Aller au contenu

Photo

Solas Thread - NOW OFFICIALLY MOVED to Cyonan's BSN (link in OP)


153431 réponses à ce sujet

#102376
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

Is it incorrect to say that the romance with Anders left Hawke feeling a bit used? I remember feeling used, but mainly glad I could allow him live. 

What I remember with Fenris is him always being angry ... lots of angry ... I don't remember if he ever lets down his guard.  

I seriously miss Merril. I sided with her more than Fenris. 

 

It really depends on your Hawke.  Mine drank the crazy Kool-Aid of violent revolution, so she was on board with his plan.  My BFF played a much more reasonable, non-mage Hawke who friendmanced him, and she felt that Anders' actions in Act 3 were basically emotional blackmail.  Like the Solas romance, player experience and opinion runs the gamut.  It is a definite possibility though.


  • Cee aime ceci

#102377
lynroy

lynroy
  • Members
  • 24 619 messages

...said most of the Solas thread :D It's either that or "I *thought* I knew what I was getting into, and then I was all the tears anyway."

Preach. I thought I knew. I still got dragged down into hell spiral.
  • Sable Rhapsody, Lunapur et Lethaya aiment ceci

#102378
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

I didn't know, and I still get the occasional "Oh, I'm sorry" when I mention I romanced Solas on my first playthrough. :P

 

Going to PAX East was a good opportunity to talk with other players (and chat with devs) since a lot of my friends hadn't finished at that point. So it was like a pilgrimage with my feelings over to where I knew I would find some understanding. I was not active here yet. Ha.



#102379
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

-catches up-
 

This is true, and I loved the scene, every word and nuance. It was even better than the first kiss in the Fade for me. I was able to have her express heartbreak over truth about vallaslin, and yet be unwilling to let go of it at the same time. I was able to let her express a range of conflicting emotion. That was really beautifully done. The scene was beautiful.

It really was beautifully done. Whether you keep the vallaslin or get rid of it, both Solas and the Inquisitor have really great dialogue. I've only played with the English Quizzy voice, but I was really impressed. And Solas just has all the right tones and all the right words. There was definitely the potential to showcase your Lavellan's inner conflict there, and it was done so well!

On the markings themselves: To be honest even though I carry the view that the vallaslin is 'reclaimed', I always get it removed just because it's a very special experience. Not only to be the only (?) elf with it taken away, but because when he cups his hands over your head it's just so intimate. And I've mentioned before that I like to imagine it is his Fen'Harel powers that give him this ability, and he shares that with you if only at least once.

Also someone mentioned the God of Rebellion removing the slave markings of another god just fitting so well, and I agree.

But in the scheme of things, there's no best choice. Only your own choice. Though it might pop up later on in DLC dialogue, who knows?

 

I think perhaps that Corypheus is only able to jump if a tainted vessel happens to be in close proximity to him? Kinda like in that Denzel Washington movie Fallen where the demon can pull the same trick, but is vulnerable if in a place where no humans or animals are present? I still have to wonder how he managed to survive the initial blast at the Conclave? Perhaps he had some Wardens outside the blast-zone that he was able to jump into, or he was able to reform from one of the burnt bodies?

I could be wrong, but I interpreted the Cory thing to be like... he can jump to any blighted body even miles away. That's why he can't be killed properly even without wardens or darkspawn nearby. If other Magisters don't have a similar red-lyrium-dragon-horcrux system like that, I don't think they can body hop.

 

Some quick thoughts on dragons in general:

A fair amount of in-game evidence suggests the earliest Gods were fundamentally draconic in nature- a theory bolstered by real-world examples of primordial serpent Gods drawn from various religions as well as the thematic connection to the cycle of the universe itself in ouroboros. It also maps in an interesting way to our concept of the universe as a single mind - the earliest gods' domains being the "reptilian complex" (Elgar'nan/Pre-Elgar'nan Order/the Sun) and the "paleomammalian complex" (Earth-Mythal) of the triune brain. In Jungian terms, this would be the subconscious, the unknown. "Here be Dragons" in our map of the mind.

