Aller au contenu

Photo

Fiona. Alistairs potential mother.


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
535 réponses à ce sujet

#301
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Loghain always gets his head chopped off so...

 

no

 

In my headcanon, my Warden says something like this to Loghain.

Mage Warden: I sacrificed my friendship with the closest friend I've ever had. Do NOT give me cause to regret that more than I already do.



#302
Shadow Fox

Shadow Fox
  • Members
  • 4 206 messages

Bummer.

Hey at-least he becomes dragon food so Cousland can keep shagging Leiliana right? :P



#303
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Mage Warden Hawke Inqusitor hopes his god baby will carry on the good work of ruining the Chantry.

:-)



#304
Shadow Fox

Shadow Fox
  • Members
  • 4 206 messages

Mage Warden Hawke Inqusitor hopes his god baby will carry on the good work of ruining the Chantry.

:-)

It was more he didn't want to cheat on his girl and subject a child to Morrigan as a mother in Cousland's case. :unsure:



#305
LobselVith8

LobselVith8
  • Members
  • 16 993 messages

I could have sworn this was a thread about Fiona, and her potential relationship to Alistair, who might be King of Ferelden in the canon of some players.


  • HeyCal aime ceci

#306
Grand Admiral Cheesecake

Grand Admiral Cheesecake
  • Members
  • 5 704 messages

It was more he didn't want to cheat on his girl and subject a child to Morrigan as a mother in Cousland's case. :unsure:

 

That's why you harden Alistair, force him to marry Anora, tell Morrigan to **** off, and feed Loghain to the Archdemon.

 

Everybody wins.


  • Tielis et Drasanil aiment ceci

#307
Shadow Fox

Shadow Fox
  • Members
  • 4 206 messages

I could have sworn this was a thread about Fiona, and her potential relationship to Alistair, who might be King of Ferelden in the canon of some players.

So basically a thread for people to attack each other over her?...I like this better

 

That's why you harden Alistair, force him to marry Anora, tell Morrigan to **** off, and feed Loghain to the Archdemon.

 

Everybody wins.

I wouldn't wish her on my worst enemy cheese. :lol:



#308
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

That's why you harden Alistair, force him to marry Anora, tell Morrigan to **** off, and feed Loghain to the Archdemon.

 

Everybody wins.

 

Mage Warden Hawke Inqusitor had a deep affection for Morrigan.

He just understood he had more in common with Leliana.

I imagine if you're going to do a one-night-stand, "I would die otherwise" is as good a defense as any.

Though it still might explain why Leliana went to work for the Divine.



#309
Shadow Fox

Shadow Fox
  • Members
  • 4 206 messages

Mage Warden Hawke Inqusitor had a deep affection for Morrigan.

He just understood he had more in common with Leliana.

I imagine if you're going to do a one-night-stand, "I would die otherwise" is as good a defense as any.

Though it still might explain why Leliana went to work for the Divine.

Do you really want to risk pissing your ex assassin lover off? :P



#310
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Do you really want to risk pissing your ex assassin lover off? :P

My first playthrough, I was HORRIBLE to Leliana.

She left me for Majoraine.

I didn't even know that was POSSIBLE.

I assume they teamed up to kill me.


  • Shadow Fox aime ceci

#311
LobselVith8

LobselVith8
  • Members
  • 16 993 messages

So basically a thread for people to attack each other over her?...I like this better

 

No one has to attack Fiona. I guess discussing Fiona with civility isn't within the realm of possibility, however.



#312
Shadow Fox

Shadow Fox
  • Members
  • 4 206 messages

No one has to attack Fiona. I guess discussing Fiona with civility isn't within the realm of possibility, however.

"For people to attack each other over her"

 

Much like any mage/elf discussion here isn't it seems.



#313
Gorguz

Gorguz
  • Members
  • 235 messages

Poor Elthina...

 

Honestly Anders killing a lady that reminded me of my grandmother didn't earn him any brownie points.

Elthina was the best manipulating character in the universe. It is not as innocent as she claims to be. She was the one who made Petrice a Mother (approving her antiqunari campaing, if she wasn't the mind behind that operations from the start), and the one who left her to the qunari when she wasn't useful anymore. She didn't even look sorrowful, she simply turned her back. But did she not tell to Sebastian that death is never justice? It seems like she say something and act the other way.

And she was the one who allowed Meredith to be a psycho ******. She had the power to turn the templars against meredith, and since even the most loyal templars and the nobles started fearing Meredith, she wouldn't have had any problem doing so. But she did nothing, cause the chantry (and her) were gaining power with Meredith on charge.

