when, it was rare to have any sort of disagreement in here. Not even the kind that involved civil arguments. We were even discussing similar things to now, including more NSFW topics, though we were careful not to go too far. Not that there was any real art or fic to share back then, since the large chunk of Solas fans there are now hadn't yet jumped on board and we knew almost nothing about him. Somehow we rarely ever went too far or made someone uncomfortable so nobody ever really had to talk boundaries or start up disagreements.
Now....not so much with the lack of arguments. But there are more people than before in here, for obvious reasons, and a lot of new faces too. Communities change. I still find this place amazingly civil and amazingly on-topic. Not quite like before (though we did have a few bad moments here and there) but hey, we were scrounging for scraps back then and we had to be kind of jovial about it all. 
You know what? I think it's the lack of Mr. Schumacher's presence and his masterful drawings since spring last year. 