I spent way too much time in the CC both in Origins (until I found the Elf Update mod) and DAI trying to make my elf eyes look like the ones on the NPCs from DA2.
*proud fan of the DA2 elf look*
NPCs like this? 

Ahh, glad I'm not the only one who liked the DA2 elf look. Those big eyes were the best. I really liked how they tried to differentiate each race instead of 'short human' 'pointy eared human' 'big bronze-skinned human' in DA:O. The only thing I regret is how much they butchered Zevran :'(
Ugh! What they did with Zevran's face was unforgivable. 
Can't say I was a BIG fan of the DA2 elf redesign. Sure, the eyes were more like how they were described in the books, but it did make the elves look more like... animals to me. Like some kind of goat or sheep. Like when Pol died, I remembered thinking that his face before his death looked like a bleating lamb. 
Of course there were good-looking elves like Fenris, Merrill, and Orsino (and maybe some other elves I'm missing out), but a lot of the rest looked... meh. And don't get me started on Tallis. Brrrr! 
I get what they were going for, but I think they executed it poorly. It made me hard to believe that humans find elves more beautiful when all I could think of is that most of the elves in DA2 looked like goats/sheep (unless you're into that sort of thing...), which is why I'm glad that they changed the elf design for DA:I.
Plus, I can't imagine Solas in big anime uguu eyes. 