This theory seems to be borne out in subtle hints we find in the temple of Mythal mosaics. Unlike the other gods of the elvhen Pantheon, Mythal and Elgar'nan share a distinctive rounded, almost snout-like pattern in the tiles that compose their face.

Spoiler

I knew it. You're just trying to impress the notion that the ancient government of the elves were lizard men!

 

Well we know some sort of lizard men exist, since we've seen them painted on the rocks in the Emerald Graves.

The artist in me is more inclined to say that these features more likely represent their cheek bones, and the tiled nature of the mosaics giving off a coincidental reptilian vibe. The claws, of course, representational of Elgar'nan's fierce fury. Though now I look at it, I can kind of see why the Vints called the elves 'rattus'!

 

It all does begin so wonderfully light, romantic, and happy. ^_^ I was accidentally spoiled on who he was right before the temple but I did not get spoiled on him dumping you.  It's really beautiful, all of it, ultimately, in the most heartbreaking of ways. I didn't know what I was getting into either, just like most.

My first play through was a mage Trevelyan, and I romanced Cullen because I shrugged and thought "well, may as well be you". The whole time I felt like I was doing Cullen a misdeed and leading him around because Trevelyan really had a huge crush on Solas. There was no romance availability, as we well know, but the things he says even to a non-elf are enough to make a girl fall for him. Seriously. The Cullen romance made me feel dirty because of that. :<

I played an elfy mage next round. Much better.

Also, uh... Does anyone else get the vibe that Cullen has a crush on the Inquisitor even if you don't romance him?


  • Sable Rhapsody, Lunapur, Nightspirit et 2 autres aiment ceci

#102380
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

Does anyone else get the vibe that Cullen has a crush on the Inquisitor even if you don't romance him?

 

With some of the flirts and some of Cullen's later romance dialogue, yes.  Solas's dialogue is pretty intimate even with a friendly quizzy, but I never interpreted it as a crush; it came off more like Solas just being rusty with people and not getting social boundaries.  Cullen, though, I definitely got the crush vibe.  It bothered me with Amell/Surana, so I took care to steer clear of it with Lavellan.  The poor noodle doesn't need unrequited crushes on TWO different PCs.

 

I love Cullen, though.  And I do like his comments about Amell/Surana, and getting over that childish crush.  I'd like to think that if they met again, Cullen and my Amell could be friends.


  • CapricornSun, NightSymphony, coldwetn0se et 2 autres aiment ceci

#102381
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

With some of the flirts and some of Cullen's later romance dialogue, yes.  Solas's dialogue is pretty intimate even with a friendly quizzy, but I never interpreted it as a crush; it came off more like Solas just being rusty with people and not getting social boundaries.  Cullen, though, I definitely got the crush vibe.  It bothered me with Amell/Surana, so I took care to steer clear of it with Lavellan.  The poor noodle doesn't need unrequited crushes on TWO different PCs.

 

I love Cullen, though.  And I do like his comments about Amell/Surana, and getting over that childish crush.  I'd like to think that if they met again, Cullen and my Amell could be friends.

OK, not just me! Phew. He's the kicked puppy of the love interests, imo. And a complete romantic. Probably why I felt badly about it. Poor Cullen even let Trevelyan win at board games, but she was all hung up on an elven god. :<

Edit: just watched some of the earlier Cullen scenes again thanks to Youtube, and I just want to say: awwwwww. He deserves a happy ending.

Solas also deserves a happy ending. Come on, Bioware!


  • Lunapur aime ceci

#102382
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

OK, not just me! Phew. He's the kicked puppy of the love interests, imo. And a complete romantic. Probably why I felt badly about it. Poor Cullen even let Trevelyan win at board games, but she was all hung up on an elven god. :<

 

It worked out for him in my BFF's canon.  She didn't play Amell/Surana, and her Trevelyan didn't exactly get along with Solas.

