Aller au contenu

Photo

Wow... The books and comics are actually important


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
97 réponses à ce sujet

#1
CosmicGnosis

CosmicGnosis
  • Members
  • 1 593 messages

I've just started skimming through the non-game material, and I've discovered some rather crazy things... like Alistair's real mother. Like... what? I didn't even know this was a controversial question. Wow.

 

So it appears that Dragon Age's expanded universe content is far more important than Mass Effect's. I mean, significant plot progression has actually happened. I feel like I'm not caught up on the story at all.


  • Kidd, Lebanese Dude, Zelanthair et 1 autre aiment ceci

#2
Chron0id

Chron0id
  • Members
  • 604 messages
Hmm, maybe I should read the books after all...

#3
Nimlowyn

Nimlowyn
  • Members
  • 1 809 messages

I love the books. They add so much more richness to the world and are entertaining in their own right. I read The Masked Empire in a day. Asunder too, just about. Reading The Stolen Throne and The Calling made Loghain's eventual betrayal 10x more potent and bitter and left me a little devastated. Also, while they're not necessary to play the games, having more knowledge about the nature of Thedosian society helps me roleplay. 

 

I haven't gotten around to the comics yet, mostly because they contradict my canon playthroughs. Maybe someday I'll make Alistair king...


  • Noviere, thedistortedchild, JeffZero et 8 autres aiment ceci

#4
cindercatz

cindercatz
  • Members
  • 1 351 messages

... So is there a cliff's notes spoiler list of relevant details somewhere?



#5
Blackout62

Blackout62
  • Members
  • 1 009 messages

... So is there a cliff's notes spoiler list of relevant details somewhere?

 

Check the wiki.


  • cindercatz et BloodyTalon aiment ceci

#6
Chanda

Chanda
  • Members
  • 3 195 messages

I love the books. They add so much more richness to the world and are entertaining in their own right. I read The Masked Empire in a day. Asunder too, just about. Reading The Stolen Throne and The Calling made Loghain's eventual betrayal 10x more potent and bitter and left me a little devastated. Also, while they're not necessary to play the games, having more knowledge about the nature of Thedosian society helps me roleplay. 

 

I haven't gotten around to the comics yet, mostly because they contradict my canon playthroughs. Maybe someday I'll make Alistair king...

 

Reading the books helped me to understand why Loghain did what he did in Origins, though. At first I thought he was just a power-hungry jerk, but when you know the backstory, it makes you see where his head is at when he's doing things.


  • Darth Krytie, PlasmaCheese, Gamercat et 3 autres aiment ceci

#7
riverbanks

riverbanks
  • Members
  • 2 991 messages

The books are very important. Stolen Throne is absolutely essential to understand what Loghain's character was really about, and even ultimately why Cailan and Alistair turned out the way they did, through what you learn about Maric, Rowan and the Guerins. The Calling is essential to understand who Duncan really was beyond the guy who recruited you and then died, and why protecting both Cailan and Alistair was so important to him. Asunder resolves hanging threads from Origins and introduces characters who will definitely show up in Inquisition, and along with Masked Empire set the events that directly lead to DA:I.

 

Plus, they're all very entertaining reads, well written, and the universe is cohesive between each book and game, really expanding the universe with rich backstories rather than muddling it up. The mess that were those ME books doesn't even compare.

 

The comics are a different story. They're good, but they follow a unique canon that doesn't blend in so neutrally as the book universe does with the games, and some decisions in the treatment of certain characters are... questionable. Worth reading, especially if you're interested in how Alistair fares post Origin, but take them with a grain of salt and some suspension of disbelief if their canon doesn't exactly match up with yours.

 

But yes, the books. Read them. Do it. If you're a slow reader or only have limited time or resources to get all the expanded universe, I'd really recommend letting everything else for later and just reading Asunder and Masked Empire now, if you can. They're not mandatory, but they really help situate you on where the world stands right now -it's changed a lot since the last time you saw it at the end of DA2- and no summaries will do the characters and events of these books any justice.


