No, you are being purposefully obtuse and ignoring every developer comment or hypothetical that counters your objection. Blood magic is gone specifically because it is illegal throughout Thedas and carries a death penalty. There is no reason for us to believe that Gaider lied when he said that they could not do the spec justice in relation to the lore so they removed it. We've been told time and time again that the Inquisition does not have to support the Chantry, yet you refuse to believe this... why? I mean really, if the Inquisition can side with the mages, that should tell you right there that we are not puppets of the Chantry. Why would Laidlaw or Cameron Lee (I don't remember which...) have lied during the Skyhold interview? Why would Bioware lie at all about any of this?
No. What I am being is having a opinion and defending it. I´ve seen those comments from devs about the game/lore/story/gameplay, BUT, as a individual I make my own judgement from the bits of information available. Time will tell who is right won´t it? It´s not like Bio doesn´t have a recond of stating something and doing something else so I wouldn´t take everything they say like a word of god. My main argument is that blood magic is not much more diffucult to implement than any other magic branch. Story and gameplay can be finetuned so that using blood magic is possible (I´ve explained it before) and it works well with the rpg spirit. You use something people don´t like? Tought luck, then work with the tools you have. People and factions may leave but why is it that you can´t replace them with someone more acceptable? It might be because if you have already railroaded storyline with a specific faction then it comes more clear why such thing like blood magic is banned. And what faction in the gameworld hates most blood magic, thats right, andrastian chantry. If I´m proven wrong then excellent, but I am skeptical.
Couple of things:
- blood magic might be illegal in Thedas but the continent is in turmoil and in civil war. Who has time to watch for blood mages?
- pc is the only one who can close veil tears, who would deny him from using blood magic?