 

More and more, I find myself not particularly liking love triangles  :unsure: Maybe I'm just getting old and grumpy or something.


  • Lethaya et ChuChu aiment ceci

#102383
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

I never got that vibe at all from Cullen, but then again I don't think I flirted with him more than once or twice on my rogue. I did take flirts with several people but after a while, at Haven, I just stopped flirting with anyone but Solas for the remainder of the game.


  • Lunapur, ChuChu et MayriyaNoori aiment ceci

#102384
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

More and more, I find myself not particularly liking love triangles  :unsure: Maybe I'm just getting old and grumpy or something.

Honestly? I don't really like them either. After playing Lavellan, I'm content to let my Trevelyan be happy with Cullen. I'm just going to stick with Lavellan as my canon play through now, though. :)

Maybe we are getting old and grumpy, or maybe we just want people to be happy. Who knows!


  • Sable Rhapsody aime ceci

#102385
CapricornSun

CapricornSun
  • Members
  • 3 724 messages

Also, uh... Does anyone else get the vibe that Cullen has a crush on the Inquisitor even if you don't romance him?

 

My Lavellan was flirting with both Cullen and Solas before finally deciding to have Solas as her canon romance (because Fade kiss happened), so Cullen may have an unrequited crush on my Lavellan in my playthrough. Poor guy.  :mellow:


  • ChuChu aime ceci

#102386
Illyria

Illyria
  • Members
  • 5 304 messages

I have this thing where I dislike losing approval and especially losing teammates, but there is a rivalry system built into DA2 so I think it's about time I tried it out because I hate Sebastian and I don't care if he doesn't like me.

 

I would like to know from people who've romanced both which romance is more enjoyable? Fenris or Anders? 

 

Is it incorrect to say that the romance with Anders left Hawke feeling a bit used? I remember feeling used, but mainly glad I could allow him live. 

What I remember with Fenris is him always being angry ... lots of angry ... I don't remember if he ever lets down his guard.  

I seriously miss Merril. I sided with her more than Fenris. 

 

Fenris is a much better romance than Anders.  Fenris, on the friendship path at least, is actually very sweet and lets his guard down quite a bit.  With a sarcastic Hawke he'll flirt and joke right back and put him in a party with Varric and Aveline ad he's pretty relaxed and cheerful.  He gets very flirty with Isabela (and will even get into a relationship with her in Act III if they're both unromanced) and his friendship with Seb is very sweet and will let you see another side to Sebastian.  He even tries reaching out to Anders at one point, which is more than Blondie ever does for him.

 

As for romancing ladies as ladies - I just think 'who is my character drawn to?'  There's been a few times where the romance I intended hasn't been the one that happened (my Cousland was meant to be for Alistair, she romanced Leliana; my Lavellan was meant for Sera and romanced Solas; and my Brosca was meant for Zev and romanced Alistair).


  • Nehn, SimoneV et Cee aiment ceci

#102387
lynroy

lynroy
  • Members
  • 24 619 messages
I only flirted with Cullen during the chess scene just so he'd say "wouldn't you prefer the company of Solas?" or whatever it is he says.
  • SimoneV et ChuChu aiment ceci

#102388
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

Mine took the first Iron Bull flirt because it's comedy gold, one or two with Cullen, I think maybe one with Blackwall, and several with Sera. Josephine is too much like me, which my boyfriend pointed out and I couldn't not think about it, so the idea of flirting with her is a bit weird, even though I do love her and she's sweet. Cassandra got some glances from me, the player, but I used my knowledge as a player to not flirt with her because I knew she couldn't reciprocate. If she were open to women, however, I might have been saved from ancient elvhen heartbreak. ;)

 

And lots of Solas flirts. My doom <3


  • Nehn, Lunapur et SimoneV aiment ceci

#102389
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

Maybe we are getting old and grumpy, or maybe we just want people to be happy. Who knows!

