Hmm I did 3 me1 runs
If I remember correctly,
Run 1:
Male paragon Shepard -Soldier
Ashley died
LI Liara (always-life long Batarian Romance) in the trilogy
Saved the queen
Council saved and base destroyed
I took this one to ME3 as well
Favorite characters, Samara and Garrus.. I just felt like they were such the strong Moral compass trio. Favorite Mission... What's fresh in my mind is the Final raid on the Collector Base. I still love how Samara (in my case) had the Justicar bubble going and the whole team was involved (btw - all team members survived every me2 playthrough). Such epic storytelling.
Run 2: (me1 and me2 only)
Renegade Femshep - Sentinel I believe
Ashley Died (she just kindof annoys me in me1)
LI - Liara (obviously)
Saved the Queen (she had a little heart despite being Renegade)
Council Saved.
Run 3 (me1 and me2 only)
insanity with my default paragon male shep Soldier
LI - Liara, Miranda (If Liara wants to go all Shadowbroker on me, fine!)
Saved Queen
Council Saved
I think my next run through will actually be Renegade FemShep through all three. I'm actually thinking straight biotic (but really renegade this time. Maybe.)
LI - let's be honest here, Liara
I may record it.. we'll see.