  • DalishRanger, frostajulie, cindercatz et 18 autres aiment ceci

#8
cindercatz

cindercatz
  • Members
  • 1 351 messages

Thanks. :)



#9
Nimlowyn

Nimlowyn
  • Members
  • 1 809 messages

Reading the books helped me to understand why Loghain did what he did in Origins, though. At first I thought he was just a power-hungry jerk, but when you know the backstory, it makes you see where his head is at when he's doing things.

Absolutely. Before the books I didn't quite get Loghain's angle at first. Then I was like, okay, this guy is power hungry and deluded. Then I read the books...

 

For me, a better understanding of his motivations actually made the betrayal feel worse. And that made the story so much more emotional and meaningful...and tragic.



#10
Killdren88

Killdren88
  • Members
  • 4 638 messages

Indeed..with the extra time, I wouldn't mind it if Asunder and Masked Empire got on Audible. Stolen Throne and the Calling are already on there.



#11
Estel78

Estel78
  • Members
  • 686 messages

Who Alistair's mother is is not really important.



#12
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages

I couldn't put Asunder down but I can't get past the first chapter of Masked Empire. (I don't know what the difference is. It just seems kind of ... political? Instead of interesting lore wise, with demons and such.)

 

Is there super relevant stuff in there for DAI do you reckon?



#13
Spaghetti_Ninja

Spaghetti_Ninja
  • Members
  • 1 454 messages

I'd say the only book that is ''required'' reading is Stolen Throne for DA:O, because otherwise the Loghain character's motivations will make little sense.



#14
Estel78

Estel78
  • Members
  • 686 messages

Loghain's motivations made sense to me, without reading the book.


  • Bloodlupine, BigEvil, PK-Persona et 10 autres aiment ceci

#15
Nightwing99

Nightwing99
  • Members
  • 165 messages

The books are very important. Stolen Throne is absolutely essential to understand what Loghain's character was really about, and even ultimately why Cailan and Alistair turned out the way they did, through what you learn about Maric, Rowan and the Guerins. The Calling is essential to understand who Duncan really was beyond the guy who recruited you and then died, and why protecting both Cailan and Alistair was so important to him. Asunder resolves hanging threads from Origins and introduces characters who will definitely show up in Inquisition, and along with Masked Empire set the events that directly lead to DA:I.

 

Plus, they're all very entertaining reads, well written, and the universe is cohesive between each book and game, really expanding the universe with rich backstories rather than muddling it up. The mess that were those ME books doesn't even compare.

 

The comics are a different story. They're good, but they follow a unique canon that doesn't blend in so neutrally as the book universe does with the games, and some decisions in the treatment of certain characters are... questionable. Worth reading, especially if you're interested in how Alistair fares post Origin, but take them with a grain of salt and some suspension of disbelief if their canon doesn't exactly match up with yours.

 

But yes, the books. Read them. Do it. If you're a slow reader or only have limited time or resources to get all the expanded universe, I'd really recommend letting everything else for later and just reading Asunder and Masked Empire now, if you can. They're not mandatory, but they really help situate you on where the world stands right now -it's changed a lot since the last time you saw it at the end of DA2- and no summaries will do the characters and events of these books any justice.

 

 

Some people need a better imagination they  need to look at the comics as Visiting a Alternative Universe or like Reading  Marvel what if or Ultimate Universe



#16
Ailith Tycane

Ailith Tycane
  • Members
  • 2 422 messages

Loghain's motivations made no sense to me and I did read the book, lol


  • SurelyForth, Dutchess, katerinafm et 2 autres aiment ceci

#17
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

I couldn't put Asunder down but I can't get past the first chapter of Masked Empire. (I don't know what the difference is. It just seems kind of ... political? Instead of interesting lore wise, with demons and such.)

 

Is there super relevant stuff in there for DAI do you reckon?

 

It starts of pollitical but there is some lore stuff later on. It pretty much tells us all about Orlais, it's nobility and what kind of political landscape the Inquisitor will be walking into in DAI. Not needed as such because I am sure all the relevant info will be covered in game but I really enjoyed it. There is some stuff about spirits/demons, the elves and the Eluvians in it.