 

Maybe happy isn't the right word.  After all, I killed my Andersmancing Hawke and my Zev-romanced Tabris because I'm a bit of a horrible person  :lol:

 

It's more that I find the implementation of love triangles to be kind of...I dunno, juvenile?  Even the ones I used to like (Bishop and Casavir's man-b*tching comes to mind).  Also most of the Inquisition cast is older, and IMO should be beyond that sort of thing.


  • Cee et Lethaya aiment ceci

#102390
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

Fenris is a much better romance than Anders.  Fenris, on the friendship path at least, is actually very sweet and lets his guard down quite a bit.  With a sarcastic Hawke he'll flirt and joke right back and put him in a party with Varric and Aveline ad he's pretty relaxed and cheerful.  He gets very flirty with Isabela (and will even get into a relationship with her in Act III if they're both unromanced) and his friendship with Seb is very sweet and will let you see another side to Sebastian.  He even tries reaching out to Anders at one point, which is more than Blondie ever does for him.

 

As for romancing ladies as ladies - I just think 'who is my character drawn to?'  There's been a few times where the romance I intended hasn't been the one that happened (my Cousland was meant to be for Alistair, she romanced Leliana; my Lavellan was meant for Sera and romanced Solas; and my Brosca was meant for Zev and romanced Alistair).

 

*ignores the top part of that* :P

 

I don't really pick anyone for my character on a first time out. I just kind of have a loose-ish idea of who my character is, motives, history, personality, morality, etc and then fill in more blanks as I have more blocks to build with. So the process is a question of both "Who is my character drawn to?" and also who am I, as a player, drawn to? on the first time through. Though I might guess or have some in mind before and that shifts. I thought I'd probably wind up pairing my Lavellan with Sera but then Solas opened his mouth.

 

I have more planning on subsequent playthroughs but the feeling of discovery that first time never has a match again.
 


  • CapricornSun et ChuChu aiment ceci

#102391
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

Maybe happy isn't the right word.  After all, I killed my Andersmancing Hawke and my Zev-romanced Tabris because I'm a bit of a horrible person  :lol:

 

It's more that I find the implementation of love triangles to be kind of...I dunno, juvenile?  Even the ones I used to like (Bishop and Casavir's man-b*tching comes to mind).  Also most of the Inquisition cast is older, and IMO should be beyond that sort of thing.

Haha. Maybe you are just getting old and grumpy, but you can wear those like badges of honor! All protagonists beware. ;P

Also -- I dunno, imo, no one is too old for a love triangle. Human emotions are complex things. I think it's possible to outgrow the plotting of a love triangle, of course, because it can be annoying and so over-used and rarely done 'right'. I wouldn't exactly say my Trevelyan/Cullen with Solas crushing on the side was a triangle, either, of course. xD

Ew, now I'm thinking of Twilight. -cleanses herself with holy water-  

 

*ignores the top part of that* :P

 

I don't really pick anyone for my character on a first time out. I just kind of have a loose-ish idea of who my character is, motives, history, personality, morality, etc and then fill in more blanks as I have more blocks to build with. So the process is a question of both "Who is my character drawn to?" and also who am I, as a player, drawn to? on the first time through. Though I might guess or have some in mind before and that shifts. I thought I'd probably wind up pairing my Lavellan with Sera but then Solas opened his mouth.

 

I have more planning on subsequent playthroughs but the feeling of discovery that first time never has a match again.
 

I will not ignore the top part of that! Fenris is too adorbs. Then again, I don't know what happened exactly, Anders just sort of rubbed me the wrong way...? I feel blasphemous saying that here since I know there are a ton of Anders fans in this thread. D:

I play similarly to you. My first playthrough is a let-your-heart-and-feet-guide-you style (more or less a projection of myself). Of course, this is why I had tragedy on my first play through -- had to make up for it as an elf the second time around. Because yes. Egghead opened his mouth. What was the part that snagged me... it was: "Was that a serious question?". I just didn't yet have the awareness that he wasn't romanceable to anyone but elves!

I think it would have been hilarious if, after X-amount of failed Vivienne flirts, you get a special romance scene where she shuts you down. Hard.


