But what about high approval Inquisitor who wants to save him?
If they die they will leave behind they loved ones, perhaps a lover, that's just pointless and sad.
If it goes exactly like irredeemable Solas route then it'll make players feel cheated, both because their relationship with Solas didn't matter and because Lavellan is only one to die. Her life is sad enough, why does she need that? Just because she loves the Dread Wolf and decides to try and save him she dies?
Between Solas and my Lavellan I'd rather he dies, just because she can deal with his death and will die out eventually, Solas will have to bear this for thousand of years more. Plus, Inquisitor is a symbol and potentially has many friends...
Death as redemption is so boring, Romeo and Juliet is too sad and annoying for me... If Solas collapses the Veil and sacrifices his life to right the wrong I'll feel cheated, because nothing will change and we'll lose a great character.
I am waaaay behind on this thread, but this expressed my thoughts as well.
Beyond the fact that I am not a huge fan of Romeo and Juliet (or similar such narrations...sorry

), the loss of the character within the DA-verse would highly disappoint me. And I am also a huge fan of "friend"-Inquisitor. Actions, reactions, being somewhat equitable across all PC choices, is a hope of mine. For better, and/or worse, depending on said choices. That doesn't mean I don't think the romance should come into play - not in the slightest. The romantic in me, most certainly would adore something befitting regarding the choice to romance him. I am just wishing that all options get quality and relevant content.
If the writer(s) decide to go further with this storyline.
Frankly, I am all "angst" out. I don't expect much specificity in any Solavellan story conclusion. I could end up being completely wrong, but I don't wish to set myself up for expectations that clearly don't end up being met.
As for the romance itself, it's funny, I had my fingers crossed as we prepared first for the game, and later for it's epilogue:
1) Don't let the romance end in heartbreak (i.e. death, breakup) - 0 for 1
2) Don't let him be some sort of god like figure (since
those generally turn out well

) - 0 for 2
3) Don't let him become a villain. (
Dammit!) - three strikes!

(I must be mental - kept making PC's to romance him.)