Aller au contenu

Photo

Homosexuality in Thedas


1071 réponses à ce sujet

#651
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

He's only flirty when you stop his assassination attempt if your Warden is female. The male Warden will receive a hint that Zev has been with men at the party camp, and then has to ask him 'what he fancies.' After that Zevran pretty much outright asks male Warden if he is offended if he said he fancied him.

 

Here's the start of the party camp convos.

 

http://youtu.be/KncaRlV5MM4?t=8m2s

 

Ah, thanks. Makes me want to replay DA:O. 



#652
David Gaider

David Gaider
  • BioWare Employees
  • 4 514 messages

The existence of the lines from Zevran and Anders makes me believe that homosexual relations in Thedas aren't quite so accepted as the codex may lead one to believe, or perhaps more likely, that it was pandering to the straight bro gamer.

 

It means that the lack of general homophobia in a cultural sense does not mean there is not still the possibility of homophobia in the individual. Thedas does not lack for bigots, sexists, and generally disagreeable people who could potentially take "that's kind of weird" to new and exciting levels.


  • DalishRanger, DaySeeker, TheJediSaint et 16 autres aiment ceci

#653
Guest_Imanol de Tafalla_*

Guest_Imanol de Tafalla_*
  • Guests

I am fairly certain that somewhere in Thedas, there is a heterosexual or two who had to deal with uncomfortable advances from a homosexual and thus has a chip on their shoulder against the latter group as a whole.


  • Dream aime ceci

#654
Who Knows

Who Knows
  • Members
  • 1 328 messages

I do find it strange that the people of Thedas are, for the most part, so accepting of homosexuality. Being gay certainly isn't 'normal' as some people would have us believe, so the fact that they're so accepting of it is rather strange to me, especially when the setting of Thedas, and the Dragon Age universe as a whole, is supposed to be medieval-like, which makes it even more perplexing.

 

I'm not saying that we should have gay characters being lynched (or something like that) in Dragon Age, but having a few more characters who are less accepting of gays would make the world feel a little more realistic (you can't seriously be telling me that there are hardly any people in the Dragon Age universe who are homophobic).

Dragons are not realistic, and certainly not normal. Even in medieval times :rolleyes:

Yet no one complains about them being unrealistic. Why are dragons, dwarves, elves, qunari and magic exempt from the "realism" argument, but sexual orientation isn't?


  • Leoroc aime ceci

#655
Dark Helmet

Dark Helmet
  • Banned
  • 1 686 messages

Dragons are not realistic, and certainly not normal. Even in medieval times :rolleyes:

Yet no one complains about them being unrealistic. Why are dragons, dwarves, elves, qunari and magic exempt from the "realism" argument, but sexual orientation isn't?

 

As a general rule people are more willing to accept obvious fantasy elements, the aforementioned dwarves, elves, qunari and dragons but raise an eyebrow at smaller changes.

 

A dragon burning down a village wouldn't cause most to bat an eye but just about EVERY peasant being literate would.


  • Steelcan et eyezonlyii aiment ceci

#656
CuriousArtemis

CuriousArtemis
  • Members
  • 19 656 messages
I looked up "bigoted troll" on Google, and the username that came up was... Nah, better not go there.

#657
Vita Brevis

Vita Brevis
  • Members
  • 630 messages

Dragons are not realistic, and certainly not normal. Even in medieval times :rolleyes:

Yet no one complains about them being unrealistic. Why are dragons, dwarves, elves, qunari and magic exempt from the "realism" argument, but sexual orientation isn't?

Cause sexuality is a mundane thing.

And has little to do with the fantasy.

 

I do find it strange that the people of Thedas are, for the most part, so accepting of homosexuality. Being gay certainly isn't 'normal' as some people would have us believe, so the fact that they're so accepting of it is rather strange to me, especially when the setting of Thedas, and the Dragon Age universe as a whole, is supposed to be medieval-like, which makes it even more perplexing.

 

I'm not saying that we should have gay characters being lynched (or something like that) in Dragon Age, but having a few more characters who are less accepting of gays would make the world feel a little more realistic (you can't seriously be telling me that there are hardly any people in the Dragon Age universe who are homophobic).

Someone must've been missing history classes, yea? Because there were times in history when those things were not only normal but expected even. True, it wasn't in the medieval times but who really cares? And it's not that "normal" in DA, not to the point where no one cares or no one mentiones that and such. People just care less because they have more important things going on around than that, that's all. And the Chanty has more important things to preach, too.



#658
daveliam

daveliam
  • Members
  • 8 437 messages

Zevran's hesitation over hitting on another guy was done for the benefit of the straight guy audience. He was essentially asking the *player* for permission to hit on their male character.  That's why it seems to clash with the lore concerning homosexuality in Thedas.    Same with Leliana and female characters I believe.

 

That's how I've always read Zev's lines, as well.  It's less about the Warden and more about the player.  It's like the second warning after you try to delete a file, "Are you sure you want to flirt with a male?"


  • Dirthamen, eyezonlyii et Who Knows aiment ceci

#659
Lebanese Dude

Lebanese Dude
  • Members
  • 5 545 messages
Hey now.....criticizing the Zevran romance isn't really fair.

Remember the game was released a long time ago, and the flirtation interaction between the male PC and Zevran was probably the first "gay" experience for many players. (One that wasn't meant for comic relief that is)

Gay characters weren't as prevalent in video games back then as they are now. Every major game website talked about the potential romance and it even made American news.
Its also how I discovered Dragon Age when I had just come out while looking for something to relate to in the media,

So I think it was more about being cautious as pioneers in a controversial situation, rather than straight-bro pandering.