#18
Firky

Firky
  • Members
  • 2 140 messages

Hmm. Cheers. I might try again.

 

(I have to admit to a fondness for Eluvians.)



#19
NRieh

NRieh
  • Members
  • 2 907 messages

I couldn't put Asunder down but I can't get past the first chapter of Masked Empire. (I don't know what the difference is. It just seems kind of ... political? Instead of interesting lore wise, with demons and such.)

 

Is there super relevant stuff in there for DAI do you reckon?

I had exactly same issues, I could only make myself past first ME pages on my 3rd attempt. It's nothing like Asunder, in very many ways. I can't say 'it's a bad book per se, but it's definitely not my type of reading. Much less expressive descriptions, which are supposed to pass an impression to a reader. much more direct dry details (buttons, laces, gems, pearls, buckles etc). Much less believable emotions, much more politics. 

 

Unfortunately, both Asunder and ME seem to be vital for the DAI plot. On the other hand - it's meta-gaming. Player is going to know hell lot of stuff that the character is (very likely) unaware of.    

 

 

like Alistair's real mother. Like... what?

Don't even go there. Unless they bother to explain Goldanna, I can't accept that as a game-canon. All the 'sister' DAO dialogues do not fit the 'Calling' events. Mother's Amulet does not fit either, but could possibly be explained.   


  • Han Shot First aime ceci

#20
katling73

katling73
  • Members
  • 281 messages

It annoys me that it seems like the books and whatnot are being tied into the game universe. I already have a to-read list that's about 20 books long and I have no interest in adding more books to it. Add to that the fact that now the books feel like they're 'required reading' and that's really, really off-putting to me. I haven't done 'required reading' since I was at university and frankly the best way to make me not read a book is to tell me I have to read it to understand what's going on. To make it 'required reading'. Call it my own little imp of the perverse - the more you tell me I should read something, the less I want to read it and the more I will actively dislike it.



#21
Aurawolf

Aurawolf
  • Members
  • 386 messages

The books do add to the lore quiet a bit. Asunder was an interesting take on the mage rebellion it is nice to know it wasn't all about Anders and his stupid ideas.



#22
Force of the North

Force of the North
  • Members
  • 74 messages
   
 

Don't even go there. Unless they bother to explain Goldanna, I can't accept that as a game-canon. All the 'sister' DAO dialogues do not fit the 'Calling' events. Mother's Amulet does not fit either, but could possibly be explained.
[/quote]

Just in case I will say spoiler, but this is in response to another spoiler so... Duh



Let me try... Goldanna is the child of a maid that died giving birth to her second child. What is not revealed in DAO is that the child also died. Duncan and Eamon see this rare opportunity to hide baby Allistar's true parentage and replace the dead baby with the new born Allistar. Growing up Allistar thinks the secret behind his parents is that his father was the King, but the real secret that is being kept from him is his real mother was an elf who was cured of the taint... Of those who know the truth only Eamon (and possibly Allistars real mother) remain.
  • Noviere, SurelyForth, Dermain et 6 autres aiment ceci

#23
Magdalena11

Magdalena11
  • Members
  • 2 843 messages

I think the books and comics are really great for going more in depth into the series, but not in any way necessary to understand what's gone before, since anything relevant will be covered in game.  There are some really intriguing possible future plot implications in them, though, if you like to guess what might be important coming up.



#24
hexaligned

hexaligned
  • Members
  • 3 166 messages

I'd say the only book that is ''required'' reading is Stolen Throne for DA:O, because otherwise the Loghain character's motivations will make little sense.

They made perfect sense, Biowares writing is typically better than the usual video game fare,  but it's never subtle, or objectively complex. I think people (westerners especially), have just been (sub)culturally programmed to have a disposition towards seeing antagonist, once they are presented, as mustache twirling villains.  


  • cindercatz aime ceci

#25
Maria Caliban

Maria Caliban
  • Members
  • 26 094 messages
I don't consider them important or required, especially as there's a wiki.
  • Ailith Tycane aime ceci