Aller au contenu

Photo

Mages or Templars?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
3241 réponses à ce sujet

#101
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 914 messages

My popcorn bucket is posed and waiting to be flipped once the fighting becomes more intense. But to add more flame to the fire..... BLOOD MAGIC

this had better not be human... i stepped in

Mages.I understand why the Templars do what they do, though.Which leaves me wondering whether I want to be merciful for my DA:I playthrough or Mageneto.

magneto didnt help my friend

#102
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

She was not a mage. It is stated several times

 

By sources that were obviously corrupted by the blood mage in question.

 

Accept them as you will, i however don't view their testimony as worth much.



#103
WillieStyle

WillieStyle
  • Members
  • 1 298 messages

I don't take that with much accuracy considering the lady in question was a blood mage who could have easily ensorcered her daughter to remember whatever she wanted her to remember.

 

 Wait what?  What evidence is there that Lady Harimann was a blood mage?! 



#104
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

 Wait what?  What evidence is there that Lady Harimann was a blood mage?! 

 

http://dragonage.wik...Johane_Harimann

 

Points out that quite clearly on her specialization, she also used it in combat.



#105
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

http://dragonage.wik...Johane_Harimann

 

Points out that quite clearly on her specialization, she also used it in combat.

 

Gameplay story segregation. She was certainly a "Blood Mage". There's no questioning that. But was she a mage or capable of casting spells before having dealt with the Desire Demon?



#106
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

Gameplay story segregation. She was certainly a "Blood Mage". There's no questioning that. But was she a mage or capable of casting spells before having dealt with the Desire Demon?

 

As i said there was nothing to indicate that one way or another, The devs never said a word on it to my knowledge.

 

However given she is a blood mage, i dismiss what her daughter stated, and assumed she was a mage all along.

 

That's the line of thought i follow.



#107
rigron

rigron
  • Members
  • 197 messages

First of all, hello everyone, I am a new member in this community and I hope we will have fun here. I played Dragon Age Origins (great game) on 360, I played Dragon Age 2 (not so great...) on PC and now I have Dragon Age Inquisition preordered for the PS4. One thing: I am not a native english speaker, I will be asking for forgiveness for my bad english a lot of times so please, keep that in mind if you come across gramatical errors on my post

 

Now with the thread´s topic: Mages. I make a Mage character and go with the mages on my first playthrought of DA games: I went with them on Dragon Age Origins, I sided with them on Dragon Age 2 and I will side with them again as a human male Mage Inquisitor in Dragon Age Inquisition and do my best to wipe out the Templars and the Chantry if possible for the freedom of mages. I hope the game offers us the choice to side with either of them and for the different outcomes of that the decision to play out, well, differently, affecting the world of our game.

 

One of the things I really love of Dragon Age lore is everything related with mages, magic (specially Blood Magic), the Veil and the demons/spirits. I hope this conflict plays a big role in Inquisition and that we are allowed to either support Templars and wipe out Blood Mages, take the "preventive" stand and wipe out almost all mages (something like the purge of Meredith) or side with Mages and support only the freedom of "good" mages and teachings, support all Mages and teachings including Blood Mages/Magic and even  make bargains with demons (similar to the Desire Demon of DAO or Topor in DA2). It seems like one of our companions, Solas, has a lot of knowledge about the Veil, strange abilities related to it and he is able to freely move around there in some kind of lucid dreams and take one person (us) with him, so I am sure we will know more about it on DA Inquisition.



#108
Navasha

Navasha
  • Members
  • 3 724 messages

I make my first playthrough of any game is as a 'good' person, hence I can only ever bring myself to side with the mages.    I side with the Templars on my brash, violent, uncaring, renegade playthroughs.


  • Karai9 aime ceci

#109
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Gameplay story segregation. She was certainly a "Blood Mage". There's no questioning that. But was she a mage or capable of casting spells before having dealt with the Desire Demon?

You can't turn someone into a mage, and you can't just come into contact with a demon. It doesn't work that way. 


  • Icy Magebane aime ceci

#110
WillieStyle

WillieStyle
  • Members
  • 1 298 messages

http://dragonage.wik...Johane_Harimann

 

Points out that quite clearly on her specialization, she also used it in combat.

 

I don't find the meta-gaming "specialization" tag on an unofficial wiki page particularly convincing  And citing her combat skills as evidence she was a blood mage is somewhat circular.  The question is, can non-mages be possessed and granted magical powers by demons.  Given that question, an example of a demon-possessed person using magical powers cannot be dis-positive.  To assume that Lady Harimann was a mage is to beg the question.



#111
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

As i said there was nothing to indicate that one way or another, The devs never said a word on it to my knowledge.

 

However given she is a blood mage, i dismiss what her daughter stated, and assumed she was a mage all along.

 

That's the line of thought i follow.

 

Damn, the devs really need to answer that one. It would give a lot of insight to both sides of the Mage-Templar argument.


  • Senya, Darkly Tranquil et Master Warder Z_ aiment ceci

#112
Elite Midget

Elite Midget
  • Members
  • 4 193 messages

Inquisition should be about siding with either or making a new treaty that pleases both parties as they do seem to want peace hence the summit.

 

DA2 didn't have peace as an option because many factors, such as the idol making Meredith even more cray cray/Anders//dead Grand Cleric/incompetent Orsino, took that off the table. 

 

Now that heads are "somewhat" cooler the Inquisitor, with Hawke's help and reputation, could forge a long term peace between Templars and Mages.


  • Senya aime ceci

#113
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

 

No **** i just stated it was my own line of thought.

 

But she did demonstrated blood magical abilities, so the accuracy of what those under her thrall can recall is suspect to me.

