Aller au contenu

Photo

Homosexuality in Thedas


1071 réponses à ce sujet

#1051
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 400 messages

I brought him along after Rivalmancing him, and I got no such dialogue (as I recall) and I'm pretty sure Legacy doesn't understand the difference between during and after Act 3 (Anders is fretting over Meredith, and i don't think he's worried she's coming back to life)

 

Ah pity =/



#1052
X Equestris

X Equestris
  • Members
  • 2 521 messages

To me the most obvious example of marrying for love is Aveline and Donnic. She, his SUPERIOR, even takes his last name. :rolleyes:

I don't recall anything about her taking Donnic's last name. Vallen was Wesley's surname.

There is a codex entry that could be construed that way, but the Codex does typically refer to characters by first name and omits their surname.

#1053
vertigomez

vertigomez
  • Members
  • 5 279 messages
About Sebastian- friendmance with female Hawke results in the chaste marriage. Rivalmance with female Hawke (well, if you become Viscountess) results in a political engagement at the endgame. He says that he'll offer Hawke no less than a Prince, and says, "the Prince of Starkhaven and the Viscountess of Kirkwall? It would be the strongest alliance the Free Marches has ever seen."

#1054
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

Nope, I didn't make it up.  I don't see how it is biphobic.  I also don't see how one bisexual man on this thread would be able to speak for all bisexuals, but there it is.  There was a flurry of activity on bisexual erasure I was reading about, and this was part of it.  I don't see why it would be so hard to believe; it is easier and more socially acceptable to be in a heterosexual relationship, there are way more possibilities to do so.  Hetero relationships also allow marriage in every state and the ability to procreate.  

Bisexual men exist outside the United States. They exist, for example, in places like Canada, where we could marry other men and adopt children. It's arguable whether a same-sex relationship is any less socially acceptable here. 



#1055
Nightdragon8

Nightdragon8
  • Members
  • 2 734 messages

I think its more based on social status. As for king's and queens the need to produce an Heir is paramount. The same with I would assume Nobles. As for the common folk I would say its not that big of an issue, but I'm sure more parents would want to see grandchildren.



#1056
Steelcan

Steelcan
  • Members
  • 23 279 messages

I think its more based on social status. As for king's and queens the need to produce an Heir is paramount. The same with I would assume Nobles. As for the common folk I would say its not that big of an issue, but I'm sure more parents would want to see grandchildren.

gotta have someone to work the fields while you grow old into your 30's


  • Drasanil, Riverdaleswhiteflash, Lebanese Dude et 1 autre aiment ceci

#1057
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 688 messages

My point was that some of their base has grown enough to be represented, even though they're the minority and that trying include every minority might turn off the majority of their base. There's only so much minority representation the market as a whole will (grudgingly) accept.

 

I'm sorry you can't play the way you wish to. It sucks not being able to fully roleplay the way you want. :( I think Sebastian was the closest thing to your stated preference but he wanted a sexless marriage entirely, not just to wait until after marriage so I guess it's really not suitable to your needs any more than the rest. Unfortunately, it's not common enough for Bioware to see a need to include it.

Story of my life as a Bioware fan. 

 

And yeah, I understand why they do or do not have certain things like more orientations or lifestyle choices, but it hurts just the same. 



#1058
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 912 messages

My point was that some of their base has grown enough to be represented, even though they're the minority and that trying include every minority might turn off the majority of their base. There's only so much minority representation the market as a whole will (grudgingly) accept.

 

I'm sorry you can't play the way you wish to. It sucks not being able to fully roleplay the way you want. :( I think Sebastian was the closest thing to your stated preference but he wanted a sexless marriage entirely, not just to wait until after marriage so I guess it's really not suitable to your needs any more than the rest. Unfortunately, it's not common enough for Bioware to see a need to include it.

Is it specifically stated that "chaste" means "sexless?" Because according to the original definition (which the Chantry's closest irl counterpart still uses) "chaste" means "sexually proper," which doesn't necessarily mean that there's no sex happening at all considering that the two are married to each other. Nor does a marriage in which there's no sex happening make any sense according to the Word Of Gaider I previously linked to that says marriages are specifically meant as something that produces children. (Which is also pretty close to the Catholic Church's doctrine.)



#1059
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 914 messages

Is it specifically stated that "chaste" means "sexless?" Because according to the original definition (which the Chantry's closest irl counterpart still uses) "chaste" means "sexually proper," which doesn't necessarily mean that there's no sex happening at all considering that the two are married to each other.

what defines "proper"?

#1060
Lebanese Dude

Lebanese Dude
  • Members
  • 5 545 messages

what defines "proper"?