  • Sable Rhapsody, coldwetn0se et Nightspirit aiment ceci

#102392
Gwyvian

Gwyvian
  • Members
  • 492 messages

And Siegfried. ;) And Letho.  :wub: (I have diverse tastes.)

Same here! :D *high fives*

 

Oh, there are certainly more sumptuous male choices in there! Personally, Iorveth completely wrecks my brain cells and turns me into an emotional pudding of incoherent adoration, so everyone else is kind of shunted aside, but if I could look past Iorveth...  :wub: I did mention I have an unhealthy obsession, right?  :lol:

 

Ohhhhh I just met my new Witcher 3!  :wub:  :wub:   It's GORGEOUS!  :wub:  :wub:

 

Everything else has officially vanished from my mind! (Except Solas, of course! :lol: )

 

*high five*!


  • Caddius aime ceci

#102393
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

 

I will not ignore the top part of that! Fenris is too adorbs. Then again, I don't know what happened exactly, Anders just sort of rubbed me the wrong way...? I feel blasphemous saying that here since I know there are a ton of Anders fans in this thread. D:
 

That was just me poking fun since Illyria hates Anders and I like/romanced him. Kind of an ongoing tease.

 

I was going to make a human but changed to an elf at the last moment since I was like....eh, bored of humans (my Warden is a Cousland married to King Alistair), especially humans with old names/family trees, and so went Dalish. It was a fateful decision. ;)


  • Illyria aime ceci

#102394
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

That was just me poking fun since Illyria hates Anders and I like/romanced him. Kind of an ongoing tease.

 

I was going to make a human but changed to an elf at the last moment since I was like....eh, bored of humans (my Warden is a Cousland married to King Alistair), especially humans with old names/family trees, and so went Dalish. It was a fateful decision. ;)

-rallies to Illyria's side-

You did indeed make a wise choice :)


  • Illyria aime ceci

#102395
Sifr

Sifr
  • Members
  • 6 796 messages

Does anyone know what Hawke says about Carver if he's a templar? Warden bro is far from Orlais and safe, but templar bro was right in the thick of things at Kirkwall. I don't want him to turn into one of those red lyrium monsters...

 

Found this out when I flubbed one of my imports in the Keep and it had him become a Templar instead of a Warden.

 

He quits the Templars after the events at the Gallows and instead joins the City Guard under Aveline (if she's still captain), helping to try and put the city back together in the aftermath of the rioting. It's actually fitting for his character if he goes that route, since he admits in Legacy and MotA that he's not entirely happy in the Templars and after seeing Meredith go nuts, he probably would have decided he'd had enough?

 

You'd imagine that Cullen, being the one running things at this point, would be sympathetic and accept his reasons for leaving the Order. He was probably the one who recommended (or pulled strings with Aveline) to allow him to join the Guards in the first place, pointing out that he doesn't need to be a Templar to help Kirkwall and they desperately need good people like him lending a hand during the crisis?

 

Aveline would also accept him as a guard when she hadn't before, because having been in the Templars for at least 6 years by that point, Carver's shown that he's got the capability to follow orders and take his commitments seriously? This was dedication that she hadn't seen back when he was an 18 year kid who's got a chip on his shoulder so large he could use it as a greatsword?

 

(I'm assuming that Aveline is still captain anyway, not played around with the Keep to see if she stays on even after wanting to quit in DA2?)


  • Sable Rhapsody, NightSymphony, Illyria et 3 autres aiment ceci

#102396
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

(I'm assuming that Aveline is still captain anyway, not played around with the Keep to see if she stays on even after wanting to quit in DA2?)

I think so! Had to double check, and at the very least, wiki agrees. It says: "Varric will state that she is still Guard-Captain and is responsible for a lot of Kirkwall's stability."



#102397
Sifr

Sifr
  • Members
  • 6 796 messages

I like Carver, but it took awhile.

