All right, this is strange, since I had been getting this guest (via miltiple playthroughs) with an imported save where Nathaniel was alive. (Wouldn't have brought it up otherwise). Good to know. 
Did you ALSO get the "Finding Nathaniel" quest? Because if you did, then it was a bug. If you did not, then Nathaniel was dead. Even if he wasn't. Because, there was in fact a bug in the save importing where unless you actually had Nathaniel with you when you fought Mother, he is flagged as dead in the save file. I call it the "babysitter bug" It's related to the other bug where unless you directly save Vigil's Keep the Keep falls and everybody dies (this may not be reflected in your tiles, it's a bug with the importing, as Nathaniel still gets flagged as dead even if you abandon Amaranthine and save Vigil's Keep, if he's not in your party for the Mother fight, he's dead). It doesn't matter with Anders/Justice because they return in DA2 no matter what. It does not matter with Sigrun, Oghren, or Velanna because they do not return. It only matters with Nathaniel.
Modifié par AbsolutGrndZer0, 23 octobre 2014 - 06:32 .