Aller au contenu

Photo

Solas Thread - NOW OFFICIALLY MOVED to Cyonan's BSN (link in OP)


153434 réponses à ce sujet

#129026
drosophila

drosophila
  • Members
  • 5 549 messages

Felassan: Now you're starting to understand.  Next step: go back to those friends of yours and apologise.

 

Solas: And who will apologize to our people as the last of them become like you?



#129027
NeverlandHunter

NeverlandHunter
  • Members
  • 1 627 messages

Solas and Blackwall seem very similar when they first banter and I wonder if that's why he gets so upset when he finds out he lied about himself. He's not doing any better, even though he didn't lie about his real name like Thom did.

He sort of did though... I know Solas is technically his real name, but he pretty much called him self Solas the unassuming but helpful apostate hobo who travels the Fade seeking knowledge and who just generally wants to do what he does in peace. While in actuality he was Fen'Harel who was at one point Solas and is also known as the Dread Wolf who is also considered a god by some and he has godly powers and wants to destroy the world but denied actually being a god. 

I would argue that lying by omission is still lying. Both Rainer and Solas hid who they truly were behind different identities, they were wearing masks. Solas even admits as such in one of the post break up dialogues.

 

We don't judge...much :P

And I'm not a beard girl either. With the exception of Richard Armitage as Thorin because HAWT DAMN.

I think Chris Hemsworth makes a hawt Thor too! But I'm definitely not a facial or body hair person, unless it's a bit of a shadow, cuz that can be hawt ;)

Yeah, Thorin was the first good looking dwarf I've ever seen that still looks fairly traditional.


  • LadyEledhwen aime ceci

#129028
FernRain

FernRain
  • Members
  • 1 217 messages

Droso I just read the fic :'(. Feels. Thank you..



#129029
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests

He sort of did though... I know Solas is technically his real name, but he pretty much called him self Solas the unassuming but helpful apostate hobo who travels the Fade seeking knowledge and who just generally wants to do what he does in peace. While in actuality he was Fen'Harel who was at one point Solas and is also known as the Dread Wolf who is also considered a god by some and he has godly powers and wants to destroy the world but denied actually being a god. 

I would argue that lying by omission is still lying. Both Rainer and Solas hid who they truly were behind different identities, they were wearing masks. Solas even admits as such in one of the post break up dialogues.

 

That's also what I think too. Lying is lying, but he did not directly make up (or steal) a name like Thom. That's what I meant. Also I found it interesting that both he and Blackwall say that the titles Fen'Harel and Blackwall are like Inquisitor and try to relate to you and both have caused some pretty nasty things and can be judged or attempted to be redeemed in the end.


  • Missy_MI, NeverlandHunter et LadyEledhwen aiment ceci

#129030
NeverlandHunter

NeverlandHunter
  • Members
  • 1 627 messages

 

Oh, playlist. Why.

 

 

Spoiler

 

Am I the only one that makes a little AMV in my head whenever I listen to a song that fits Solas?


  • Jaderail et Elda aiment ceci

#129031
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

That's also what I think too. Lying is lying, but he did not directly make up (or steal) a name like Thom. That's what I meant. Also I found it interesting that both he and Blackwall say that the titles Fen'Harel and Blackwall are like Inquisitor and try to relate to you and both have caused some pretty nasty things and can be judged or attempted to be redeemed in the end.


That really bothered me, especially coming from Blackwall, and I think it's what initially soured me on his character arc. Blackwall is a name he stole to cover his shame. Inquisitor is a title that I damn well earned, constantly risking my life for people I've never met. Not even close, buddy. I was happier when he turned up in Trespasser as Thom.

The analogy holds truer for Solas, though.
  • LadyEledhwen et meersalz aiment ceci

#129032
NeverlandHunter

NeverlandHunter
  • Members
  • 1 627 messages

That's also what I think too. Lying is lying, but he did not directly make up (or steal) a name like Thom. That's what I meant. Also I found it interesting that both he and Blackwall say that the titles Fen'Harel and Blackwall are like Inquisitor and try to relate to you and both have caused some pretty nasty things and can be judged or attempted to be redeemed in the end.

Yeah, their similarities are interesting  ;) except Rainer's bloody past will lead him to a future where he lives for the individual. He'll always remember the ghosts of his past, but he's ready to move forward and let them go. Solas can't escape his ghosts.



#129033
The Lone Shadow

The Lone Shadow
  • Members
  • 349 messages

* pops in *

I was wondering, for all those lucky enough not to be like me and be stuck with an Xbox 360 game, how did your Quizzes (Lavellan and others) respond when they caught up with Solas in Trespasser? (angry, sad,i.e)

 

*pops out* 



#129034
dragondreamer

dragondreamer
  • Members
  • 2 638 messages

It has to happen no matter what, so either we stopped their awakening or they are still safe. It had to be one of the creepiest things I ever saw in the game after learning what lyrium really is too. It made me think of vampires and human blood.

