I still like it a great deal, though I fail to see why it's worshipped to such a degree.
The cliche story, clunky combat, choppy writing, stereotypical characters........this game hasn't aged very well.
But yes, I still love it. I'm more aware of its flaws now, however.
*Ducks out of the way before the eggs start flying*
Nah, I'm not going to throw eggs at you.
Origins' story made no secret about what it was. A Dark Fantasy tale with heavy emphasis on reconstructing the archetype of the "monomyth" as to present a new story with interesting angles and dynamics despite following a fairly common formula.
Yes, there's a clear and unambiguously evil threat that needs to be stopped. But the Warden doesn't have to be a knight in shining armor. (Mad Mairon Amell for example, laughed while the werewolves tore the elves apart)
Loghain is a traitor, but he's not a one-note villain with his own motivations and context which explain his actions and attitudes.
You have a band of companions that all fit a certain character mold, but that mold doesn't stop the characters from being enjoyable or even somewhat unique.
Couple that with a good combat and level-up/equipment system (clunky in parts, but has lots of room for customization); and you have yourself a great game that many believe has aged mostly well.
That said...I've also noticed several flaws that keep it from being "truly flawless". But I still love it.