And you also think the taint was a just punishment from the Maker, I suppose?
No. since i believe the eternal city and the golden city are the same place. and thats makes me question what did fen'harel actually imprison. i don't believe the maker is true as the chantry says. and i am a pro-chantry player so i'm not biased. i believe the taint is something more.
The taint is almost like a possession on its own and the magisters are like abominations but different. but it becomes a whole new species after a few generation. so no i don't think the magisters turned the city black and no i dont think the makers punished thedas.
Just because my opinion is different doesn't mean its cookie cutter. And i base my feelings about the forgotten ones and the old gods off of the legends. not by appearance