Y'all talking about Catullus a while ago made me look up my favorite poem of his:
Give me a thousand kisses, then a hundred.
Then, another thousand, and a second hundred.
Then, yet another thousand, and a hundred.
Then, when we have counted up many thousands,
Let us shake the abacus, so that no one may know the number,
And become jealous when they see
How many kisses we have shared.
*sighs*
No, he says "What will you do with the power of the Well once Corypheus is dead?" ... and all I can think is, dude I'm not going to do jack with it go ask Morrigan. What I actually says is ... "I'm going to make the world a better place with rainbows and kittens and unicorns - no, not the bog unicorn, that thing is creepy as ****"
Edit: I loaded a save where I didn't drink just to double check. Now I have to go through the whole scene where he dumps my char. Again. Space bar don't fail me!
I like to imagine that the bog unicorn ends up being really affectionate and wants to be loved on, but everyone's like "NOPE IT'S YOUR TURN".
I think it might be a little bit of both. I think Varric is partially right Cole came into this world to help people, but he also fashioned a human body that looked like the real Cole because he wanted to honor his memory, and symbolically help him live on by living in his stead. Like Solas says though, Cole is also a spirit.
In a way, they both focus too much on one side of Cole's nature and ignore the other, and the Inquisitor has no choice but to side with one and choose to encourage one side of Cole's nature and have him "forget" (or let go of) the other. I personaly feel like something is lost either way, and I feel like it's too bad we can't help Cole reconcile his human and spirit qualities.
Oh well, c'est lavie. Cole seems more content with himself either way, and just grateful for the help no matter what you do.
That's how I see it too. When it comes to the decision, it felt to me like Solas was playing it safe. He was scared of what could possibly happen to Cole if he tried to ignore his own nature and go more human (which is more poignant after he loses his spirit friend). By playing it safe, he is also ignoring a part of what Cole is and a trajectory Cole has been going on for a while now.
Varric, on the other hand, is potentially playing with fire with no real understanding of the possible consequences. He recognizes human potential in Cole and clings to it. He has no true knowledge of spirits and doesn't respect them as people the way Solas does.
All in all, Solas has better judgment in my opinion. Even if I ignore it in favor of making Cole more human, mostly for selfish reasons of wanting him to be my humany little bro. And because the human path is more interesting in terms of the lore.
Yep, I kind of hated going off on what Solas and Varric thought was best - but Cole was in great distress at that time and just wanted to kill the man. It was like a family intervention.
Solas definitely was playing it safe especially after what occurred with Wisdom. But I doubt it's just because of that, just another deciding factor. He does know what he's talking about, and it is a risk to make Cole more human, because what if, like Anders, it twists something inside him and he turns into a demon again?
Varric doesn't know anything about "weird ****". He sees Cole suffering...like Anders did...and wants to bring forth the human side.