#660
Hellion Rex

Hellion Rex
  • Members
  • 30 037 messages

That's how I've always read Zev's lines, as well.  It's less about the Warden and more about the player.  It's like the second warning after you try to delete a file, "Are you sure you want to flirt with a male?"

It really amazes how much I see it now in hindsight. When I first played the game, admittedly as a freshman in high school, that concept went right over my head. I was kind of blown away by the fact that there was actually a guy I could romance in a game and have it not be a total joke.


  • daveliam et Dirthamen aiment ceci

#661
daveliam

daveliam
  • Members
  • 8 437 messages

Yeah, I usually acknowledge that Zev's terrible implementation (his double checking if it's "okay" to flirt with you; his constant yammering about how he likes women) was due to his being one of the first m/m LI's.  Sky, the only one who came before him, also had some questionable dialogue.  I found his implementation to be better, but I thin this is a ymmv situation.



#662
Lebanese Dude

Lebanese Dude
  • Members
  • 5 545 messages

Yeah, I usually acknowledge that Zev's terrible implementation (his double checking if it's "okay" to flirt with you; his constant yammering about how he likes women) was due to his being one of the first m/m LI's. Sky, the only one who came before him, also had some questionable dialogue. I found his implementation to be better, but I thin this is a ymmv situation.

Zevran is bisexual though, with a preference for women.

I don't think it dilutes his m/m romance at all.

I have a bisexual female friend who only talks about hot guys in the media but had had a long term lesbian relationship. It's normal.
  • Tevinter Rose aime ceci

#663
Vita Brevis

Vita Brevis
  • Members
  • 630 messages

I have a bisexual female friend who only talks about hot guys in the media but had had a long term lesbian relationship. It's normal. 

Um... how's that normal? 



#664
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

Um... how's that normal? 

Normal in that typically bisexual people have a preference for one or the other, yet can sustain long term relationships with either.


  • Tevinter Rose aime ceci

#665
Grieving Natashina

Grieving Natashina
  • Members
  • 14 554 messages

Being bisexual doesn't not preclude someone from being monogamous.  Just like with straight folks, we can be attracted to and comment on other people being hot while maintaining monogamy.  And while some pan/bisexual prefer one gender over the other (or don't think of it in such binary terms,) for others it can depend upon the person, not their gender.  

 

Hey Exile, I think that starting a "Bisexuality for Dummies" thread is looking really tempting again.


  • In Exile, karushna5 et Tevinter Rose aiment ceci

#666
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

Being bisexual doesn't not preclude someone from being monogamous. Just like with straight folks, we can be attracted to and comment on other people being hot while maintaining monogamy. And while some pan/bisexual prefer one gender over the other (or don't think of it in such binary terms,) for others it can depend upon the person, not their gender.

Hey Exile, I think that starting a "Bisexuality for Dummies" thread is looking really tempting again.


Part of the difficulty with this perception is the extent to which media makes *visibly* bisexual characters to be very sexual and very open in their pursuit of sex. The IB (as cool as he seems) falls into this trope too.

It really is pretty tempting. I kind of want to hold up a sign that says "we're all different!!" because, you know, we are all different. My ex-gf couldn't be monogamous for a number of reasons, one of which was that being with just one gender was really difficult for her. It's very YMMV

#667
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

It means that the lack of general homophobia in a cultural sense does not mean there is not still the possibility of homophobia in the individual. Thedas does not lack for bigots, sexists, and generally disagreeable people who could potentially take "that's kind of weird" to new and exciting levels.


What are your views on portraying such people in Thedas in a DA game? If they exist, on the one hand, we should see them. On the other hand, I kind of don't want to deal with this BS in my gaming. It's bad enough dealing with the occasional attention at a restaurant.
  • karushna5 aime ceci

#668
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 292 messages

What are your views on portraying such people in Thedas in a DA game? If they exist, on the one hand, we should see them. On the other hand, I kind of don't want to deal with this BS in my gaming. It's bad enough dealing with the occasional attention at a restaurant.

well there was Gamlen



#669
Hellion Rex

Hellion Rex
  • Members
  • 30 037 messages

well there was Gamlen

I think we can all agree he was just a scumbag all around.



#670
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 292 messages

I think we can all agree he was just a scumbag all around.

Aye he's a piece of work

 

He had his moments of almost sympathy, but then he Gamlened it all up



#671
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Gamlen is not homophobic, though. He hates all people equally. He's better than most of us. 


  • leadintea et Dark Helmet aiment ceci

#672
Grieving Natashina

Grieving Natashina
  • Members
  • 14 554 messages

Gamlen is not homophobic, though. He hates all people equally. 

I agree with this part.  Gamlen not necessarily homophobic, or any kind of phobic really.  He's just an a**hole.



#673
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 292 messages

I agree with this part.  Gamlen not necessarily homophobic, or any kind of phobic really.  He's just an a**hole.

Does soapaphobic count?



#674
DaySeeker

DaySeeker
  • Members
  • 522 messages

Normal in that typically bisexual people have a preference for one or the other, yet can sustain long term relationships with either.

 

Not quite true.  Bisexual men most often will limit their interactions with men to only sex and form relationships with women says statistics.



#675
Grieving Natashina

Grieving Natashina
  • Members
  • 14 554 messages

Does soapaphobic count?

That's....not even a word.   Unless you mean a fear of those that follow Sapphos, but even then that doesn't work. 

 

The only phobia that would make sense for Gamlen in Ablutophobia, the fear of bathing.  Still, we're probably stretching it more than a bit here.  Like i said, he doesn't appear to really be phobic.  He's just a jerkass that is probably giving Hawke grief because Hawke made it good and Gamlen still stuck in his hut in Lowtown that smells like old cabbage.  Jealousy plus being naturally being caustic= him looking for any excuse to insult Hawke.