Elthina was the best villain ever.


  • Tielis aime ceci

#314
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Fiona is a character I actually look forward to seeing. I think the character has a lot of potential but I think it'll largely depend on her presentation in the story versus how she's presented in the Calling--which is over forty years ago as I reckon time. As a woman in her sixties, I don't expect her to act like she did before and I'd be interesting if we got a more nuanced depiction of her role during the Mage's Rebellion.

 

Is she still stalwart like a Grey Warden, unintimidated by the Templars? Does this put her at odds with her fellow Mages who HAVEN'T faced legions of Darkspawn?

Is she stunned by the fact she's helped bring a Blight-level disaster to Thedas?

 

Does she mourn the thousands who have died because of her actions? Including many under her command.

 

I think I'm willing to give Bioware a chance in writing the answers to all this.



#315
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages

I will trash economy and then some if it frees the slaves.

The economy? Please.

Do you realize that Astapor, the first city Daenerys "freed" was taken over by a butcher who killed the whole council she left to rule and then seized every highborn boy in the city to make new Unsullied. Every pyramid became an armed camp and the marker was devoid of food.

And that was before the Yunkai'i arrived at which point, at the same time they were sieging the city, civil war broke within, it went through three different rulers before it got to the point where they just unhearted the body of the previously mentioned butcher, mounted him and sent him to fight the Yunkai'i, stuffed larvae and all. The city was sacked and then plague arrived.

 

So, yeah. Good job Daenerys.



#316
MisterJB

MisterJB
  • Members
  • 15 587 messages

Is she stunned by the fact she's helped bring a Blight-level disaster to Thedas?

Actually, that is a very good point.

First, she helps to start the Fifth Blight, then she helps start a Mage-Templar war.

 

Someone needs to stop this woman before she kills more people!
 



#317
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Actually, that is a very good point.

First, she helps to start the Fifth Blight, then she helps start a Mage-Templar war.

 

Someone needs to stop this woman before she kills more people!
 

 

I would be interested in that but, honestly, Thedas needed to be wrecked every which way from Sunday.

:)



#318
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

 

And she was the one who allowed Meredith to be a psycho ******. She had the power to turn the templars against meredith, and since even the most loyal templars and the nobles started fearing Meredith, she wouldn't have had any problem doing so. But she did nothing, cause the chantry (and her) were gaining power with Meredith on charge.

Elthina was the best villain ever.

No, she actually didn't have the power to do anything. And since she denied every single on of Meredith's "psycho ******" actions, I'm not really sure what your point is. 



#319
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

No, she actually didn't have the power to do anything. And since she denied every single on of Meredith's "psycho ******" actions, I'm not really sure what your point is.

Part of my problem with Dragon Age 2 is that it did the Templar vs. Mage conflict in microcosm. The Chantry is sympathetic to the Mages but keeps the Templars in power, the Templars hate the Mages, and the Mages hate the Templars. Ultimately, Anders just exposed the fact that the "back and forth" between the three needed to end.



#320
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Part of my problem with Dragon Age 2 is that it did the Templar vs. Mage conflict in microcosm. The Chantry is sympathetic to the Mages but keeps the Templars in power, the Templars hate the Mages, and the Mages hate the Templars. Ultimately, Anders just exposed the fact that the "back and forth" between the three needed to end.

1. Templars do not hate mages. Radicals hate mages.

2. The Mages don't hate Templars. They hate Meredith and radicals. 

3. The Chantry keeps the Templars in power because the Templars are a part of the Chantry. A necessary one. 

4. Kirkwall is a standard Circle as a ghoul is a standard person. 

5. All Anders exposed anyone too was hot ash and death. What needed to end was the blood magic loose in the Circle, and I was happy to oblige. 



#321
Grand Admiral Cheesecake

Grand Admiral Cheesecake
  • Members
  • 5 704 messages

Actually, that is a very good point.

First, she helps to start the Fifth Blight, then she helps start a Mage-Templar war.

 

Someone needs to stop this woman before she kills more people!
 

 

Mage: Ehy Fiona what're we gonna do today?

Fiona: The same thing we try to do every day Mage-y. Try to take over the world **** Thedas over even more!


  • sarbas aime ceci

#322
Dean_the_Young

Dean_the_Young
  • Members
  • 20 684 messages

Autonomous, my ass. They were ruled by the Templars and you know it. Call a spade, a spade, JB.

 

They were ruled by the Templars, who could legally do whatever they wanted except everything they couldn't and didn't do that any effective system of rulership would have allowed them to do.