 

Nothing is as creepy as that black ball with red eyes in the library though. I wonder if that's the image we supposedly see in the Temple of Mythal (using Veilfire) of the person being punished for taking on a form reserved for the Divine?

 

If you mean what I think, I suspect that might be a representation of the Void.

 

And yup, things are getting kinda vampire-y in Thedas after DA:I.   I want my anti-blood magic Surana to find out what's actually in those lyrium potions.  :P



#129035
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests

That really bothered me, especially coming from Blackwall, and I think it's what initially soured me on his character arc. Blackwall is a name he stole to cover his shame. Inquisitor is a title that I damn well earned, constantly risking my life for people I've never met. Not even close, buddy. I was happier when he turned up in Trespasser as Thom.

The analogy holds truer for Solas, though.

 

He seems to want to use it to help redeem himself, but I don't think he meant for you to take offense to it. He might have hinted you were inspiring him to honor the name.

 

 

Yeah, their similarities are interesting  ;) except Rainer's bloody past will lead him to a future where he lives for the individual. He'll always remember the ghosts of his past, but he's ready to move forward and let them go. Solas can't escape his ghosts.

 

Solas only almost lets go because of his love for Lavellan, but I strongly suspect he is bound to Mythal in some odd way based on how he speaks of how what you think or do will never be you. I think he's both wanting to do this, it's Mythal's Will and he wants to die or be punished as the Enuvaris were. Thom is the white version to his black I would say. Like a Yin and Yang possibly.

 

 

* pops in *

I was wondering, for all those lucky enough not to be like me and be stuck with an Xbox 360 game, how did your Quizzes (Lavellan and others) respond when they caught up with Solas in Trespasser? (angry, sad,i.e)

 

*pops out* 

 
She refused to support his cause, she still loved him, yelled at him for not trusting her and vowed to save him. My Trevelyan was a bit softer with him (they were best friends), and also vowed to redeem him.


#129036
FernRain

FernRain
  • Members
  • 1 217 messages

It looks like Mythal is emerging from a rock, and the dragon form appears more like a sea creature.  (And all the water pouring in when things start blowing up suggests the place is somewhere underwater...)
 
Ooh...  And according to Dalish legend, Mythal first emerges from the ocean.

 
Wow this is interesting. I've always wondered about the sea in the deeproads we see in descent:

Spoiler

We've been talking about lyrium in Frank's lore thread if anyone is interested.


  • dragondreamer aime ceci

#129037
midnight tea

midnight tea
  • Members
  • 4 819 messages

That's also what I think too. Lying is lying, but he did not directly make up (or steal) a name like Thom. That's what I meant. Also I found it interesting that both he and Blackwall say that the titles Fen'Harel and Blackwall are like Inquisitor and try to relate to you and both have caused some pretty nasty things and can be judged or attempted to be redeemed in the end.

 

The fundamental difference between Fen'Harel and Blackwall is that "Blackwall" for Rainier was a lifeline and a source of inspiration - for Solas, it was actually a mask and something used to accomplish his goals, no matter how ruthless. And while "Blackwall" helped redeem Thom in its own way (it at least let him survive, both literally and metaphorically, until the arrival of Inquisitor), "Fen'Harel" may yet consume Solas.

 

Spoiler

 

Seems to me that "Dread Wolf" is a road of deception, doom and gloom - unlike Thom, Solas was just Solas in Inquisition. In many regards, he hasn't been more true to himself than when he hanged around with his new gremlin friends.

 

So in some sense both are similar, but in others - they're completely opposite.


  • CapricornSun, NightSymphony, Lunapur et 2 autres aiment ceci

#129038
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

 

Oh, playlist. Why.

 

 

Spoiler

 

 

I just got back from a nap (note, not uthenera, but allergies have been playing with my system hard lately :angry: ) and I see this. *settles into the feels corner*
 



#129039
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests
 

If you mean what I think, I suspect that might be a representation of the Void.

 

And yup, things are getting kinda vampire-y in Thedas after DA:I.   I want my anti-blood magic Surana to find out what's actually in those lyrium potions.   :P

 
It's the big black ball with red eyes and a sun symbol in the middle. And it makes me think that's our real big baddie.

 

The fundamental difference between Fen'Harel and Blackwall is that "Blackwall" for Rainier was a lifeline and a source of inspiration - for Solas, it was actually a mask and something used to accomplish his goals, no matter how ruthless. And while "Blackwall" helped redeem Thom in its own way (it at least let him survive, both literally and metaphorically, until the arrival of Inquisitor), "Fen'Harel" may yet consume Solas.

 

Seems to me that "Dread Wolf" is a road of deception, doom and gloom - unlike Thom, Solas was just Solas in Inquisition. In many regards, he hasn't been more true to himself than when he hanged around with his new gremlin friends.

 

So in some sense both are similar, but in others - they're completely opposite.

 

Sometimes I see Thom in Trespasser and wonder if Solas COULD have been that guy too.