One of my favorite moments with my first snarky Hawke mage was when he flipped from 'Goofball' to 'End this conversation or I end you,' in the conversation where Carver says Bethany died on Hawke's watch. (She died because mages aren't meant for close quarters combat...I might have gone for an archer sniping her as she was blasting the Ogre back or something.) And then Carver backs down. And then they're both sullen. And then they decide to go kill slavers together to work out their issues rather than just talking.  :lol: Bioware understands brothers.

 

That's why Snarky Hawke is my favourite of all the personalities, as well as why I enjoy their interaction with Carver (even if he's a total pain sometimes), because I think it gives their character way much more depth to them? You really get the sense that snarky Hawke uses humour as a coping mechanism and it's scenes like this (and after Leandra dies) that really show what happens when that facade crumbles, even for a second.

 

While I didn't like how flat Hawke felt in Inquisition, I can at least see it being the result of all that weight they've been carrying from DA2 onwards has left Hawke extremely world-weary and slightly bitter, which we're now seeing since that jocular front has slowly been eroded away.

 

In many ways, Varric does the same thing by deflecting his own problems with humour and blatant lies, which makes me think that's part of why he and sarcastic Hawke get on so well in DA2, they recognise that they're two peas in a pod.

 

I love the dynamtic between rival!Carver and sarcastic!Hawke.  You really get the impression that Hawke is trying to be friends but just really doesn't get her brother, and he doesn't quite get her.

 

That was always my take on the relationship as well, that snarky Hawke wanted to be friends and was desperately trying to get Carver to loosen up and take himself less seriously, but he's convinced that s/he's constantly making fun of him and treating him like a silly kid brother?

 

I like to think that whenever Hawke makes light of Carver during his "I wanna be a badass" moments, it's not done out of maliciousness but because they're subtly pushing Carver to try and prove them wrong, rather than just complaining about it? Like during that argument, Carver gripes that Hawke always has to be the leader in everything they do, which prompts Hawke to retort, "Well, I don't see you taking the reins?"

 

Bioware gave Carver and his complicated relationship with his elder sibling way more depth and layers to it than most people give them credit for?


  • Patchwork, coldwetn0se, BloodKaiden et 3 autres aiment ceci

#102398
MayriyaNoori

MayriyaNoori
  • Members
  • 5 289 messages

So, I have figured out how I can successfully romance someone other than Solas in a play through AND get to play an elf at the same time. And I am fairly certain that what I'm dong is the sign of some kind of problem.

 

This play through is not the Inquisitor. No, no. This time I'm playing my Inquisitor's younger sister who decided to come help out the inquisition with her roguey ways and work under Leliana. I completely block out all the inquisitor stuff, absolutely no talking to Solas outside of necessary(which is a very difficult thing to do) and just keep telling myself "This is not actually the Inquisitor. She's running around having a good time with Solas!"

 

I'll have a completely different group( my mage Lavellan ran around everywhere with Cass, Cole and Solas) and pretty much only run around and kill stuff to get through the story as quickly as possible.

 

....I basically have to play the entire game pretending my character is NOT the main character of the game. This is either genius....or I/my character has a serious problem. Maybe both.

 

I mean......how else does one resist?

Spoiler

 

Oh, and I was looking through my screenshots and realized that THIS right here is the biggest lie told to those of us who romance Solas.

Spoiler

 

LIES!!!! LIES LIES LIES!!!!

 

Hope everyone else is having a great day!


  • Lunapur et Lethaya aiment ceci

#102399
Illyria

Illyria
  • Members
  • 5 304 messages

*ignores the top part of that* :P

 

I don't really pick anyone for my character on a first time out. I just kind of have a loose-ish idea of who my character is, motives, history, personality, morality, etc and then fill in more blanks as I have more blocks to build with. So the process is a question of both "Who is my character drawn to?" and also who am I, as a player, drawn to? on the first time through. Though I might guess or have some in mind before and that shifts. I thought I'd probably wind up pairing my Lavellan with Sera but then Solas opened his mouth.

