Aller au contenu

Photo

Mages or Templars?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
3241 réponses à ce sujet

#2051
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Eh, I think they made a deliberate invocation of it for a parallel.

 

I'm not saying it's a big one but I think it's there.

It's also a part of Anders story with Karl.

How? Nobody cares about sexuality in Thedas. Like almost no one. And Gaider made it pretty clear the point was not to stress social issues with sexuality. The only value it had, you made for it. 



#2052
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

Yes, but it happened because that same organization's military arm bowed to nonviolent methods of resistance. (Of course, I am kinda interested to hear how Lambert would have reacted to such a thing.)

Are you talking about when the Circles were first formed? And wondering how Lambert would have reacted if he had been one of the templars there?



#2053
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 951 messages

Are you talking about when the Circles were first formed? And wondering how Lambert would have reacted if he had been one of the templars there?

I'm asking you to picture how he'd have reacted if he'd been in charge of them. Try to tell me that's not an amusing mental image.


  • dragonflight288 aime ceci

#2054
Cainhurst Crow

Cainhurst Crow
  • Members
  • 11 374 messages

god that game never sodding ends. Butbjoke aside its just unnecassary if you disagree cool but to make snide remarks its iffy at best. Personally i just think bioware should put a end to this mage templar bull its divided the fans


Only way that would happen would be for mages and templars to get majorly retconed, or removed all together.

And I don't think anyone wants to see that, no matter what side you fall on.

#2055
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 920 messages

People can identify different elements of fictional groups with real world groups - some people see Native American elements in the Dalish, while others see Jewish or Palestinian elements. Some have expressed that they like the Chantry because certain elements remind them of Christianity. I'm not certain why anyone should be denigrated for relating to certain elements about a fictional group because they can see something they relate to in that group.

i just defending his interpetation i dont see it like that but it was his. View of that scene not mine. Simple

#2056
dragonflight288

dragonflight288
  • Members
  • 8 852 messages

Yes, but it happened because that same organization's military arm bowed to nonviolent methods of resistance. (Of course, I am kinda interested to hear how Lambert would have reacted to such a thing.)

 

Lambert is a different man from a different country. He likely would have made very, VERY different choices, especially if he feared what may happen if the mages actually did get what they wanted. 

 

I don't know about the templars and their leaders way back when, but Lambert let his experiences in Tevinter rule his opinion on what may happen if the mages didn't do exactly as he wanted them to. 

 

Although, that would be an interesting alternate universe to read. 

 

 

Another thing is the Circle Towers are controlled, in theory, by the Enchanters.

 

They're just supervised by the Templars.

 

Technically true in theory, doesn't seem to be common in actual practice 1000 years later.

 

Irving: If things were up to me, they'd be different, but the chantry....*sigh* (in regards to Jowan's upcoming tranquility)

 

Nah, but pointing out how dumb opinions are is a past time of human society.

I mean, just look at Socrates. Dude made history and altered the entire course of greek society by just pointing out peoples opinions as being opinions. That and playing the longest game of "Why?" ever created.

 

One of my favorite things he did was when he was debating the priests. They were telling him that by asking questions the way he was, he was inviting the wrath of the gods upon him as it was unholy. He responded by asking what was holy between, Hades, Ares, and Athena. Once that question was answered, he pointed out that those gods had different views and different things they approved of, so by those priests same logic, an act could be both holy and unholy at the same time depending on which god you worshiped. 

 

He didn't make many friends by pointing out logical fallacies in their arguments. 



#2057
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

People can identify different elements of fictional groups with real world groups - some people see Native American elements in the Dalish, while others see Jewish or Palestinian elements. Some have expressed that they like the Chantry because certain elements remind them of Christianity. I'm not certain why anyone should be denigrated for relating to certain elements about a fictional group because they can see something they relate to in that group.

 

Folk also need to realize this is a fictional universe and not get so caught up in the hype that they forget to enjoy all aspects of that fictional universe. For example; I am black on my mother's side. That's not going to stop be from playing a hardcore Tevinter Magister if I get the chance. Can't wear your social issues on your sleeve or you won't get anything done including something as simple as enjoying Dragon Age.


  • Dean_the_Young, Icy Magebane, BlueMagitek et 3 autres aiment ceci

#2058
Cainhurst Crow

Cainhurst Crow
  • Members
  • 11 374 messages

I'm asking you to picture how he'd have reacted if he'd been in charge of them. Try to tell me that's not an amusing mental image.


He'd probably have some Sandor Clegane words for the divine mother ordering them to attack the chantry. Lamberts a hardline a-hole but he's no mad dog killer, there's gotta be more involved then just "mages don't want to be stuck doing candle and janitor duty" for him to act.

You gotta remember, lambert's been head of the seekers for years before DAO. All that time he didn't make a move, probably cause he didn't think there was a reason to, and then anders come and pulls dragon age 9/11 on everyone.

Things change. Rules change. Anders sympathizers and secessionists seem to get the majority of power. Things get nuts, and so people get nuts.

Mages boarding themselves in the chantry and not making an aggressive move/not using blood magic, summoning demons, calling forth AOE spells, etc, means the whole situations different, so characters would act accordingly.

