Lol, are we really still trying to excuse the magisters?
This thread is nice, very very very nice.
He admits it. He's a darkspawn. There's really no discussion.
Corypheus points more to the Chant's story being true than false... unless he was a Darkspawn before entering the Golden City - which, I'm thinking: No.
Corypheus points more to the Chant's story being true than false... unless he was a Darkspawn before entering the Golden City - which, I'm thinking: No.
True , I just think we need more information too make a real judgement.
We need more information to get the complete picture, true. But so far, we can make a judgment: that the Chantry's version, embellished and extremely biased as it is, it's the one that gets more sources backing it. Including the important part about Magisters + Fade Walk + Darkspawn being related in some way or another. That's the real matter here, because it's the most important reason the Chantry uses to speak ill of mages.
That the city was golden or black before or after the Fade Walk, that the Maker spoke or not, that Dumat tricked them or not is secondary and looks more like an attempt to avoid adressing the main issue here: that a Tevinter Magister did perform a Fade Walk to try to reach the fabled city and that he became tainted and was part of the first darkspawn known by Thedas.
There was more then one Tevinter magister to do the Fade Walk do.
It's amazing how easy "convert or die" is excused when it comes to the Chantry.
Lol, are we really still trying to excuse the magisters?
I hereby invoke the Right of Annulment.
Every pro-mage in the forums is to be banned. Imediatelly!
for just and secure society.
Given they willfully disregarded the treaty the onus was entirely on them
That was their home for generations and I would disregard an treaty that forced me from my home. They were also unarmed that were killed.
Antivan Maquis!
Quick, to the Badlands.
I hereby invoke the Right of Annulment.
Every pro-mage in the forums is to be banned. Imediatelly!
in fairness we dont know they were unarmed just assumptionThat was their home for generations and I would disregard an treaty that forced me from my home. They were also unarmed that were killed.
Antivan Maquis!
Quick, to the Badlands.
It was in the codex that they were unarmed protesters...[url] http://dragonage.wik...omerryn_Accords[\url]in fairness we dont know they were unarmed just assumption
Hey, at least I have morality to prevent me from killing unarmed people, which the chantry did in this situation.
Star Trek Maquis.
Told to leave there homes so the Fereration could play nice with the Cardassians, they said 'screw you' and did their own thing.
[quote name="Ryriena" post="17389899" timestamp="1411752667"]
That was their home for generations and I would disregard an treaty that forced me from my home.[/quote
Then you make that decision and accept its consequences.
They made their decision, nothing more.
How very Qunari of you.
Hey, at least I have morality
It was in the codex that they were unarmed protesters...
How very Qunari of you.
Don't recall that bit
the Rivain Chantry and nationalist forces, unable to convert its people back to the worship of the Maker, tried a purge by the sword, slaughtering countless unarmed people and burying them in mass graves.
-Codex Entry: The Llomerryn Accords
Here you go from the link here.Don't recall that bit
Qunari"—refused to leave their homes and go in exile to the islands. And again, when the Rivain Chantry and nationalist forces, unable to convert its people back to the worship of the Maker, tried a purge by the sword, slaughtering countless unarmed people and burying them in mass graves.
Ce sujet est fermé
Retour en haut