 

I have more planning on subsequent playthroughs but the feeling of discovery that first time never has a match again.
 

 

pffft, you're just jelous I got the good LI :P

 

I agree with the building blocks approach.  I tend to go into a playthrough knowing a few things about my character and then see how that works out in game.  It's actually why it took me so long to get into my Adaar playthrough because I kept trying to force a personality that didn't work for her (I now have 'sarcastic Andrastian, pratical and a fantastic player of the game')

 

I will not ignore the top part of that! Fenris is too adorbs. Then again, I don't know what happened exactly, Anders just sort of rubbed me the wrong way...? I feel blasphemous saying that here since I know there are a ton of Anders fans in this thread. D:

I play similarly to you. My first playthrough is a let-your-heart-and-feet-guide-you style (more or less a projection of myself). Of course, this is why I had tragedy on my first play through -- had to make up for it as an elf the second time around. Because yes. Egghead opened his mouth. What was the part that snagged me... it was: "Was that a serious question?". I just didn't yet have the awareness that he wasn't romanceable to anyone but elves!

I think it would have been hilarious if, after X-amount of failed Vivienne flirts, you get a special romance scene where she shuts you down. Hard.

 

You're not alone with those kind of feelings towards Anders.  I guess a lot of Andersmancers have never seen that bit in his Act III quest where he insults your LI (possibly to their face) and goes into total Nice Guy mode.  It's like how a lot of Seramancers will never see her post-Solas breakup scene (which soured a lot of Solasmancers to her character).

 

That was just me poking fun since Illyria hates Anders and I like/romanced him. Kind of an ongoing tease.

 

I take offence, Cee.  Fite me IRL.

 

-rallies to Illyria's side-

You did indeed make a wise choice :)

 

I like this human, they understand.

 

That's why Snarky Hawke is my favourite of all the personalities, as well as why I enjoy their interaction with Carver (even if he's a total pain sometimes), because I think it gives their character way much more depth to them? You really get the sense that snarky Hawke uses humour as a coping mechanism and it's scenes like this (and after Leandra dies) that really show what happens when that facade crumbles, even for a second.

 

While I didn't like how flat Hawke felt in Inquisition, I can at least see it being the result of all that weight they've been carrying from DA2 onwards has left Hawke extremely world-weary and slightly bitter, which we're now seeing since that jocular front has slowly been eroded away.

 

In many ways, Varric does the same thing by deflecting his own problems with humour and blatant lies, which makes me think that's part of why he and sarcastic Hawke get on so well in DA2, they recognise that they're two peas in a pod.

 

 

That was always my take on the relationship as well, that snarky Hawke wanted to be friends and was desperately trying to get Carver to loosen up and take himself less seriously, but he's convinced that s/he's constantly making fun of him and treating him like a silly kid brother?

 

I like to think that whenever Hawke makes light of Carver during his "I wanna be a badass" moments, it's not done out of maliciousness but because they're subtly pushing Carver to try and prove them wrong, rather than just complaining about it? Like during that argument, Carver gripes that Hawke always has to be the leader in everything they do, which prompts Hawke to retort, "Well, I don't see you taking the reins?"

 

Bioware gave Carver and his complicated relationship with his elder sibling way more depth and layers to it than most people give them credit for?

 

As a younger sibling I really felt that the relationship between Hawke and Carver to be the most real part of the game.  And I also think that Carver is by far one of the most complex characters in DA2.

 

Snarky!Hawke is my favourite too.  Way too many fans dismiss snarky!Hawke as being nothing but terrible one liners, but I see them as the most real of all three personalities.  They're just an ordinary person trying to cope with the horrible things that keep happening to them in the best way they can.


  • Sifr, Cee et ChuChu aiment ceci

#102400
ChuChu

ChuChu
  • Members
  • 517 messages

It's like how a lot of Seramancers will never see her post-Solas breakup scene (which soured a lot of Solasmancers to her character).

 

So... I totally told Sera she couldn't join my Inquisition, and I never saw this. Does anyone have a link? xD