After today, I've committed myself to giving more, and more specific, comments and feedback on anything I read. If I read it, I impose on myself to comment on it. But it would be great if others commit to this as well, since there's a range of writers around here with different styles, experience, etc.
If you don't know what to say, here's a handy prompt:
1. What was your favorite line? Why? How did it make you feel, did it evoke tears, laughter, anger, anything else?
2. Do you think any particular character is very well-done?
3. What would you like to know more about?
4. Was there some line, word, description that somehow brought you out of immersion for a particular character? Can you come up with a better alternative?
5. How's the pacing? Is the story going too fast? Too slow? Just right?
6. Any comments about the writer's style? Is it poetic, easy-going, dramatic?
This is just something to get people started. Feel free to add or remove things from the list.
So let's try an experiment: Next time you post a fic, add a note at the end that you welcome feedback, and paste these question prompts (or the edited version of them). See if this helps us give and receive more feedback within our little community.