Because this isn't a debate, XD you said something that was just plainly wrong and now are praticing free-climbing on mirrors by trying to change what you said.
You tried to sass a person telling: QUOTE
Trying to be clever?
._.
A spirit during the age of creation, after the introduction of discord into arda though, he became a progenitor elf, its just simpler to recall the character as an elf.
Because that was what he was for recorded history." /END QUOTE
Which is just wrong.
Simple as that.
Now, if you want a debate on this last post of your [which still shows a certain confusion lore-wise (for example: orcs are not an original creation the only Vala creating life without Eru's permission was Aulë (not a renegade Vala at all), the elves who followed the Valar were not the only ones that resulted in "what the lore recognizes ads elves (example:the Sindar, Avari; Silvan), Eru created Ea besides elves and men, and I took into consideration the published Silmarillion as the main source (not a song, HOME has songs) and apart from the Ainulindalë there are no sources documenting the pre-Awakening period.]
It really isn't? Mirror climbing isn't what i'm doing, i consider the offshoot of elves, to be the offshoot of elves.
The Avari an offshoot i mentioned prior, so bringing something i already mentioned into this, doesn't do much. I consider the Maia, which are in essence the Valar, which interbred with the primordial elves to create them into what they are today, to be the beginning of the elf race.
Honestly, its a pretty simple theory and it doesn't contradict the given lore, only a creation myth that hasn't ever really been expanded upon, Eru awoke the elves, there was never any indicator that however, that he had created them, That brings into question, what created them when the material world was forming at the end of the age of creation, but that doesn't have to do with what i propose.
Also i don't recall stating Orcs were an original creation, i stated the rebel ainur created life outside the bounds of Eru, which he did.
And Melkor is an Ainur, the strongest of his kind created. not a valar by the way.
Bleh, I really don't wish to discuss this any further, because apparently we have both reached the point where we are going to cite our own lore as basis, I consider Sauron an elf, due to the race he assumed when he came to the world, aka a lesser Ainur Valar.
Which directly had a hand in creating the elves we saw in the series, due to the interbreeding.
Just a theory, but it makes sense to me.