That's like saying because someone got scared and ran from a mountain lion, they'd get scared and run from anything on a mountain, from goats to grass.

#2059
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 920 messages

Only way that would happen would be for mages and templars to get majorly retconed, or removed all together.And I don't think anyone wants to see that, no matter what side you fall on.

im thinking green ending lmao
  • Cainhurst Crow et sarbas aiment ceci

#2060
LobselVith8

LobselVith8
  • Members
  • 16 993 messages

i just defending his interpetation i dont see it like that but it was his. View of that scene not mine. Simple

 

I was speaking generally, since you brought up interpretation. It wasn't intended to be taken as a rebuke of what you wrote.



#2061
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

I'm asking you to picture how he'd have reacted if he'd been in charge of them. Try to tell me that's not an amusing mental image.

LOL! I can see him passing running around like a chicken with it's head cut off frothing at the mouth demanding they be allowed to preform the Exalted March immediately.



#2062
Cainhurst Crow

Cainhurst Crow
  • Members
  • 11 374 messages

im thinking green ending lmao


"Well, looks like we're all mages now. Might not be so bad. Now to let all the soldiers, farmers, peasants, destitutes, and everyone else with no former training mages get to go to bed and open themselves to the fade.

Nothing bad could possibly happen."
  • raging_monkey, Shadow Fox et sarbas aiment ceci

#2063
Cainhurst Crow

Cainhurst Crow
  • Members
  • 11 374 messages

LOL! I can see him passing running around like a chicken with it's head cut off frothing at the mouth demanding they be allowed to preform the Exalted March immediately.


Why?

#2064
dragonflight288

dragonflight288
  • Members
  • 8 852 messages

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone. 

 

That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with. 



#2065
BlueMagitek

BlueMagitek
  • Members
  • 3 583 messages

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone. 

 

That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with. 

 

I imagine that would end terribly, especially since demons seem to have rare or hard to dispel magic; look at how completely the Desire Demon had the Templar under her spell back in DA:O.  Only cure was death.  Now have a craftier demon with a King. 



#2066
Icy Magebane

Icy Magebane
  • Members
  • 7 317 messages

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone. 

 

That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with. 

I think you're in luck.  That sounds like the "demons win" ending I've been hearing about.



#2067
LobselVith8

LobselVith8
  • Members
  • 16 993 messages

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone. 

 

That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with. 

 

Yavana mentioned a time before the veil, when dragons ruled the world.



#2068
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 920 messages

"Well, looks like we're all mages now. Might not be so bad. Now to let all the soldiers, farmers, peasants, destitutes, and everyone else with no former training mages get to go to bed and open themselves to the fade.Nothing bad could possibly happen."

i blame mages...damn i am a mage

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone.  That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with.

it would be D&D new generation

#2069
dragonflight288

dragonflight288
  • Members
  • 8 852 messages

I think you're in luck.  That sounds like the "demons win" ending I've been hearing about.

 

It sort of reminds me of the bad ending in the game "The Bard's Tale"

 

Which is ironically the best ending for the Bard. 



#2070
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 951 messages

He'd probably have some Sandor Clegane words for the divine mother ordering them to attack the chantry. Lamberts a hardline a-hole but he's no mad dog killer, there's gotta be more involved then just "mages don't want to be stuck doing candle and janitor duty" for him to act.

You gotta remember, lambert's been head of the seekers for years before DAO. All that time he didn't make a move, probably cause he didn't think there was a reason to, and then anders come and pulls dragon age 9/11 on everyone.

Things change. Rules change. Anders sympathizers and secessionists seem to get the majority of power. Things get nuts, and so people get nuts.

Mages boarding themselves in the chantry and not making an aggressive move/not using blood magic, summoning demons, calling forth AOE spells, etc, means the whole situations different, so characters would act accordingly.

That's like saying because someone got scared and ran from a mountain lion, they'd get scared and run from anything on a mountain, from goats to grass.

All of which is fair, I suppose.



#2071
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

i blame mages.

So do I. Mages are the worst. 



#2072
thetinyevil

thetinyevil
  • Members
  • 831 messages

Why?

Why what?



#2073
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 951 messages

It would be interesting, instead of everyone becoming mages, if the veil is destroyed completely, and spirits and demons wander around the mortal world. They'd no longer have need of possessing anyone. 

 

That would remove the threat of mages becoming abominations. There would just be a butt load of demons that would have to be dealt with. 

No it wouldn't. Demons who have been forced into the material world in their true forms still possess mages quite willingly.



#2074
dragonflight288

dragonflight288
  • Members
  • 8 852 messages

No it wouldn't. Demons who have been forced into the material world in their true forms still possess mages quite willingly.

 

And anyone else they came across. Or anything, in the case of trees, corpses, animals, and so on. 

 

Mages would't be the only ones in danger. They still aren't, but they are the easiest targets. If there were no veil and demons could wander where they willed, anyone and everyone would be at risk. You'd see more non-mages being possessed by virtue of there being more of them than there are mages. 



#2075
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 920 messages

So do I. Mages are the worst.

i was making ajoke but thank you for taking it out of context lol still giving you the laugh:)