57 réponses à ce sujet

[TurianRebel212]

Number 1 should Be Half Life 2 or Resident Evil 4. 

[Johnnie Walker]

Number 1 should Be Half Life 2 or Resident Evil 4. 

1 + 4 - 2 = 3

 

Half-Life 3 confirmed.

[TurianRebel212]

1 + 4 - 2 = 3

 

Half-Life 3 confirmed.

 

 

[Johnnie Walker]

A few weeks days ago I had a wishbone from this whole chicken. Thus I decided to make a wish because why the fcuk not. I had just recently replayed Half-Life 2 at the time so naturally I wished for Gaben to get on with Half-Life 3.

This is what happened..

 

 

Half-Life 3 confirmed...?

[Ridwan]

Any list that doesn't have Super Mario Bros. in the top 5 is a fail list.

[Ridwan]

Half-Life 3 is going to be a disappointment.

[Chris]

Sh!t list ! Fallout 3 ? but not Fallout 2, what !?!, lack of Ultima 7,Wizardry, Jagged Alliance,Heroes 3 and Gothic 2.

 

I give up, i could take up lots of games that i wanted in a 100 top list but it's no point !

[TurianRebel212]

Where is Hello Kitty Island Adventure??? 

[Nukekitten]

Thoughts?

They're the games that Empire magazine readers liked. Which is another way to say they're the games that the sort of people who like Empire magazine are likely to vote for. Since I don't like Empire magazine, the overlap in our tastes is likely to be quite small.

Depending on the distribution of tastes among those who read Empire, and how they worked out the voting, the list may well be worse than useless anyway. But hey ho, that's one of the drawbacks of voting: it has a tendency to dilute choice; clear judgement and meaningful expression of taste.

[Ridwan]

They're the games that Empire magazine readers liked. Which is another way to say they're the games that the sort of people who like Empire magazine are likely to vote for. Since I don't like Empire magazine, the overlap in our tastes is likely to be quite small.

Depending on the distribution of tastes among those who read Empire, and how they worked out the voting, the list may well be worse than useless anyway. But hey ho, that's one of the drawbacks of voting: it has a tendency to dilute choice; clear judgement and meaningful expression of taste.

 

Shows you why hardcore gamers should never be listened to. Any list, and no this is my opinion or subjectivey, that doesn't have Super Mario Bros. 3 in the top five is deeply flawed. In this case, you got hardcore gamers, voting without thinking logically.

 

Key games like Civilisation, Super Mario Bros. and the likes should always be on the top of any list.

[Fang]

A few weeks days ago I had a wishbone from this whole chicken. Thus I decided to make a wish because why the fcuk not. I had just recently replayed Half-Life 2 at the time so naturally I wished for Gaben to get on with Half-Life 3.

This is what happened..

 

 

Half-Life 3 confirmed...?

Three bones = 3

 

That chicken now has half a life as there is now a version of itself in an alternate reality in which it still lives.

 

Half life chicken + 3 = Half life 3

[Johnnie Walker]

Three bones = 3

 

That chicken now has half a life as there is now a version of itself in an alternate reality in which it still lives.

 

Half life chicken + 3 = Half life 3

 

Quiet, Jon Snow

[AventuroLegendary]

Whenever I see a top 5 list or anything, I stop when I notice Ocarina of Time. 

 

It's a good game but it's indicative of blind nostalgia, more often than not.

 

Subjectivity and all.

[President of Boom]

Half-Life 2 at 15, Portal 2 at 41, Silent Hill 2 at 62, Fallout 3 at 25, Homeworld at 98... but oh, GTA *twice* in top twenty, CoD *anything* anywhere near this list, ME2 higher up than ME, Halo in top ten, and The Last of Us at number one.

 

Empire Magazine, yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

[Hello!I'mTheDoctor]

Whenever I see a top 5 list or anything, I stop when I notice Ocarina of Time. 

 

It's a good game but it's indicative of blind nostalgia, more often than not.

 

Subjectivity and all.

 

Despite owning an N64 since I was 7 years old (I still have it and it still works), I never played OoT until a couple of years ago. My reaction was that it was greatly overrated. Granted, I was spoiled by Twilight Princess and WindWaker. Majora's Mask was better imo. It was a great game, don't get me wrong, but the other LoZ's were better.

[slimgrin]

The Last of Us represents both an advance and a step back for games imo. When a game is that much watching cutscenes with small bits of redundant gameplay, it shouldn't be called a game. But the presentation and voice acting are excellent.

[TheChris92]

This list is going to get a few thumbs up for including SH2 at least -- There's definitely some worthy Zeus-bestowed-gems on it, but also a lot of tripe sandwiches like Championship Manager? Duke Nukem? Skyward Sword? Guns of the Patriots? League of Legends of all things?!

[AventuroLegendary]

Despite owning an N64 since I was 7 years old (I still have it and it still works), I never played OoT until a couple of years ago. My reaction was that it was greatly overrated. Granted, I was spoiled by Twilight Princess and WindWaker. Majora's Mask was better imo. It was a great game, don't get me wrong, but the other LoZ's were better.

 

I definitely feel that way, too. 

 

If anything, OoT was a beta test for 3D Zelda. It made way for better games in the style. It's sort of how Symphony of the Night (Also overrated) made way for Metroidvanias.

[Fishy]

Edit..

 

Since it's was a fan vote anyway .. That why the list is a mess.

[themikefest]

Why isn't Pong on the list. I would rank it as #1