 

Meredith couldn't even search the rooms and private property of her own tower, when she was at the height of her already highly disproportionate and barely restrained power. Even liberal democracies have governments that can do that. Meredith didn't get to dictate the promotion or alignment of mages, only performed unilateral tranquility very late on when she was blatantly breaking the laws in place, and couldn't even dictate the political leadership of the mages (which is one of the key tests for effective autonomy of a subordinate group- when they can have and keep their own leadership).

 

 

I'm quite happy to call a spade a spade, but you have to show me a spade first. Even in Kirkwall the mages had substantial autonomy, despite the abuses of Templar power and restrictions. It was certainly restrictive, but autonomy doesn't mean 'free': it always functions within the scope of what exactly is up for autonomy.
 


  • Drasanil, Boss Fog, Aimi et 2 autres aiment ceci

#323
Gorguz

Gorguz
  • Members
  • 235 messages

No, she actually didn't have the power to do anything. And since she denied every single on of Meredith's "psycho ******" actions, I'm not really sure what your point is. 

She had power. Do not forget that knight commanders (Meredith like gregoir) are always seconds to the Grand Cleric, or whoever is the highest representative of the Chantry in the region. Elthina was the one with the last word. Right in the beginnig of act 3 we see her giving orders to Orsino, Meredith and even Meredith bodyguards!.She didn't move to stop the abuses because she didn't want to: without a viscount she, as representative of the Chantry, was the ruler of Kirkwall. Her genius was in the way she hide her ambition behind the caring grandma facade. She tricked everyone.


  • Tielis aime ceci

#324
Lulupab

Lulupab
  • Members
  • 5 455 messages
I will not answer any off-topic posts. Its really impolite to ignore the mods when they say stay on topic.

They were ruled by the Templars, who could legally do whatever they wanted except everything they couldn't and didn't do that any effective system of rulership would have allowed them to do.
 
Meredith couldn't even search the rooms and private property of her own tower, when she was at the height of her already highly disproportionate and barely restrained power. Even liberal democracies have governments that can do that. Meredith didn't get to dictate the promotion or alignment of mages, only performed unilateral tranquility very late on when she was blatantly breaking the laws in place, and couldn't even dictate the political leadership of the mages (which is one of the key tests for effective autonomy of a subordinate group- when they can have and keep their own leadership).
 
 
I'm quite happy to call a spade a spade, but you have to show me a spade first. Even in Kirkwall the mages had substantial autonomy, despite the abuses of Templar power and restrictions. It was certainly restrictive, but autonomy doesn't mean 'free': it always functions within the scope of what exactly is up for autonomy.


The separation from chantry is the important factor here and it was the main concern of Fiona. The circles should exist and mages must be confined but they should decide their own fate because the chantry dictates everything. For example if we are looking at things rather courteously, say mages are unhappy with a certain Templar who patrols inside the circle. The mages should have the power to replace this Templar by sending him to outside patrol and bringing in another one for the same duty. This is just a simple example and there are many more to be made. Whatever decisions mages make they will be ones affected by it. And the Templars have volunteered.

Mages are kept like living weapons who are called upon when needed, its wrong on so many levels. After the separation each circle will be like a nation and when Thedas needs help they will decide how to aid others, they will also decide how many of their brethren should join the grey wardens. This way no nation can use mages to fight other nations, because for example the circle in Orlais DOES NOT belong to Orlais, its an independent nation of mages and therefore its not obligated to aid Orlais in attacking Ferelden. Using mages in a war between nations only brings catastrophe and destruction and must be avoided at all costs.

Also the circles will not be based on bloody Gallows (just look at the name ffs) a scene that horrified every single man woman and child when they saw it. And lets be honest here, life is not fair and mages are born with extra gifts and are precious so they actually deserve better living conditions.

#325
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

She had power. Do not forget that knight commanders (Meredith like gregoir) are always seconds to the Grand Cleric, or whoever is the highest representative of the Chantry in the region. Elthina was the one with the last word. Right in the beginnig of act 3 we see her giving orders to Orsino, Meredith and even Meredith bodyguards!.She didn't move to stop the abuses because she didn't want to: without a viscount she, as representative of the Chantry, was the ruler of Kirkwall. Her genius was in the way she hide her ambition behind the caring grandma facade. She tricked everyone.

Elthina is basically an example of the passive face of the Chantry in my mind. She's a pacifist in not only ideals but action.

Telling Meredith "don't abuse mages" is too much action.

So is stopping Petrice.