 

Beyond that, there was never any indicator from the people who can actually CAN confirm this if she was or wasn't.

 

Believe as you will.



#114
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

You can't turn someone into a mage, and you can't just come into contact with a demon. It doesn't work that way. 

 

According to her daughter you can. Maybe she enthralled her daughter to say that as per Warder's suspicion, but there's insufficient information either way. The devs are the only ones that can answer that one. Who wrote Sebastian's arc and missions?



#115
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

According to her daughter you can. Maybe she enthralled her daughter to say that as per Warder's suspicion, but there's insufficient information either way. The devs are the only ones that can answer that one. Who wrote Sebastian's arc and missions?

Her daughter>literally everything else we know about mages now? 


  • Master Warder Z_ et sarbas aiment ceci

#116
Master Warder Z_

Master Warder Z_
  • Members
  • 19 819 messages

Damn, the devs really need to answer that one. It would give a lot of insight to both sides of the Mage-Templar argument.

 

Indeed, but we do know that spirits and demons and alike can already empower normal men.

 

But granting magic... i don't know.

 

That seems to be something far above just a plain old regular desire demon, that sounds like something you would want to ask of an elder pride demon.



#117
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 914 messages

First of all, hello everyone, I am a new member in this community and I hope we will have fun here. I played Dragon Age Origins (great game) on 360, I played Dragon Age 2 (not so great...) on PC and now I have Dragon Age Inquisition preordered for the PS4. One thing: I am not a native english speaker, I will be asking for forgiveness for my bad english a lot of times so please, keep that in mind if you come across gramatical errors on my post
 
Now with the thread´s topic: Mages. I make a Mage character and go with the mages on my first playthrought of DA games: I went with them on Dragon Age Origins, I sided with them on Dragon Age 2 and I will side with them again as a human male Mage Inquisitor in Dragon Age Inquisition and do my best to wipe out the Templars and the Chantry if possible for the freedom of mages. I hope the game offers us the choice to side with either of them and for the different outcomes of that the decision to play out, well, differently, affecting the world of our game.
 
One of the things I really love of Dragon Age lore is everything related with mages, magic (specially Blood Magic), the Veil and the demons/spirits. I hope this conflict plays a big role in Inquisition and that we are allowed to either support Templars and wipe out Blood Mages, take the "preventive" stand and wipe out almost all mages (something like the purge of Meredith) or side with Mages and support only the freedom of "good" mages and teachings, support all Mages and teachings including Blood Mages/Magic and even  make bargains with demons (similar to the Desire Demon of DAO or Topor in DA2). It seems like one of our companions, Solas, has a lot of knowledge about the Veil, strange abilities related to it and he is able to freely move around there in some kind of lucid dreams and take one person (us) with him, so I am sure we will know more about it on DA Inquisition.

hello rigron really glad your part of the BSN now dont mind the heated disscussion. its usualy not this heated :) but feel free to talk with us
  • rigron aime ceci

#118
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

Her daughter>literally everything else we know about mages now? 

 

She said that no one in their line had magic. I'd expect she'd recognize if her mother was an untrained mage in hiding. Common sense.



#119
Icy Magebane

Icy Magebane
  • Members
  • 7 317 messages

According to her daughter you can. Maybe she enthralled her daughter to say that as per Warder's suspicion, but there's insufficient information either way. The devs are the only ones that can answer that one. Who wrote Sebastian's arc and missions?

I remember her daughter saying "we've never had magic in our line," and not actually answering the question we asked her.  The idea of a non-mage being able to cast spells... advanced blood magic at that... is a bit far-fetched to me.  I'd like to hear what the devs have to say, since this contradicts everything we know about magic and the Fade.


  • Senya aime ceci

#120
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

Gameplay story segregation. She was certainly a "Blood Mage". There's no questioning that. But was she a mage or capable of casting spells before having dealt with the Desire Demon?

 

My theory was she's a hedge mage. As we see with Connor, nobility "opting out" of the Circle isn't uncommon.


  • Senya aime ceci

#121
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

I remember her daughter saying "we've never had magic in our line," and not actually answering the question we asked her.  The idea of a non-mage being able to cast spells... advanced blood magic at that... is a bit far-fetched to me.  I'd like to here what the devs have to say, since this contradicts everything we know about magic and the Fade.

 

The Old Gods did teach Darinius blood magic. So there's that. Perhaps a particularly powerful Desire Demon can actually grant a non-mage blood magic specifically if that's what they wanted or needed to achieve a greater goal.



#122
WillieStyle

WillieStyle
  • Members
  • 1 298 messages

Why all these emphatic claims that non-mages cannot be granted magical powers?  Did Knight-commander Meredith use "magic" in the final fight of DA:2?



#123
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

She said that no one in their line had magic. I'd expect she'd recognize if her mother was an untrained mage in hiding. Common sense.

Just like Eamon? Nah, friend, if you're untrained it's quite easy to hide your magic. Magic can also appear in bloodlines it was not in before, so that doesn't really mean anything. 


  • Master Warder Z_ aime ceci

#124
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

The Old Gods did teach Darinius blood magic. So there's that. Perhaps a particularly powerful Desire Demon can actually grant someone blood magic specifically if that's what they wanted or needed to achieve a greater goal.

Humans already had the capacity to use magic, they just didn't know how to. Dumat didn't personally grant every magister the ability to use magic. He taught one, and then he taught more.  



#125
Willowhugger

Willowhugger
  • Members
  • 3 489 messages

I have a very simple view of the Templar vs. Mage situation.

My view?

"I fully support mages but it's often very hard to do so when I keep having to kill them because so many of them are evil [censored]. I think between Hawke and the Warden, they've killed more Abominations and Mages than the Templar Order as a whole in a year."