 

Missionary :P



#1061
Grieving Natashina

Grieving Natashina
  • Members
  • 14 488 messages

what defines "proper"?

It probably means that they are married,  and have sex only with the intent of having children.  Sex for fun was very frowned upon, though I have my doubts Thedas is the same way.

 

That's my guess.  <shrug>



#1062
raging_monkey

raging_monkey
  • Members
  • 22 914 messages

Missionary :P

ah boring but gets the job done i guess

#1063
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Is it specifically stated that "chaste" means "sexless?" Because according to the original definition (which the Chantry's closest irl counterpart still uses) "chaste" means "sexually proper," which doesn't necessarily mean that there's no sex happening at all considering that the two are married to each other. Nor does a marriage in which there's no sex happening make any sense according to the Word Of Gaider I previously linked to that says marriages are specifically meant as something that produces children. (Which is also pretty close to the Catholic Church's doctrine.)

Sebastian took vows, I believe.There is no sex period. Besides, the way Carver talks about it, it sounds like more than just only having sex the "proper" way. 



#1064
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 912 messages

what defines "proper"?

As far as the Chantry goes, I'm not sure. I'm going to guess that it means that it only happens between man and wife, which is part of the definition of its irl counterpart. (The irl counterpart forbids any contraceptive measure apart from just not having sex while the woman has an ova in the right place to cause pregnancy, which might or might not also be part of the Chantry's teachings.)

 

Sebastian took vows, I believe.There is no sex period. Besides, the way Carver talks about it, it sounds like more than just only having sex the "proper" way. 

That doesn't seem to make sense in the context of the Chantry's teachings on the purpose of marriage as Gaider describes it, but fair enough. (Edit: Though on the other hand, now that I've actually looked up Carver's dialogue it seems like Carver's aware of the discrepancy too.)



#1065
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

Sebastian took vows, I believe.There is no sex period. Besides, the way Carver talks about it, it sounds like more than just only having sex the "proper" way. 

Wait so Templar vows include not having sex? Then why on earth would Aveline have a Templar husband?



#1066
Grieving Natashina

Grieving Natashina
  • Members
  • 14 488 messages

Wait so Templar vows include not having sex? Then why on earth would Aveline have a Templar husband?

From what I can gather it's "no sex outside of marriage," not that they can't have sex at all. 



#1067
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Sebastian isn't a Templar, though.


  • Hellion Rex et AresKeith aiment ceci

#1068
Hellion Rex

Hellion Rex
  • Members
  • 30 036 messages

Sebastian isn't a Templar, though.

I agree. Being a Chantry priest comes with a completely different set of values versus Templars. I'd imagine sex isn't banned to Templars, I merely think they are advised to be more conservative about it.


  • AresKeith aime ceci

#1069
Riverdaleswhiteflash

Riverdaleswhiteflash
  • Members
  • 7 912 messages

Wait so Templar vows include not having sex? Then why on earth would Aveline have a Templar husband?

As Br3admax points out, Sebastian isn't a Templar. However, I did want to ask why Hawke would have a brother husband if brothers weren't allowed to have sex.



#1070
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

Apparently, Sebastian is just that great of a person, from what I've seen of the Friendmance. Rivalmance Hawke convinces him to go back to Starkhaven as Prince and renounce his vows. But they don't sleep with each other because they need to be married first for Sebastian to be happy. 



#1071
LukaCrosszeria

LukaCrosszeria
  • Members
  • 1 304 messages

So what I'm saying is, if Thedas doesn't have that immense history of misogyny the way we do, would marriage have evolved as something that represents commitment between two equals... and not just a baby factory for a powerful man?

 

Because if so we would see husbands and husbands / wives and wives on Thedas, and we don't :(

 

I got the impression marriage in Ferelden and the Free Marches is expected to be between a woman and a man. Doesn't mean it can't be a commitment between equals though.

 

I would say that from what we've seen so far of society in Dragon Age, that it has a ways to go before same-sex marriages can come into play.



#1072
vertigomez

vertigomez
  • Members
  • 5 279 messages

I agree. Being a Chantry priest comes with a completely different set of values versus Templars. I'd imagine sex isn't banned to Templars, I merely think they are advised to be more conservative about it.


Yeah, I've never seen anything that indicates Templars aren't supposed to have sex - they apparently frequent brothels a lot. I think they're just not supposed to have sex with their charges and possibly there are rules against fraternization, which limits their options.

I can see why marriage might be discouraged but not forbidden. The Chantry doesn't want you to have split loyalties, and a spouse complicates things.