71 réponses à ce sujet

[bmwcrazy]

Ah top PC games, well there goes my Chrono Trigger point, though I still contend DOTA 2 shouldn't even be on that list

 

DotA 2 is by far the most played multiplayer game on Steam. It is 2 to 3 times larger than Counter Strike Global Offensive, 20 times larger than all Call of duty games combined.

 

Say what you want but this remake (or sequel) of the original DotA mod is a very balanced, very well thought out, and very entertaining game. With the success it has achieved so far, it definitely deserves to be on the top 100 list.

[chance52]

DotA 2 is by far the most played multiplayer game on Steam. It is 2 to 3 times larger than Counter Strike Global Offensive, 20 times larger than all Call of duty games combined.

 

Say what you want but this remake (or sequel) of the original DotA mod is a very balanced, very well thought out, and very entertaining game. With the success it has achieved so far, it definitely deserves to be on the top 100 list.

 

Top 100 in history? I'm sorry but no way does DotA2 make the top 100 in history, let alone 16th best of all time. This guy is saying that of all PC games in existence, only 15 are better than DotA2.

 

Liking a game is not the same as it being in a top 100 of all time.  I really like Two Worlds 2, but if I was making a 'best of all time' list I would have to leave it off for all that was wrong with it.  Also how is Myst not anywhere on that list? That game is all most people could talk about for like 10 years after it came out

[bmwcrazy]

Top 100 in history? I'm sorry but no way does DotA2 make the top 100 in history, let alone 16th best of all time. This guy is saying that of all PC games in existence, only 15 are better than DotA2.

 

Liking a game is not the same as it being in a top 100 of all time.  I really like Two Worlds 2, but if I was making a 'best of all time' list I would have to leave it off for all that was wrong with it.  Also how is Myst not anywhere on that list? That game is all most people could talk about for like 10 years after it came out

 

When you look back in ten years, people will still talk about DotA 2 and it being one of the most successful multiplayer games of all time.

 

Like WoW, it will remain on the top 100 list for a while.

[Ridwan]

These lists are always so amusing since they bring out the "My opinion about video games is fact and this list is wrong because I disagree with it" crowd.

This would be a valid point, if some of the top games on that list wasn't an utter and complete bug fest, incomplete or had numerous content withheld to be sold as DLC.

 

Personally I don't care what games are on the list, as long as they are actually worthy of being on it. A top game should be a polished complete and well played game. And quite a few of the games on that list, doesn't reflect that, hence peoples criticism.

[Pateu]

Skyrim #2 is insanity.

 

WoW #34 is dumb as well.

 

If anything, WoW should be #1 for managing to have 7 million players 10 years after its launch.

 

And while I loved ME2 it definitely isn't the best game ever made. Not even the best RPG.

 

edit:

 

Oh my god Fallout 3 is 30 or so places above New Vegas what is this ****.

[Elhanan]

Another list out of harmony with my opinions. As I am still playing NWN1 occasionally after all these years after release, it continues to hold my Top spot of games from this century; longer if one takes development into consideration. Pass.

[Cyonan]

This would be a valid point, if some of the top games on that list wasn't an utter and complete bug fest, incomplete or had numerous content withheld to be sold as DLC.

 

Personally I don't care what games are on the list, as long as they are actually worthy of being on it. A top game should be a polished complete and well played game. And quite a few of the games on that list, doesn't reflect that, hence peoples criticism.

 

Yeah all I'm getting is "The list would be fine as long as I agree'd that everything should be on the list". Criticism is fine, but these people are flat out saying somebody else's opinion is wrong which is just stupidity, arrogance, or both.

 

Besides this is the internet. I could claim that Half-Life is the best game of all time(and I do, actually) and I would have plenty of people to show up and tell me about how I'm wrong because I didn't say Planescape or whatever other game they like.

[Steelcan]

bad lists are still bad

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Now I'm motivated to write my own list!

[DarthFoot]

These lists are always so amusing since they bring out the "My opinion about video games is fact and this list is wrong because I disagree with it" crowd.

You have those people yes, but with all jokes aside, this list is a full joke.

There are enough games on that list that dont even belong there. i do agree with some but technical wise that list is bullshit

[Dominus]

Now I'm motivated to write my own list!

Same here. I'll just list my favorites.