#129040
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

That really bothered me, especially coming from Blackwall, and I think it's what initially soured me on his character arc. Blackwall is a name he stole to cover his shame. Inquisitor is a title that I damn well earned, constantly risking my life for people I've never met. Not even close, buddy. I was happier when he turned up in Trespasser as Thom.

The analogy holds truer for Solas, though.

 

I really liked seeing him just reclaim Thom and no more running, owning up to everything, no more denials. He went to the Wardens and could do his good deeds without the weight that had been upon him for so long. But I felt like you about his character arc in the main game.


  • Sable Rhapsody et Uirebhiril aiment ceci

#129041
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests

I really liked seeing him just reclaim Thom and no more running, owning up to everything, no more denials. He went to the Wardens and could do his good deeds without the weight that had been upon him for so long. But I felt like you about his character arc in the main game.

 

I always make him a Warden but was surprised at how sad he seemed if you just let him go free instead.



#129042
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

* pops in *

I was wondering, for all those lucky enough not to be like me and be stuck with an Xbox 360 game, how did your Quizzes (Lavellan and others) respond when they caught up with Solas in Trespasser? (angry, sad,i.e)

 

*pops out* 

 

I've only gone through Trespasser with my canon Lavellan and I think I got the max feels ending possible. Sad options, imply that you were trying to save/help him, tell him you agree with his goal and want to join him, refuse to give up on him.



#129043
FernRain

FernRain
  • Members
  • 1 217 messages

 
Wow this is interesting. I've always wondered about the sea in the deeproads we see in descent:

Spoiler

We've been talking about lyrium in Frank's lore thread if anyone is interested.

 

And to add to that, there's a landmark called "bastion of the pure" by this 'buried sea' which says:

 

The water shimmers, a subtle but eerie blue, reminiscent of lyrium. Swimming in it would not be wise.


#129044
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests

And to add to that, there's a landmark called "bastion of the pure" by this 'buried sea' which says:

 

Reminds me of that place with the coffins I posted a pic of a few pages back.


  • FernRain aime ceci

#129045
Cee

Cee
  • Members
  • 11 504 messages

I always make him a Warden but was surprised at how sad he seemed if you just let him go free instead.

 

I haven't seen that option but he does feel bad about what he did, so I'm not surprised that sending him to the Wardens seems to net him an arc completion that makes him feel a sense of atonement as well.



#129046
Elessara

Elessara
  • Members
  • 1 880 messages

I always make him a Warden but was surprised at how sad he seemed if you just let him go free instead.

 

I don't make him a Warden, I let him go free.  I like his ending slides in Trespasser.  They're awesome.


  • neonmoth, NeverlandHunter, Moondreamer01 et 2 autres aiment ceci

#129047
NeverlandHunter

NeverlandHunter
  • Members
  • 1 627 messages
 

<snip>

 

Solas only almost lets go because of his love for Lavellan, but I strongly suspect he is bound to Mythal in some odd way based on how he speaks of how what you think or do will never be you. I think he's both wanting to do this, it's Mythal's Will and he wants to die or be punished as the Enuvaris were. Thom is the white version to his black I would say. Like a Yin and Yang possibly.

 

 
<snip>

I hope that's not the case. I want Solas's decisions to be his own, however horrible those decisions might be.

 

I really liked seeing him just reclaim Thom and no more running, owning up to everything, no more denials. He went to the Wardens and could do his good deeds without the weight that had been upon him for so long. But I felt like you about his character arc in the main game.

I like how he looks for the good in prisoners if you let him go free.

 

I don't make him a Warden, I let him go free.  I like his ending slides in Trespasser.  They're awesome.

I agree!


  • Jayla aime ceci

#129048
Guest_Keeva_*

Guest_Keeva_*
  • Guests

I haven't seen that option but he does feel bad about what he did, so I'm not surprised that sending him to the Wardens seems to net him an arc completion that makes him feel a sense of atonement as well.

 

He seems pretty lost if you just let him go free. I think being a real Warden gives him purpose. He is still better than before, but not as truly happy.


  • Sable Rhapsody aime ceci

#129049
Uirebhiril

Uirebhiril
  • Members
  • 2 530 messages

I don't make him a Warden, I let him go free.  I like his ending slides in Trespasser.  They're awesome.

 

Yep. That redeemed his character in my eyes. Not because he was off doing good and helping others, but because he got to the point with himself where that is what he wanted to do to finally atone for what he did in the past. He, Thom Ranier. Not Blackwall's echo. Not a shadow being noble and doing good to try and exist in the world. A flesh and blood man who finally owned up to being himself. I loved it.


  • Elessara, CapricornSun, neonmoth et 4 autres aiment ceci

#129050
drosophila

drosophila
  • Members
  • 5 549 messages

Ooof, right in the feels :(

 

 

Droso I just read the fic :'(. Feels. Thank you..

 

Thanks guys. You have all the hearts I could type without my post getting banned.  <3  <3  <3  <3  <3  <3  <3  <3  <3


  • FernRain aime ceci