20. Fallout: New Vegas
19. Mark of the Ninja
18. Fez
17. American McGee's Alice
16. Penumbra
15. Doom
14. Warcraft III
13. Amnesia: TDD
12. Mass Effect 2
11. Diablo II
10. Witcher 2: Assassin of Kings
9. World of Warcraft
8. Arcanum
7. Planescape: Torment
6. Myst
5. System Shock 2
4. Thief II: The Metal Age
3. Mass Effect 1
2. Dark Souls
1. Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

[TurianRebel212]

lol, Nope. 

 

CS 1.6

Quake 3 Arena

Planescape Torment 

Half Life 2

Mass Effect 2

WoW

Starcraft 2

 

 

I mean, that's just off the top of my head. 

 

Crysis 1 and Warhead should be there as well, such a shame the way Crytek dumb it down for consoles.... Muhahaha. How's that workin' out for Crytek lately....

[ObserverStatus]

Same here. I'll just list my favorites.

 

People here always post these top x game lists, and everyone complains, but they never post their own, never show people how it's done. We need to change this. My list > yours

 

20. Hatoful Boyfriend

19. Blacklight: Retribution

18. Dead Space

17. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

16. The Stanley Parable

15. Amnesia: The Dark Descent

14. Mass Effect

13. Fallout 3

12. Dragon Age: Origins

11. Fallout 2

10. Mass Effect 2

9. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

8. World of WarCraft

7. System Shock 2

6. Fallout

5. Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

4. WarCraft III

3. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2

2. Fallout: New Vegas

1. StarCraft

[TurianRebel212]

lol, any list for "greatest" pc games of all time that does not have CS 1.6 and Quake 3 Arena in at least the top 10 is an epic fail. EPIC Fail. That's like having Magic and Bird not in the top 10 NBA players of all time. Derp. 

[ObserverStatus]

lol, any list for "greatest" pc games of all time that does not have CS 1.6 and Quake 3 Arena in at least the top 10 is an epic fail. EPIC Fail. That's like having Magic and Bird not in the top 10 NBA players of all time. Derp. 

oh hush, at least I don't think the sequel is better than the original StarCraft. 95% of everything about StarCraft II's storytelling was an EPIC Fail.

[TurianRebel212]

lulz, only the ultimate scrubs would deem CS 1.6 and Quake 3 Arena as less than worthy. 

 

If you do so you are unworthy of you PC and should just stop and get a WiiU or PS4 or something. 

[ObserverStatus]

lulz, only the ultimate scrubs would deem CS 1.6 and Quake 3 Arena as less than worthy. 

If you do so you are unworthy of you PC and should just stop and get a WiiU or PS4 or something. 

If StarCraft 1 isn't in your top 10, you should be playing the Xbox One.

[TurianRebel212]

Yeah, I'd have both of them probably in the top 20 maybe 10. 

[Dominus]

My list > yours

fite me irl tbh My IP's 867.5309

I'd have listed Starcraft as a favorite if I was any good at it.

Crysis 1 and Warhead should be there as well, such a shame the way Crytek dumb it down for consoles.

S'got cool mechanics and a nice open world, but the story doesn't really blow me away. It's a great exclusive regardless, tho.

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Take these 30 games.

 

30. Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines

29. GTA IV: Lost and Damned

28. Icewind Dale 1

27. Divinity Original Sin

26. Assassin's Creed IV - Black Flag

25. Call of Duty - World at War

24. Wizardry 8

23. Victoria I

22. Call of Duty - BlackOps 2

21. Sim City 4

20. Jedi Knight - Jedi Academy

19. Unreal

18. Mortal Kombat IX

17. LEGO MARVEL Super Heroes

16. Might and Magic VIII

15. Star Wars Galactic Battlegrounds

14. XCom: Enemy Unknown

13. Doom 2

12. Fallout - Tactics

11. KOTOR II

10. Borderlands 2

9.  NWN 1+2

8. Mass Effect 2

7. Heroes of Might and Magic V

6. Crusader Kings II

5. Age of Empires II

4. Dark Souls 2

3. Civilization V - Brave New World

2. Fallout - New Vegas

1. Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast

 

Still many games not played or very early in progress, so this will change again.

[Ridwan]

Yeah all I'm getting is "The list would be fine as long as I agree'd that everything should be on the list". Criticism is fine, but these people are flat out saying somebody else's opinion is wrong which is just stupidity, arrogance, or both.

 

Besides this is the internet. I could claim that Half-Life is the best game of all time(and I do, actually) and I would have plenty of people to show up and tell me about how I'm wrong because I didn't say Planescape or whatever other game they like.

 

I know mate, and you're right about some of the whiners. But I still stand by my statement that any top list should not include the type of games I mentioned earlier.